Worked example · English · Year 11
LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Purpose
A secure Year 11 response from a pupil arguing against the bypass route, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. The two speeches are written out in full so you can hear the difference; in the lesson pupils speak from key words. Pupils arguing for the bypass would use the traffic, safety, air quality, jobs and business figures instead. Check that figures match the fact sheet: 9,200 vehicles a day; 780 lorries; about 6,500 vehicles (7 in 10) taken off the High Street; 12 minutes now, 3 minutes by bypass; 11 collisions in 5 years, 4 involving people on foot; 38 days of high fumes; 110 jobs for 2 years; 41 of 70 businesses in support; 9 of 62 hectares lost; 6 pairs of curlew; 45 homes; 10,000 tonnes of carbon; 12% more traffic within 10 years; £41 million against £3 million. Show this after pupils have tried the steps themselves.
Position: The High Street needs fixing, but this route destroys the reserve and there is a cheaper, faster answer.
| Section | Key words |
|---|---|
| 1. Address and position | Chair, members. Oppose route as planned. |
| 2. Point 1 and evidence | Problem real: 9,200 a day, 780 lorries. BUT reserve: 9 of 62 ha, split in 2, 6 pairs curlew. |
| 3. Point 2 and evidence | Sponge. 45 homes Heol y Felin. |
| 4. Counter-argument and rebuttal | “Cuts traffic.” Short term. Own consultants: +12% in 10 years. |
| 5. Request | £3m not £41m. Weight limit, 20 mph, 2 crossings. Oppose, back package. |
Key words only, in a clear order: position, two points each with a figure, a rebuttal, then a request. The pupil admits the other side has a real problem before arguing, which shows respect. Evidences criteria 1 and 4.
Chair, members of the committee, thank you. I am asking you to oppose the Aberllydan bypass as it is currently planned.
I do not dispute that the High Street has a problem. 9,200 vehicles a day, 780 of them lorries, is too many for a street with a primary school on it. But this route is the wrong answer.
First, the damage to the reserve would be permanent. The embankment would take 9 of Cors Llydan’s 62 hectares and split what remains in two. The 6 pairs of curlew that nest there need wide, quiet, open fields. A road through the middle is exactly what they cannot live with.
Second, the reserve protects homes. In heavy rain it holds water that would otherwise reach Heol y Felin, and the Trust warns that 45 homes could flood more often.
Supporters say the bypass will cut traffic. In the short term, it will. But your own consultants predict that traffic in the area will rise by 12% within 10 years.
For £3 million, not £41 million, a weight limit, a 20 mph zone and 2 new crossings would make the High Street safer within a year. I ask you to oppose this route and support that package instead. Thank you.
Formal register (“I do not dispute”, “as it is currently planned”). Signposts (“First”, “Second”) let busy councillors follow the argument. Every point has a figure, the counter-argument is answered with the council’s own evidence, and it ends with a clear request. Evidences criterion 1.
| Feature | Council version | Year 7 version |
|---|---|---|
| Register | Formal, polite, impersonal: “I ask the committee...” | Friendly and direct: “you”, “we”, contractions, but no slang. |
| Vocabulary | embankment; habitat; flood risk | a big bank of earth; the place where the birds live; a giant sponge |
| Structure | Position first, then two points, rebuttal, request. | Hook with a question first, explain what a bypass is, one story about the curlews, then the vote. |
| Examples | Figures: 9 of 62 hectares, 45 homes, 12%, £41m against £3m. | Only 2 figures, turned into pictures: about 12 football pitches; more than 30 lorries an hour. Pond dipping. |
| How I say it | Steady pace, calm, look at each councillor. | More energy, pauses after questions, smile, look across the whole hall. |
| Last line | Oppose this route and support the package. | On Friday, vote against the bypass. |
Every row changes something specific. The pupil keeps the same side and purpose but changes the register, the words, the order and the examples to suit 11-year-olds, and knows what this audience can actually do (vote on Friday). Evidences criterion 2.
Morning, Year 7. Quick question: hands up if you walked along the High Street to get here today. Keep your hand up if a lorry has ever roared past so close you felt the wind. Yes. Me too. There are more than 30 lorries an hour on that street.
So I understand why some people want a bypass: a new road round the edge of town, so the traffic misses the High Street. Sounds great. But here’s the catch. The road would go straight through Cors Llydan, the wetland reserve. Most of you went pond dipping there in primary school.
The road would cover a piece of it about the size of 12 football pitches and cut the rest in half. Curlews nest there: big brown birds with long curved beaks. They need wide, quiet fields. Put a road through the middle, and they’re gone.
And the reserve works like a giant sponge. When it pours, it soaks up the rain. Build a road across it, and houses on Heol y Felin could flood more often.
There is a cheaper way to fix the High Street: fewer lorries, slower cars, safer crossings. On Friday you vote in form time. Think of the curlews, and vote against the bypass. Thanks for listening.
Direct address and a hands-up question hook the audience. Hard words are explained (“a new road round the edge of town”), figures become pictures, and the image of the sponge replaces “flood risk”. The ending tells Year 7 exactly what to do. Evidences criterion 2.
| What to listen for | What I heard |
|---|---|
| Speaker and side | Tomos, FOR the bypass. |
| A phrase that suited the councillors | “The evidence from the school gate is clear: 38 days above your own target.” |
| A phrase that suited Year 7 | “Imagine your little brother or sister breathing lorry fumes every morning.” |
| How the register changed | From “I urge the committee” to “You know that smell on the High Street?” |
| Vocabulary, structure, examples | “Nitrogen dioxide” became “dirty air from exhausts”. He started with the story of his walk to school instead of the collision figures. |
| Speech 1: card and response | UNCONVINCED at 40 seconds. He gave the figure: 6,500 vehicles a day off the High Street, about 7 in 10. |
| Speech 2: card and response | BORED at 30 seconds. He stopped, lowered his voice and asked, “Who here has ever waited ages to cross that road?” |
| Did it work? | Yes. The figure was exactly what a councillor wants, and the question woke up the audience. He ran 10 seconds over in speech 2, so he needs to cut a point when he adds one. |
The observer quotes exact words, names what changed and judges whether each response to a card worked. This is the evidence that the speaker adapted to how listeners reacted. Evidences criterion 3.
The strongest point I heard from the other side was Tomos’s: fumes were above the target outside the primary school on 38 days last year. It is persuasive because it is about young children’s health, and it is a figure from the council’s own monitoring, not an opinion. However, it does not take into account how long the bypass would take. Building it would take 2 years, so children would breathe those fumes for 2 more years at least, and 3 in 10 vehicles would still use the High Street afterwards. A weight limit would remove the through lorries within a year for a fraction of the cost. So my answer is that I share Tomos’s worry, but the package protects those children sooner than his road would.
The pupil picks the other side’s best point, not its weakest, and says fairly why it is strong. Then the pupil tests it against other facts (2 years to build, 3 in 10 vehicles remain) and gives a reasoned answer, with respect for the speaker. Evidences criteria 4 and 5.
For the council I used a formal register and 5 figures. For Year 7 I cut down to 2 figures and turned them into pictures, such as “about the size of 12 football pitches”, and I opened with a hands-up question instead of my position. In the council speech I was shown CONFUSED when I said “embankment”, so I slowed down and said “a raised bank of earth, as high as a house”, and the card went down. My observer noticed that I looked at my cue card much less in the Year 7 version and sounded more natural, which I had not realised. In Step 5 I answered the best point from the other side, but I could have been stronger by asking how the council would pay the £41 million.
About 120 words. The pupil names exact changes, describes one reaction and the adaptation it caused, uses the observer’s view, and sets a realistic target. Evidences criteria 2, 3 and 5.