Worked example · PSE / Well-being · Year 8

Agreeing a plan for a well-being afternoon

LNF: Literacy → Listening → Listening as part of collaborative talk

What this is

A model of a group reaching agreement, with a secure Year 8 plan and listening log, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. Many plans are valid. A plan is correct if it has exactly 3 activities, costs £300 or less, and includes at least one active and one calm activity. The key idea: the group changes its plan because people listened, not because the loudest person won.

A strong moment from Step 4 (transcript)

Jac: I want the climbing wall, dodgeball and board games. Climbing is the most exciting thing on the list, and £250 plus £0 plus £40 is £290, so it fits.

Seren (questioner): I agree it is exciting, but what would happen to everyone else? It says only 20 pupils can climb in 40 minutes, and each group has 40 pupils.

Jac: Oh. So half of each group would just watch. That is not fair.

Harri: Building on what Seren said, the mural lets everyone take part, and 50 people voted for something creative.

Lili (summariser): So far we agree on dodgeball for active, and we are moving away from climbing. We still disagree about the calm activity: yoga or board games.

Seren agrees and then questions the result of Jac’s idea; Jac responds by changing his mind; Harri builds on Seren with evidence from the vote; Lili sums up agreement and disagreement. Evidences criteria 1, 2 and 3.

Step 5: the group plan

SessionActivityCost
1B: Dodgeball tournament£0
2C: Mural painting with a local artist£150
3A: Yoga and breathing£120
Total£270

Checks: active (B, and A) ✓ calm (A) ✓ the plan covers “something active” (70 votes), “time with friends” (64), “something creative” (50) and “something calm” (36) ✓

What we gave up: Jac gave up the climbing wall because not everyone could take part. Lili wanted board games as the calm activity; she agreed to yoga because it is both calm and active, as long as pupils can just do the breathing if they feel self-conscious.

The plan meets every rule, uses the vote as evidence, and records what each person gave up, which shows a genuine compromise. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 6: listening log and reflection (Jac)

What someone saidHow I responded
Seren: “What would happen to everyone else? Only 20 pupils can climb.”I agreed it was not fair and dropped the climbing wall.
Lili: “Some people hate doing yoga in front of others.”I asked, “What if people could just do the breathing part?” and she agreed.

(b) My top 3 changed. I only thought about what was exciting for me, but Seren made me see that half of every group would be left watching. I also noticed that the mural stays on the wall, so it lasts longer than one afternoon.

(c) 4 out of 5. We all responded before adding new points, but we talked over each other once. Next time the chair should stop us sooner.

The log records other people’s exact points and the pupil’s own responses, including a “what if” question that solved a disagreement. The reflection explains how listening changed the pupil’s view. Evidences criteria 1, 3 and 4.

If you finish early: ideas

Why this response is secure