Worked example · Science · Year 9

Analysing an article on antibiotic resistance

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

What this is

A secure Year 9 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key and mark guide. Step 3 answers in order: fact, opinion, fact, misleading claim, fact, opinion, misleading claim, opinion. Marks: Step 2 out of 10, Step 3 out of 12, Step 6 out of 12, Step 7 out of 5. The key idea: Text A is persuasive but built on accurate science and an expert voice, whereas Text B sounds confident but is selling something and contradicts the science. Watch for one common science error: it is the bacteria that become resistant, not the person’s body.

Step 2: find and infer

(a) She is a GP in Bangor. (1)

(b) Colds and flu are caused by viruses. (1)

(c) Mair had MRSA, which is resistant to several widely used antibiotics, so the usual tablets did not work. (1)

(d) Taking antibiotics for colds or flu; stopping a course early or saving tablets for later; using more antibiotics than needed in farming. (3) Also accept: sharing antibiotics.

(e) Osian used to think he could stop taking antibiotics whenever he wanted, but now he takes them exactly as the doctor or pharmacist says. Seeing his Nain become seriously ill with a resistant infection probably made him take it seriously. (1 for the change, 1 for the cause)

(f) She is frightened and worried. She says patients like Mrs Hughes are “the reason I lose sleep”. (1 for the feeling, 1 for the quotation; “the most frightening thing” is also correct)

Retrieval answers are precise and in full sentences; the inferences go beyond the words and are backed by a quotation. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: fact, opinion or misleading claim

TextStatementAnswer
A“antibiotics do not work on viruses”Fact
A“the most frightening thing I see in my job”Opinion
A“Alexander Fleming discovered penicillin in 1928”Fact
B“Knocks a cold out in 2 days, every time!”Misleading claim
A“some can divide every 20 minutes”Fact
B“the best thing I’ve ever done for my health”Opinion
B“kills 99.9% of viruses AND bad bacteria”Misleading claim
A“sleepwalking towards a world where a scratched knee could kill”Opinion (a warning about the future)

Highlighting Text B: the only facts are in the pharmacist’s reply (colds are caused by viruses; antibiotics do not work on viruses; most colds get better on their own in about a week). Everything Ffion and llinos_88 write is opinion, personal story or misleading claim.

(b) Colds are caused by viruses, and antibiotics only kill bacteria or stop them growing, so they cannot cure a cold. Most colds get better on their own in about a week, so Ffion would have recovered anyway and wrongly gave the credit to the antibiotics. (2)

(c) An antibiotic cannot kill viruses, so the claim contradicts the science. Ffion also gains money from it, because the post is marked #ad and she gives a discount code, and the 99.9% figure has no source or test behind it. (2: any 2 of these reasons)

Each statement is sorted correctly, and the pupil uses accurate science to show why a claim is false, not just that it sounds wrong. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 4: how the writer persuades

TechniqueQuotationEffect on the reader
Personal story (1)“the wound turned red, hot and swollen”A real person and vivid details make the reader care before any science is explained.
One-sentence paragraph (2)“The answer was MRSA.”The short line stands out and builds shock, so the reader wants to know what MRSA is.
Expert (4)“a GP in Bangor for 18 years”Her job and experience make the reader trust the warning.
Science step by step (6)“the ordinary bacteria are killed, but the resistant ones survive”Clear cause and effect shows the reader exactly why misuse matters, so the advice feels logical, not just emotional.
Rhetorical question (9)“So what happens if nothing changes?”Makes the reader imagine the future for themselves.
Metaphor (9)“sleepwalking towards a world”Suggests we are walking into danger without noticing, which makes the reader feel they must wake up and act.

(b) Starting with Mair hooks the reader with a frightening real story. Ending with her recovery and her words “Let’s not waste them” leaves the reader with hope and a clear message to act, so the article feels complete and the advice in between is framed by a real person. (2)

Each quotation is short and exact, and every effect explains how the reader is made to think or feel, not only what the words mean. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 5: comparing the texts

Text AText B
PurposeTo inform readers about resistance and persuade them to use antibiotics responsiblyTo sell ImmunoMax drops and to entertain and gain followers
AudienceLocal newspaper readers, mostly adults and families in north WalesFfion’s followers, people interested in health and wellness
Who, and do they gain?A journalist quoting a GP; neither earns money from the adviceAn influencer paid to advertise (Sponsored, #ad, discount code)
EvidenceExpert quotations, accurate science, a real case, one estimated figurePersonal stories only, and an unsupported 99.9% figure
Reliability4: the science is accurate and an expert is quoted, but it is emotive, one-sided and the 1 in 4 figure is only one GP’s estimate1: she gains money and her claims contradict the science; only the pharmacist’s reply is reliable

(b) Text A is fairly reliable because it quotes an experienced GP and explains the science accurately, whereas Text B is unreliable because Ffion earns money from the drops and her claims contradict basic science.

Purpose and reliability are linked to who is speaking and what they gain, and the pupil sees that even the reliable text uses emotive language. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 6: a model extended answer (231 words)

The writer persuades readers through evidence that is both human and scientific. The article opens with Mair, whose wound “turned red, hot and swollen”. These vivid details turn a global problem into one family’s fear, so the reader cares before any facts are given. The writer then adds expert evidence from a GP who has worked in Bangor “for 18 years”, which makes the warning hard to dismiss.

The structure also guides the reader. The one-sentence paragraph “The answer was MRSA.” creates shock and a pause. The writer then explains natural selection in order, from mutation to the point where “the resistant ones survive”. Because the reader understands why misuse helps bacteria, the advice in paragraph 11 seems logical rather than bossy. Finally, the article returns to Mair, now walking “with a stick and a smile”, which ends on hope and suggests the problem can still be solved.

The language also makes readers feel responsible. Dr Pritchard’s metaphor “sleepwalking towards a world where a scratched knee could kill” suggests that people are walking into danger without noticing, and the exaggerated image of a small cut becoming deadly is frightening. The rhetorical question “So what happens if nothing changes?” makes readers picture that future themselves. The inclusive phrase “We all share the same bacteria” shows that one person’s choice affects everyone, so the reader is persuaded to take antibiotics exactly as prescribed.

Three PEE paragraphs, one each on evidence, structure and language. Quotations are short and built into sentences, techniques are named and every paragraph explains the effect on the reader and links back to the purpose. Evidences criteria 3 and 5.

Mark guide for Step 6 (12 marks)

10 to 12: 3 developed PEE paragraphs covering evidence, structure and language. Short quotations built into sentences. Techniques named precisely, and effects on the reader explained and linked to the writer’s purpose.

7 to 9: 3 clear PEE paragraphs with relevant quotations. Effects are explained, but sometimes in general terms such as “it makes you want to read on”.

4 to 6: 2 or 3 paragraphs with some quotations. Techniques are spotted, but the answer mostly explains what the text says rather than how it persuades.

1 to 3: Retells the article with few or no quotations and little comment on technique.

Step 7: the science in 5 sentences

  1. Bacteria are single-celled living microbes, whereas viruses are much smaller and can only reproduce inside living cells, and viruses cause colds and flu.
  2. Antibiotics kill bacteria or stop them growing, but they do not work on viruses.
  3. Random mutations make a few bacteria resistant, and when an antibiotic is used these survive and multiply while the others are killed, which is natural selection.
  4. Resistance develops faster when antibiotics are taken for viral infections, when courses are stopped early, saved or shared, and when more than needed are used in farming.
  5. Everyone should take antibiotics only when prescribed and exactly as the prescriber says, never share them and take any leftovers back to a pharmacy.

Exactly 5 sentences in the pupil’s own words, each one accurate. 1 mark per accurate sentence. Do not award sentence 3 if it says the person or the body becomes resistant. Evidences criterion 6.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure