Worked example · Art · Year 11

Asking probing questions in an art critique

LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Questioning

What this is

A secure Year 11 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It shows model rewrites for Step 1, part of a model Round 1 critique on Macsen’s card, a completed Recorder log, and a model summary and evaluation. Rewrites and questions will vary: accept any that are open, fit the card and match the rung. Look for Recorder logs where all 4 rungs appear and the summary covers intention, problem and next step. Practice only, not NEA work.

Step 1: closed to open

Closed questionOpen rewriteRung
Do you like your painting?Which part of the painting works best for your intention, and why?2
Is that plaster?Can you tell me more about how you made the cast of your taid’s hand?1
Did you use white on purpose?Why did you choose white thread, and how does it connect to the idea of change?2
Is it finished?Some viewers might say the series already works without the unfinished lino print. How would you answer them?3
Would colour be better?What would happen if you stitched just one layer in a stronger colour?4

Every rewrite starts with how, why, what or which, or invites a view, so it cannot be answered with yes or no. Each links to a specific card. Evidences criteria 2 and 5.

A model critique: Round 1, Macsen’s card

Artist (as Macsen): My project is “Working Hands”. I wanted to show what physical jobs leave on people’s hands, starting with my family. I have biro studies, a plaster cast of Taid’s hand and an A1 painting of Mam scrubbing up at a hospital sink.

Questioner: Can you tell me more about what you mean by “what jobs leave on hands”? [Rung 1, clarify]

Artist: The scars, the dry skin, the way Taid’s fingers are bent from years of work. Hands tell a life story.

Questioner: You said a life story. Why did you choose to crop Mam’s painting so close, and how does that tell her story? [Rung 2, probe, with a follow-up using the Artist’s words]

Artist: Cropping close means you only see the hands and the soap, not her face, so it’s about the work, not about who she is.

Questioner: Some viewers might say the painting looks flat next to your drawings. Is there a risk that it weakens the series? [Rung 3, challenge]

Artist: Yes, I know. The skin went muddy when I blended. But I think the size makes up for it: it’s the only piece you see from across the room.

Questioner: What made the drawings feel so alive, and have you considered using that same cross-hatching on top of the painting, instead of blending? [Rung 2 then 4, probe then suggest]

Artist: The drawings are built from lines, not blends. Hatching over the acrylic with a fine brush could fix the flatness without starting again. That would fit my 3 weeks.

Recorder: So you are saying your intention is to show hands as a record of work; the painting’s problem is muddy blending; and you plan to hatch over it with a fine brush rather than restart. Is that right?

Artist: Yes, and I would add that it keeps the painting linked to the drawings.

The Artist stays in role, defends the size of the painting when challenged and concedes the problem without giving up the point of view (criterion 1). The Questioner climbs all 4 rungs and builds on the answers (criteria 2 and 5). The Recorder summarises accurately and checks it with the Artist (criterion 3).

Step 3: Recorder log for that round

Question askedRungOpen or closedKey point in the answer
What do you mean by what jobs leave on hands?1openScars, dry skin, bent fingers: hands tell a life story.
Why crop Mam’s painting so close?2openShows the work, not the person.
Does the flat painting weaken the series?3openAdmits muddy blending; argues its size gives impact.
What made the drawings feel alive?2openThey are built from lines, not blends.
Have you considered hatching over the painting?4openYes: fixes flatness, links to drawings, fits 3 weeks.

Round 1, card Macsen. Rungs used: 1 ✓ 2 ✓✓ 3 ✓ 4 ✓

Notes are short but capture the key point of each answer, and the tally shows every rung was used. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: summary and evaluation

(a) Macsen wants to show that people’s hands are a record of the physical work they do, using his mam and his taid. His drawings and cast work well, but his A1 acrylic painting looks flat because the skin tones went muddy when he blended them. He defended the painting because its size gives the series impact from a distance. He now plans to hatch over the painting with a fine brush instead of starting again, which links it to his drawings and fits the 3 weeks he has left.

(b) The most useful question was “What made the drawings feel so alive, and have you considered using that same cross-hatching on top of the painting?” It started on Rung 2 and ended on Rung 4. It was useful because it made Macsen find the answer in his own best work, so the suggestion felt like his idea, and it solved his problem and his time limit at once. The challenge question before it prepared the ground by getting him to admit the painting was flat.

The summary covers intention, problem and next step, and is fair to the Artist’s view. The evaluation explains why the question worked and how the order of questions mattered. Evidences criteria 3 and 5.

Step 5: self-assessment

Artist: Yes. Questioner: Mostly (I forgot a follow-up after my Rung 1 question). Recorder: Yes. Challenge: Yes.

Next time I will pause for 2 seconds after each answer before asking my next question, so I can pick up the artist’s exact words for a follow-up.

Honest and specific: the next step is a technique that can be practised. Evidences criteria 4 and 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure