Worked example · Science · Year 8
LNF: Numeracy → Calculation · DCF: Data and information literacy
A secure Year 8 response, annotated against the success criteria, and a full answer key for the supply teacher. Step 1: Independent = type of wrapping material; Dependent = temperature drop over 15 minutes (°C); Control = 200 cm³ water, 80.0°C start, 15 min cooling time, cardboard lid, 2 layers (6 mm). Anomaly is Beaker D Repeat 3 (29.0°C); mean with anomaly = 20.8°C (20.75°C), mean without anomaly = 18.0°C. Step 2 & Step 3: Valid means: A = 32.0°C (40.0% loss, final 48.0°C), B = 28.0°C (35.0% loss, final 52.0°C), C = 22.0°C (27.5% loss, final 58.0°C), D = 18.0°C (22.5% loss, final 62.0°C), E = 12.0°C (15.0% loss, final 68.0°C). Every valid range is 1.0°C.
| Variable type | In Class 8B’s investigation |
|---|---|
| Independent variable (what was changed between beakers) | The type of insulating wrapping material around the beaker (none, aluminium foil, corrugated cardboard, bubble wrap, sheep’s wool fleece). |
| Dependent variable (what was measured over 15 minutes, with unit) | The temperature drop of the water over 15 minutes, measured in degrees Celsius (°C). |
| Three control variables (kept the same for a fair test, with values) | 1. Volume of hot water (200 cm³). 2. Starting temperature (80.0°C). 3. Cooling time (15 minutes). (Also accept: cardboard lid fitted, 2 layers / 6 mm thickness of material, identical 250 cm³ glass beakers.) |
(b) The anomaly in Beaker D (Bubble wrap) is Repeat 3 (29.0°C), which is 11.0°C higher than the other three repeats (17.5°C, 18.5°C, 18.0°C). Leaving the cardboard lid off allowed hot air and water vapour to escape rapidly from the top of the beaker by convection and evaporation.
(c) Comparing the two mean calculations for Beaker D:
| Wrong method: including all 4 repeats (divide by 4) | Correct method: excluding Repeat 3 (divide by 3) |
|---|---|
| (17.5 + 18.5 + 29.0 + 18.0) ÷ 4 = 83.0 ÷ 4 = 20.75°C (20.8°C to 1 d.p.). This wrongly makes bubble wrap look worse by 2.8°C. | (17.5 + 18.5 + 18.0) ÷ 3 = 54.0 ÷ 3 = 18.0°C. Excluding the mistake gives a true average of the valid repeats. |
Identifies all variables with their units and quantities, explains the physical reason for the Repeat 3 outlier, and proves mathematically why dividing the 3 valid repeats by 3 is essential. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.
| Beaker & material | Repeat drops (°C) (circle any anomaly) | Working and valid mean drop (°C) | Range of valid repeats (°C) |
|---|---|---|---|
| A: No insulation | 32.5, 31.5, 32.0, 32.0 | 128.0 ÷ 4 = 32.0°C | 32.5 − 31.5 = 1.0°C |
| B: Aluminium foil | 28.0, 27.5, 28.5, 28.0 | (28.0 + 27.5 + 28.5 + 28.0) = 112.0 ÷ 4 = 28.0°C | 28.5 − 27.5 = 1.0°C |
| C: Corrugated cardboard | 22.0, 22.5, 21.5, 22.0 | (22.0 + 22.5 + 21.5 + 22.0) = 88.0 ÷ 4 = 22.0°C | 22.5 − 21.5 = 1.0°C |
| D: Bubble wrap | 17.5, 18.5, (29.0), 18.0 | (17.5 + 18.5 + 18.0) = 54.0 ÷ 3 = 18.0°C | 18.5 − 17.5 = 1.0°C |
| E: Sheep’s wool fleece | 12.0, 12.5, 11.5, 12.0 | (12.0 + 12.5 + 11.5 + 12.0) = 48.0 ÷ 4 = 12.0°C | 12.5 − 11.5 = 1.0°C |
Shows the sum and divisor for every row, excludes the 29.0°C anomaly in Beaker D from both the mean and the range, and records all values to 1 decimal place. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.
| Beaker & material | Starting temp (°C) | Valid mean drop (°C) | Final temp after 15 min (°C) | Percentage heat loss from 80.0°C (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A: No insulation | 80.0 | 32.0 | 48.0 | (32.0 ÷ 80.0) × 100 = 40.0% |
| B: Aluminium foil | 80.0 | 28.0 | 80.0 − 28.0 = 52.0 | (28.0 ÷ 80.0) × 100 = 35.0% |
| C: Corrugated cardboard | 80.0 | 22.0 | 80.0 − 22.0 = 58.0 | (22.0 ÷ 80.0) × 100 = 27.5% |
| D: Bubble wrap | 80.0 | 18.0 | 80.0 − 18.0 = 62.0 | (18.0 ÷ 80.0) × 100 = 22.5% |
| E: Sheep’s wool fleece | 80.0 | 12.0 | 80.0 − 12.0 = 68.0 | (12.0 ÷ 80.0) × 100 = 15.0% |
Subtracts each mean drop from 80.0°C and expresses each drop as a percentage of the 80.0°C starting temperature to 1 decimal place. Evidences criterion 4.
1. Rank order of insulators: From best thermal insulator (smallest temperature drop) to worst, the materials ranked: 1st Welsh sheep’s wool fleece (mean drop 12.0°C, 15.0% heat loss, final temperature 68.0°C), 2nd Bubble wrap (18.0°C, 22.5% loss), 3rd Corrugated cardboard (22.0°C, 27.5% loss), and 4th Aluminium foil (28.0°C, 35.0% loss), compared with 32.0°C (40.0% loss) for the unwrapped control beaker.
2. Why wool and bubble wrap insulated best: Sheep’s wool fleece traps millions of tiny pockets of still air between its crimped fibres, and bubble wrap traps air inside sealed plastic bubbles. Because gas particles are spread far apart, still air is a very poor thermal conductor, slowing down the rate of heat transfer by conduction through the sides of the beaker while preventing air circulating by convection.
3. Why aluminium foil performed poorly: Aluminium is a metal containing free electrons that transfer kinetic energy rapidly, making it a good thermal conductor with almost no trapped air between its thin layers. That is why the outside of the foil felt hot and the water lost 28.0°C.
4. Control beaker and anomaly: Beaker A (unwrapped control, 32.0°C drop) provided a baseline proving that every wrapping reduced heat loss to some degree. In Beaker D, Repeat 3 (29.0°C) was excluded as an anomaly because leaving the lid off allowed heat loss by evaporation and convection; excluding it corrected the mean from 20.8°C to 18.0°C.
Synthesises all five calculated means and percentages with the particle explanation of thermal conduction in metals versus trapped air pockets in insulators. Evidences criterion 5.