Worked example · Design Technology · Year 9

Checking parts against a tolerance

LNF: Numeracy → Learning about geometry helps us understand shape, space and position, and learning about measurement helps us quantify in the real world → Measurement

What this is

A secure Year 9 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Key figures: 3 bases rejected (parts 3, 5 and 9), which is 30%; slots C and E rejected; mean base length 120.2 mm (120.23 before rounding); range 1.6 mm. Nia’s holes all pass; Tomos’s holes 3 and 4 fail.

Step 2: limits

DimensionLower limit (mm)Upper limit (mm)
Base length, 120 ± 0.5119.5120.5
Base width, 60 ± 0.559.560.5
Back height, 90 ± 0.589.590.5
Slot width, 3.2 ± 0.13.13.3
Sheet thickness, 3.0 ± 0.22.83.2

The tolerance band for the base length is 120.5 − 119.5 = 1.0 mm wide.

Every limit is nominal minus and plus the tolerance. The pupil sees that ± 0.5 gives a band of 1.0 mm, not 0.5 mm. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: the batch

PartReadingLength in mmDifferenceAccept or reject?
1120.2 mm120.2+0.2Accept
2119.8 mm119.8−0.2Accept
3120.6 mm120.6+0.6Reject (too long)
412.04 cm12.04 × 10 = 120.4+0.4Accept
5119.4 mm119.4−0.6Reject (too short)
6120.0 mm120.00.0Accept
7120.5 mm120.5+0.5Accept (on the upper limit)
8120.3 mm120.3+0.3Accept
9121.0 mm121.0+1.0Reject (too long)
10120.1 mm120.1+0.1Accept

Rejected: 3 out of 10. Percentage: 3 ÷ 10 × 100 = 30%.

(b) Limits 3.1 to 3.3 mm. A 3.15 accept · B 3.30 accept (on the upper limit) · C 3.05 reject (too narrow) · D 3.22 accept · E 3.34 reject (too wide).

The centimetre reading is converted before it is judged; left as 12.04 it would look wildly wrong. Parts on a limit are accepted, as the job sheet says. Comparing 3.05 with 3.1 needs care: 3.05 is smaller than 3.10. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.

Step 4: the pattern

(a) Total: 120.2 + 119.8 + 120.6 + 120.4 + 119.4 + 120.0 + 120.5 + 120.3 + 121.0 + 120.1 = 1,202.3 mm. Mean: 1,202.3 ÷ 10 = 120.23, so 120.2 mm to 1 decimal place.

(b) Range: 121.0 − 119.4 = 1.6 mm.

(c) The laser cutter is making parts slightly too long. The mean is about 0.2 mm above 120 mm, 7 of the 10 differences are positive, and 2 of the 3 rejects are too long. The range of 1.6 mm is also wider than the 1.0 mm tolerance band, so the parts vary too much as well.

The mean is worked out from the millimetre values, rounded correctly, and used with the signs of the differences to describe a pattern. Comparing the range with the tolerance band is a strong extra point. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: datum or chain

HoleShould beNiaNia accept?TomosTomos accept?
13030.0Accept (0.0)30.5Accept (+0.5)
26060.5Accept (+0.5)61.0Accept (+1.0, on the limit)
39089.5Accept (−0.5)91.5Reject (+1.5)
4120120.5Accept (+0.5)122.0Reject (+2.0)

Tomos measured each hole from the one before, so every 0.5 mm error was added to the last one: 0.5, then 1.0, then 1.5, then 2.0 mm. By the fourth hole the errors had added up to 4 × 0.5 = 2.0 mm, twice the tolerance. Nia measured every hole from the same datum edge, so each hole only has its own small error and the errors cannot build up.

Tomos’s positions are worked out by adding 30.5 each time (30.5, 61.0, 91.5, 122.0). The explanation names the key idea: chain measuring makes errors accumulate. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 6: the quality report

I checked all 10 bases against 120 mm ± 0.5 mm. 7 passed and 3 failed, so 30% of the batch was rejected. Two of the rejects were too long (120.6 mm and 121.0 mm) and one was too short (119.4 mm). The mean length was 120.2 mm, so the laser cutter is cutting about 0.2 mm too long on average. Before the next batch, the drawing or the cutter settings should be adjusted so the parts come out about 0.2 mm shorter, and the first part should be measured before the rest are cut.

Five sentences with the pass count, the percentage, the rejects, the mean and a specific action. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.

If you finish early: answers

Worst cases: the thickest sheet (3.2 mm) will not fit the narrowest slot (3.1 mm): it is 0.1 mm too thick. The thinnest sheet (2.8 mm) in the widest slot (3.3 mm) leaves a 0.5 mm gap, so the back would wobble.

Accepted parts only: 120.2 + 119.8 + 120.4 + 120.0 + 120.5 + 120.3 + 120.1 = 841.3; 841.3 ÷ 7 = 120.19, so 120.2 mm.

45 mm ± 0.25 mm: limits 44.75 mm and 45.25 mm. 4.52 cm = 45.2 mm, so it passes.

Why this response is secure