Worked example · The Sciences · Year 10

Comparing fertilisers by percentage of nitrogen

LNF: Numeracy → Understanding the number system helps us to represent and compare relationships between numbers and quantities → Calculation

What this is

A complete, secure Year 10 answer, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Headline figures: Mr values are 80, 60 and 132; nitrogen is 35.0%, 46.7% and 21.2%; the cheapest nitrogen is urea at £1.50 per kg; the cheapest order is 11 bags of urea for £192.50. The most common mistake is counting only one N atom in ammonium nitrate: there is one in NH4 and one in NO3. Pupils who round the percentage before the next step may get answers a penny or two different; that is fine.

Step 1: counting atoms

FormulaAtomsTotalRatio
H2O2 H, 1 O3H : O = 2 : 1
CaCO31 Ca, 1 C, 3 O51 : 1 : 3
NH4NO32 N, 4 H, 3 O9N : H : O = 2 : 4 : 3
CO(NH2)21 C, 1 O, 2 N, 4 H8C : O : N : H = 1 : 1 : 2 : 4
(NH4)2SO42 N, 8 H, 1 S, 4 O15N : H : S : O = 2 : 8 : 1 : 4

The bracket in urea doubles both the N and the H2. These ratios cannot be simplified further, because the numbers in each ratio have no common factor bigger than 1. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: relative formula mass

FertiliserWorkingMr
Ammonium nitrate(2 × 14) + (4 × 1) + (3 × 16) = 28 + 4 + 4880
Urea12 + 16 + (2 × 14) + (4 × 1) = 12 + 16 + 28 + 460
Ammonium sulfate(2 × 14) + (8 × 1) + 32 + (4 × 16) = 28 + 8 + 32 + 64132

Each line groups the atoms by element before adding. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: percentage of nitrogen

FertiliserWorking% nitrogen
Ammonium nitrate28 ÷ 80 × 100 = 3535.0%
Urea28 ÷ 60 × 100 = 46.666…46.7%
Ammonium sulfate28 ÷ 132 × 100 = 21.212…21.2%

35.0 keeps the zero so that it is still 3 significant figures. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: how much does the nitrogen cost?

Fertiliserkg of N in one bagCost per kg of NRank
Ammonium nitrate25 × 0.35 = 8.75£14.00 ÷ 8.75 = £1.602
Urea25 × 28 ÷ 60 = 11.666… = 11.7£17.50 ÷ 11.666… = £1.501
Ammonium sulfate25 × 28 ÷ 132 = 5.303… = 5.30£9.00 ÷ 5.303… = £1.697… = £1.703

(b) Ammonium sulfate is only 21.2% nitrogen, so a 25 kg bag holds just 5.30 kg of nitrogen. Urea is 46.7% nitrogen, so each bag holds more than twice as much. Price per bag is not the same as price per kg of nitrogen.

Values are kept unrounded in the calculator between steps. Check: 11.666… × £1.50 = £17.50. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: the order

Fertiliserkg of fertiliser neededBagsTotal cost
Ammonium nitrate120 ÷ 0.35 = 342.9 kg342.9 ÷ 25 = 13.7, so 1414 × £14.00 = £196.00
Urea120 ÷ 0.4666… = 257.1 kg257.1 ÷ 25 = 10.3, so 1111 × £17.50 = £192.50
Ammonium sulfate120 ÷ 0.2121… = 565.7 kg565.7 ÷ 25 = 22.6, so 2323 × £9.00 = £207.00

(b) 10 bags of urea would give only 10 × 11.7 = about 117 kg of nitrogen, less than the 120 kg the field needs. The shop sells whole bags only, so any part bag means buying one more.

Check for urea: 11 bags × 11.666… kg = 128.3 kg of nitrogen, which is enough. Evidences criteria 4 and 5.

Step 6: advice for Siwan (model)

Siwan, 11 bags of urea for £192.50 is your cheapest order. It is £3.50 cheaper than 14 bags of ammonium nitrate and £14.50 cheaper than 23 bags of ammonium sulfate. However, urea can lose nitrogen as ammonia gas in warm, dry weather, so if the spring is dry, ammonium nitrate may give the grass more nitrogen for the money.

The advice uses the totals, gives the differences, and uses a fact from section 5 to explain when the cheapest answer might not be the best. It is 59 words. Evidences criterion 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure