Worked example · Design Technology · Year 9

Comparing joining methods with connectives

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Connectives and syntax

What this is

A secure Year 9 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key and a model answer. Step 1: quickest A, butt joint; strongest B, finger joint; can be taken apart D, knock-down fittings; strong, hidden and metal-free C, dowel joint. Step 2 has 4 connectives in each column. Other sensible wordings in Steps 3, 4 and 6 are fine if the connective and punctuation are correct.

Step 1: read the fact file

Quickest: A, butt joint (about 10 minutes). Strongest: B, finger joint. Can be taken apart: D, knock-down fittings. Strong, hidden and free of metal: C, dowel joint.

Finding the evidence first gives the later writing facts to use.

Step 2: sort the connectives

ContrastCauseResultAdditionCondition
however
whereas
although
on the other hand
because
since
due to
as
therefore
as a result
so
consequently
also
furthermore
in addition
as well as
if
unless
provided that
as long as

(a) however (or on the other hand) · (b) because (or since, or as) · (c) Unless

Each connective is grouped by the job it does, so the writer can choose the right one on purpose. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: build better sentences

(a) The dowel joint is hidden, but it needs very accurate drilling.

(b) The butt joint is weak because the glue is on the end grain.

(c) Although the finger joint takes about an hour, it is the strongest joint.

(d) Since the box must open for cleaning, knock-down fittings suit one side.

(e) Knock-down fittings can be taken apart, whereas a glued joint is permanent.

(f) Although the finger joint takes an hour to mark out and cut, and any slip leaves a gap, its fingers give a large gluing area that holds firm in rain and frost. It will last.

Commas follow the clauses that come first in (c) and (d), and the comma before but joins two main clauses in (a). In (f), the short sentence lands the point after a long one. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.

Step 4: improve Dylan’s answer

(a) It is a list of short sentences and fragments (“Butt joint.”) with no connectives, so the two joints are never compared directly. There is no evidence from the fact file and no reason why each point matters for a bird box.

(b) A butt joint is quick and easy to make, taking about 10 minutes a corner. However, it is the weakest joint because the glue is on the end grain, which grips poorly. A finger joint, on the other hand, is very strong since its fingers give a large gluing area, and it looks attractive. Although it takes about 60 minutes a corner, it is far more likely to stay strong outdoors. Therefore, I would use a finger joint, because a bird box must survive at least 5 years of weather.

Dylan’s ideas are kept, but contrast, cause and result connectives turn the list into a comparison, and figures from the fact file are the evidence. Evidences criteria 2, 4 and 5.

Step 5: plan

 Dowel jointKnock-down fittings
Pointstrong and neatcan be taken apart
Evidencedowels add gluing area, stop sliding; hidden; no metal; 25 min; holes must line upno glue; 15 min; can work loose; steel rusts unless coated or stainless
Justificationlasts 5 years outdoorsone side must open for cleaning

Notes, not sentences: the plan collects the facts so the timed answer can focus on linking them.

Step 6: model answer (172 words)

The dowel joint and knock-down fittings can both join the corners of the Nythfa bird box, but they suit different jobs. The dowel joint is strong because the glued dowels add gluing area and stop the pieces sliding. It is also hidden and has no metal to rust, so it will look neat and last the 5 years outdoors that the specification asks for. However, the holes must line up exactly, which makes it slower, at about 25 minutes a corner. Knock-down fittings, on the other hand, take about 15 minutes and can be taken apart. As a result, one side of the box could be opened each year for cleaning. Although this is a big advantage, the fittings can work loose, and steel ones will rust unless they are coated or stainless. Therefore, I recommend dowel joints for the fixed corners, because strength matters most for a box that stays outside. I would use stainless knock-down fittings only for the side that opens. Each method does the job it does best.

Connectives from all five columns organise the whole answer: contrast to compare, cause to explain, result to justify, condition to add a limit. Simple, compound and complex sentences are mixed and punctuated accurately. Each method has a point, evidence and justification, and the recommendation uses both. Evidences criteria 3, 4, 5 and 6.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure