Worked example · PE · Year 8
LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis
A secure Year 8 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Key facts: Text A is on the back page, 167 words, names 5 players with positions and quotes the captain and the other coach; Text B is on page 38, 72 words, names 1 player with no position and quotes only the coach. The women won by 19 points (31-12), the men by 7 (24-17). Text A describes skill; Text B describes family, looks and feelings.
| Text A: men’s final | Text B: women’s final | |
|---|---|---|
| Where in the paper? | Back page, top half | Page 38, bottom corner, next to the fishing results |
| Length in words | 167 | 72 |
| What the photo shows | Large colour photo of the captain lifting the cup | Small photo of players hugging |
| Final score | Pontglas 24, Aberbryn 17 | Pontglas 31, Cwmfelin 12 |
| How many players are named? | 5 (Morgan, Hughes, Evans, Bowen, Jones) | 1 (Ffion Davies) |
| Are players’ positions given? | Yes, for all 5 | No |
| Who is quoted? | The Pontglas captain and the Aberbryn coach | Only the Pontglas coach; no player |
| Does it explain how the game was won? | Yes: opening try, kicking, fightback, turnover, late try | No, only that Ffion scored a hat-trick |
The women won by more: 31 − 12 = 19 points, against 24 − 17 = 7 for the men. Missing from Text B: Ffion’s position (outside centre), her 60-metre break past four defenders, that the team scored five tries, that the scrum won every one of its own put-ins, and that the team is unbeaten this season.
Every fact is taken from the texts, and the pupil works out the winning margins to show that the bigger win got the smaller report. Evidences criterion 1.
| Skill and performance | Appearance, family or feelings | |
|---|---|---|
| Text A | powerful, disciplined, led from the front, smashed through three tackles, outstanding tactical kicking, showed their experience, crucial turnover, sniped over, clinical, outstanding | (none) |
| Text B | scored a hat-trick, showed plenty of spirit | girls, ladies, mum-of-two, trademark pink ribbon, pretty, smiles all round, didn’t mind getting their kit muddy |
Pattern: almost every describing word in Text A is about what the men did in the game. Most of the words in Text B are about the women’s families, looks or feelings, not their rugby.
The sorting is careful: “showed plenty of spirit” is about effort, so it goes under performance, but it is vague compared with Text A. Evidences criterion 2.
| Quotation | What it suggests | Effect on the reader |
|---|---|---|
| “the Pontglas girls” and “ladies” | “Girls” suggests children, even though they are adults. Text A never calls the men “boys”. “Ladies” sounds polite and old-fashioned, not sporty. | The reader may not take the team seriously as athletes. |
| “a pretty hat-trick” compared with “smashed through three tackles” | “Pretty” is a word about looks. “Smashed through” is a strong, violent verb that suggests power and strength. | The reader imagines Morgan as strong and Ffion as decorative, even though she scored three tries. |
| “before the main game” | The women’s final was just a warm-up and the men’s final was the one that mattered. | The reader is told the women’s final is less important, before they even know the score. |
Each answer focuses on a single word, explains what it suggests and links it to the reader. The first and second compare directly with Text A. Evidences criterion 3.
The Cwm Courier does not report the two finals fairly. Both Pontglas teams won, but the men’s report is on the back page and is 167 words long, whereas the women’s report is only 72 words on page 38. Text A describes skill, for example the captain “smashed through three tackles”. In contrast, Text B describes Ffion Davies as a “mum-of-two” with a “pink ribbon” and calls her hat-trick “pretty”, which makes her sound decorative instead of powerful. Text B also calls adult players “girls” and says the men’s match was “the main game”, which suggests the women’s final did not really matter. However, the women won by more points, 31-12. Text C shows what was left out: a 60-metre break, five tries and an unbeaten season. The Courier clearly treats the men as athletes and the women as a side show.
142 words. A clear point first, six short quotations, facts from Step 2, comparison words (both, whereas, in contrast, however) and a judgement supported by Text C. Evidences criteria 4 and 5.
Headline: DAVIES HAT-TRICK POWERS PONTGLAS TO CUP GLORY
Pontglas Women produced a powerful, attacking display to beat Cwmfelin 31-12 in the women’s final of the Cwm Eirin Cup at Parc y Bont on Saturday. Outside centre Ffion Davies led the way with a hat-trick, including a 60-metre break that beat four defenders. The Pontglas scrum won every one of its own put-ins, and the side stayed unbeaten this season with five tries in the final.
The rewrite copies the structure of Text A: a strong headline, the score and place first, then named players with positions and what they did. Every fact comes from Text C, and nothing is about appearance or family. Evidences criterion 5.
167 ÷ 72 = 2.319…, so Text A is about 2.3 times as long as Text B.
A new player might feel that girls’ rugby is not taken seriously, because the paper talked about ribbons instead of tries. She might think that no matter how well she plays, she will not be noticed. On the other hand, a report like the rewrite, with a named player doing something skilful, could give her a local role model.
Caption: “Hat-trick hero Ffion Davies breaks through the Cwmfelin defence.” (This would also need an action photo.)