Worked example · PSE / Well-being · Year 11

Comparing the cost of borrowing for a laptop

LNF: Numeracy → Understanding the number system helps us to represent and compare relationships between numbers and quantities → Financial literacy

What this is

A secure Year 11 response and full answer key, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. The key figures: store credit costs £779.04 (£179.04 extra); rent to own costs £1,013.22 (£413.22 extra); unpaid credit card debt grows to £760.95 in 12 months, a real yearly rate of 26.8%. Recommendations can differ if they are justified with numbers and affordability.

Step 2: total cost

OptionTotal paidCost of creditExtra as a %
A12 × £50 = £600.00£00%
B3 × £200 = £600.00£00%
C24 × £32.46 = £779.04£179.04179.04 ÷ 600 × 100 = 29.8%
E78 × £12.99 = £1,013.22£413.2268.9%

Each total is found by multiplying the payment by the number of payments, then compared with the £600 price. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: compound interest

Month0123612
Balance£600.00£612.00£624.24£636.72£675.70£760.95

(a) 24% of £600 would be £144, giving £744. The real balance is £760.95, which is £160.95 more than £600, or 26.8%. It is more than 24% because each month the 2% is charged on the interest already added, not just on the £600.

The multiplier 1.02 and the power key give an efficient method, and the pupil explains why compound interest beats simple interest. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 4: comparing rates

(a) 1.0212 = 1.268…, so the card really charges about 26.8% a year.

(b) The store credit (29.9% APR) has the higher yearly rate. But it has a fixed payment of £32.46 and a fixed end date, so you know exactly what you will pay. With a credit card, it is easy to pay only the minimum and stay in debt for much longer.

Rates are converted to the same basis (per year) before comparing, and the pupil weighs certainty as well as cost. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.

Step 5: risks

(a) £600 + 2 × £12 = £624. The missed payments may also go on the credit file, making it harder or more expensive to borrow later, for example for a phone contract or a car.

OptionAdvantageDisadvantage
ACheapest; no debt at allMust wait 12 months
BLaptop now, no interestLarge payments of £200; fees and credit file damage if missed
CSmall, fixed paymentsCosts £179.04 extra
DFlexible; cheap if paid off quicklyCompound interest grows fast if you pay only the minimum
ELaptop now; small weekly paymentsMost expensive: £413.22 extra; not yours until the end

Every option is judged on risk as well as cost. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 6: recommendations

Nia: option C. She needs the laptop in 2 weeks, so she cannot save up. She cannot afford option B, because £200 a month is more than her £90 spare. Option C costs £32.46 a month, well within £90, although it costs £179.04 extra. Option E is also affordable (about £56 a month) but costs £413.22 extra, so C is better. She should also ask her college whether it can help with a laptop.

Dylan: option A. He does not need the laptop for 12 months and is only 17, so he cannot get credit anyway. Saving £150 a month, he could buy it in 600 ÷ 150 = 4 months, paying just £600 with no risk.

Alys: option B. She needs it now and has £250 a month spare, so she can afford 3 payments of £200 and pay no interest at all: £600 in total. The risk is a £12 fee for a missed payment, so she should set up automatic payments.

Each recommendation checks affordability against the person’s budget, compares cost with at least one alternative, and considers the person’s timing and age. An accepted alternative for Nia: option D, if she pays £90 every month, clears the debt in about 8 months for about £51 of interest; a strong answer would add that this only works if she never pays just the minimum. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure