Worked example · MFL · Year 9

Comparing Transport Carbon Footprints and Timetables in French

LNF: Numeracy → Learning that statistics represent data and that probability models chance helps us make informed inferences and decisions → Interpreting data · DCF: Data and computational thinking → Data and information literacy

What this is

A complete Year 9 answer key and model response annotated against the success criteria. Key figures: Option A 12 h 30 min, 1,260 kg CO2, £90.00/pupil (£2,700.00); Option B 6 h 15 min, 540 kg CO2, £130.00/pupil (£3,900.00); Option C 1 h 30 min flight (4 h 30 min door to door), 5,940 kg CO2, £150.00/pupil (£4,500.00). Share this after pupils have completed their own work.

Step 1: calculate journey durations across the 1-hour time-zone change

Transport option Departs Cardiff (GMT) Arrives Paris (CET) Arrives Paris in GMT (−1 h) Travel duration Door-to-door duration
A: Le car et le ferry 06:00 19:30 18:30 12 h 30 min 12 h 30 min
B: Le train et l’Eurostar 07:15 14:30 13:30 6 h 15 min 6 h 15 min (check-in included)
C: L’avion 10:20 12:50 11:50 1 h 30 min 4 h 30 min (1 h 30 min + 3 h transfers)

Time-zone mistake explained: If a pupil forgot to subtract 1 hour for the GMT to CET time-zone change, they would calculate the train journey from 07:15 to 14:30 as 7 hours 15 minutes, overestimating the journey by a whole hour.

Converts all Paris CET arrival times into UK GMT before subtracting departure times, and adds the 3-hour transfer and check-in time for the flight. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: calculate CO2 emissions and ticket costs for 30 pupils

Option CO2 per pupil (kg) Total CO2 for 30 pupils (kg) Price per pupil (€) Price per pupil (£) Total cost for 30 pupils (£)
A: Coach + Ferry 42 kg 1,260 kg 108 € £90.00 £2,700.00
B: Train + Eurostar 18 kg 540 kg 156 € £130.00 £3,900.00
C: Plane 198 kg 5,940 kg 180 € £150.00 £4,500.00

Multiplies by 30 accurately and divides euro prices by the 1.20 exchange rate (108 ÷ 1.20 = £90.00; 156 ÷ 1.20 = £130.00; 180 ÷ 1.20 = £150.00). Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: interpret the data against the school’s rules

  1. The plane emits 11 times as much CO2 as the train (198 ÷ 18 = 11). Across the group of 30 pupils, flying produces 5,400 kg more CO2 than taking the train (5,940 kg − 540 kg = 5,400 kg).
  2. Option C (Plane) breaks both rules: at £150.00 per pupil it exceeds the £135.00 budget cap by £15.00, and at 5,940 kg it is nearly four times the 1,500 kg CO2 cap. Both Option A and Option B meet the school rules, but Option B (Train + Eurostar) is exactly twice as fast as the coach (6 h 15 min vs 12 h 30 min) and emits less than half the CO2 (540 kg vs 1,260 kg), while staying £5.00 under the £135.00 price cap.

Uses ratios, differences and fixed constraints to compare all three options across time, cost and carbon impact. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: 4 comparative sentences in French

1. Le train est moins polluant que l’avion parce que le trajet en train produit seulement 18 kg de CO2 par élève (540 kg pour le groupe) contre 198 kg en avion (5 940 kg pour le groupe).

2. Le car est moins cher que le train parce que le billet coûte 108 € (90 £) par élève contre 156 € (130 £) en train.

3. Cependant, le train est plus rapide que le car parce que le voyage dure 6 h 15 au lieu de 12 h 30.

4. Je recommande le train et l’Eurostar parce qu’il est plus écologique que le car et moins cher que l’avion (130 £ contre 150 £).

Uses plus ... que twice, moins ... que three times, and parce que / parce qu’ in all four sentences, backed by exact figures from Steps 1 and 2. Evidences criterion 4.

If you finish early: answers

Return journey time-zone calculation: Leaving Paris at 15:45 (CET) is the same instant as leaving at 14:45 (GMT) in UK time (subtract 1 hour when moving west from CET to GMT). Adding the 6 hours 15 minutes journey duration to 14:45 (GMT) gives an arrival time in Cardiff of 21:00 (GMT).

Superlative sentence in French: Le train est le moyen de transport le plus écologique pour notre école parce qu’il produit seulement 540 kg de CO2 pour les trente élèves.

Why this response is secure