Worked example · Art · Year 10
LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis
A secure Year 10 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Step 1: the quarry pit, the slate tips and the quarrymen at work are all missing from Artwork A. Step 4: 1 F, 2 I, 3 F, 4 I, 5 F, 6 I. Steps 2, 3, 5 and 6 are open: accept other points if they are backed by details from the stimulus. Both artworks and all context are invented. Practice only, not NEA work.
Content marked: shepherd, dog, sheep, woman in a red shawl, chapel, river, oak trees; pit, slate tips, ghost trees, plastic, warning sign. Form marked: S-shaped river, red shawl as focal point, framing trees, balanced composition; flat turquoise shape, hard edges, flat yellow sky, pink line. Process marked: oil, thin glazes, varnish; screen print, separate screens, collage, misaligned layers. Mood marked: calm, peaceful, hazy, golden; loud, uneasy, urgent.
Missing from Artwork A: the quarry pit, the tips of waste slate (hidden behind the oak trees) and the 350 quarrymen and the blasting. The only worker shown is a shepherd.
Close reading of both descriptions and panels, sorted into the 4 headings. The missing things are found by comparing the painting with context panel A. Evidences criteria 1 and 3.
| A (1893) | B (2019) | |
|---|---|---|
| Content | A farming valley: “a young shepherd in a clean white smock”, sheep, a chapel, hay fields. Oak trees where the quarry was. | The “flooded quarry pit”, slate tips, a warning sign, real plastic litter. No people, no sheep. Ghost outline of the oak trees. |
| Form | Warm palette of gold and ochre; the red shawl is the focal point; the S-shaped river leads the eye; trees frame it “like the curtains of a stage”. | “Acid turquoise” flat shape with hard edges in the centre; fluorescent pink river; flat yellow sky with no depth. |
| Process | Oil paint in “thin, transparent glazes”, glossy varnish, no visible brushstrokes: a smooth, polished finish. | Screen print, one screen per colour, layers that “do not line up perfectly”; collage of plastic that casts shadows. |
| Mood | Calm, still, golden, nostalgic: a perfect summer evening. | “Loud, uneasy and urgent”: a warning. |
Each box has a quoted detail, and the notes show how form and process create the mood, for example smooth glazes suit a calm, perfect scene while misaligned layers and real litter feel raw. Evidences criteria 1 and 4.
| Question | Artwork A (1893) | Artwork B (2019) |
|---|---|---|
| Who paid? | Josiah Brereton, the quarry owner. | A community arts grant. |
| Who was it for? | His investors and guests, in his private dining room. | The village first (village hall), then gallery visitors. |
| What is left out? | The quarry, the tips, the workers and the danger. | The farming, the sheep, the people and any beauty in the valley today. |
| Why? | Brereton asked for the valley “as it ought to look”, so his guests would see a peaceful place, not the industry that made his money. | Seren wanted to “put back what was left out” and to warn people about the pit and the litter. |
The oak trees: in A they are a disguise, painted over the slate tips so the owner’s industry disappears. In B the same trees are a ghostly grey outline, so they become evidence of the cover-up: the viewer sees both the trees and what they hid.
Context is used to explain choices, not just listed. The pupil notices that Artwork B also leaves things out, which shows balanced reading. Evidences criteria 3 and 5.
1 F (context panel A). 2 I: the stimulus shows Brereton asked for it; we do not know how Hale felt. 3 F. 4 I. 5 F (context panel B). 6 I.
Evidence for statement 4: the plastic is real litter from the valley floor, it sticks out and casts shadows, and context panel B says rubbish is dumped at the edge of the pit.
Statement 2 is the trap: it sounds like a fact but guesses at a feeling the evidence does not support. Evidences criterion 2.
Hale hides the quarry completely, whereas Adeyemi-Rees makes it the centre of her print. In the 1893 painting, a “dense clump of oak trees” stands exactly where the slate tips were, and the smooth glazes and golden light create a peaceful scene. This is because the quarry owner paid for it to impress his guests and asked for the valley “as it ought to look”. In contrast, the 2019 print fills the centre with a flat, “acid turquoise” pit and prints the old oak trees as a grey ghost, exposing what Hale covered up. The real plastic and the warning sign make the mood urgent. Both artists shape the valley to suit their audience: one to reassure investors, the other to warn a community.
Point, evidence from each artwork, explanation linked to context, and 3 comparative connectives. The last sentence moves beyond difference to a shared idea: both works are shaped by purpose. About 120 words. Evidences criteria 1, 3 and 4.
I mostly agree. Seren’s print shows the quarry, the flooded pit and the litter that Hale’s painting deliberately hid under oak trees at the owner’s request, so it tells a more honest story about industry and its damage. However, it is not a neutral record either. Context panel B tells us sheep still graze the lower slopes, yet the print shows no farming and no people, and Seren admits “I have left things out too”. Both works are arguments rather than photographs, but Seren is open about her choices, while Hale’s painting pretends to be a simple, true view.
A clear position, qualified with “mostly” and “however”, supported by evidence from both artworks and both context panels. Evidences criteria 2 and 5.