Worked example · Music · Year 8

Comparing two versions of a folk song: Ar Lan y Môr

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Connectives and syntax

What this is

A secure Year 8 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Siôn uses and 8 times, but once and then once. Other sensible groupings in Step 1 and other correctly punctuated sentences in Step 2 are fine. Either version can be judged the better fit in Step 5, as long as the judgement is backed by the comparison. Builds towards GCSE Music Unit 3: Appraising.

Step 1: sort the connectives

GroupConnectives
Difference (contrast)whereas, however, in contrast, on the other hand, unlike, although
Similaritysimilarly, likewise, both
Cause and effectbecause, as a result, therefore, so, which means that
Addingalso, furthermore, in addition
Order in timeat first, later, finally

All 20 connectives are placed by what they do in a sentence. Contrast connectives are the biggest group, which is why they matter so much in a comparison. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: join the sentences

  1. Version 1 is slow, at about 66 BPM, whereas Version 2 is faster, at about 112 BPM.
  2. Version 1 is mostly quiet; as a result, it sounds calm and private.
  3. Both versions are in a major key.
  4. Version 2 has a much thicker texture because it adds drum kit, bass, electric guitar and synth.
  5. Version 2 modulates up a tone for the last verse; however, Version 1 stays in one key.
  6. Lowri Haf uses rubato, which means that she can slow down on important words.

Starting with Because: Because Version 2 adds drum kit, bass, electric guitar and synth, its texture is much thicker. The comma goes at the end of the because part.

Sentences 2 and 5 use a semicolon and a comma, following the punctuation tip; sentence 3 removes the repetition. The Because sentence shows a complex sentence can start with its linking clause. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: Siôn’s paragraph, improved

Lowri Haf’s version is slow, whereas Tonnau Tân’s version is fast. Lowri Haf sings quietly; in contrast, the band play loudly. Lowri Haf is accompanied only by a harp, so the texture is thin. The band, on the other hand, use drums, guitars, a synth and backing singers, which means that their texture is much thicker. In addition, the band modulate for the last verse, although Lowri Haf stays in one key. Both versions are in a major key and use the same traditional melody.

Connectives: whereas, in contrast, on the other hand, although (contrast); so, which means that (cause and effect); in addition (adding); both (similarity). Four groups. Musical terms added: texture, modulate, major key, melody. Siôn’s ideas are kept, but the reader now knows how each one relates to the last. Evidences criteria 1, 3 and 4.

Step 4: plan

ParagraphElementsKey point and connective
1Tempo and dynamics66 BPM with rubato whereas 112 BPM steady; p to mp, as a result tender
2Texture and timbrethin harp and voice; band thick and layered, on the other hand; husky, distorted, because
3Structure, tonality, judgementBoth strophic and major; however instrumental, tag, modulation; Overall Version 1 fits a quiet love song

Connectives are chosen at the planning stage, so the structure of the comparison is decided before writing. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 5: the comparison

Lowri Haf’s version is slow, at about 66 BPM, whereas Tonnau Tân play at about 112 BPM with a steady beat on the drum kit. Lowri Haf also uses rubato, which means that she can linger on important words such as “cariad”. Her dynamics stay between p and mp; as a result, the song sounds tender and private. In contrast, the band play mostly mf to f, although they drop suddenly to p for verse 2.

The texture of Version 1 is thin: one voice with harp arpeggios. Tonnau Tân, on the other hand, build a thick, layered texture with backing vocals, electric guitar, bass, drum kit and a synth pad. Because the lead singer’s voice is husky and the guitar is distorted, their version sounds rougher and more energetic. In addition, the synth pad adds a soft, glowing sound, whereas Version 1 relies on a clear voice and a delicate harp alone.

Both versions are strophic and in a major key. However, the band add an 8-bar instrumental and a tag at the end, and they modulate up a tone for the last verse, so the ending feels like a crowd singing along. Overall, I think Lowri Haf’s version suits the words better. The song is a quiet love song about a sweetheart sleeping at night; therefore, the slow tempo, soft dynamics and thin texture match its tender mood.

230 words in three paragraphs that follow the plan. Connectives: whereas, also, which means that, as a result, in contrast, although, on the other hand, because, in addition, both, however, so, therefore: 13 different ones from four groups. Two sentences start with a connective and are punctuated correctly. Every paragraph compares, rather than describing one version and then the other, and the judgement links the music back to the words of the song. Evidences criteria 2, 3, 4 and 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure