Worked example · RE · Year 9

Comparing views on wealth: Christian, Sikh and humanist

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

What this is

A secure Year 9 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. The key idea: all three perspectives say wealth is not wrong in itself and should be used to help others. The biggest difference is why: Christians and Sikhs answer to God and a holy book, whereas humanists use reason, evidence and empathy because they believe this is the only life. People: 1 Sikh, 2 humanist, 3 Christian, 4 Sikh or Christian (or humanist), 5 humanist, 6 Christian.

Step 2: key terms

TermMeaning
StewardshipLooking after what God owns and has trusted to us.
TithingGiving a tenth of your income, often to the church.
Kirat KarniEarning an honest living by hard work.
Vand ChhaknaSharing what you have with others.
LangarFree kitchen in a gurdwara, open to everyone.
EmpathyUnderstanding how other people feel.

Every meaning is short, accurate and in the pupil’s own words. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: the views

QuestionChristianSikhHumanist
Is being rich wrong?No, but loving money is “a root of all kinds of evil”; Jesus warned the rich.No, if it is earned honestly. Greed (lobh) is one of the five thieves.No. What matters is the effect on people’s wellbeing.
How earned or treated?Stewardship: it belongs to God, so use it well.Kirat Karni: honest hard work, not begging.Think about its effect on others.
What to do with it?Tithing; give to the poor and to charities like Christian Aid.Vand Chhakna; dasvandh, a tenth; langar.Reduce suffering and unfairness; give to charities that work best.
Where from?Bible, Jesus, the ChurchGuru Granth Sahib, the GurusReason, evidence, empathy

Information from three texts is sorted under the same four headings, which makes comparison easy. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 4: whose view is it?

PersonMost likelyClue
1Sikh“a tenth” (dasvandh) and “langar”
2Humanist“We only get one life”
3Christian“what God has lent me”: stewardship
4Sikh, but could be Christian or humanist“make honestly” matches Kirat Karni, but all three groups value honest work
5Humanist“check the evidence”
6Christian“Jesus warned us”, “storing up treasure”: the Rich Fool

Each viewpoint is inferred from a specific clue, and the pupil notices that person 4 fits more than one group. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 5: similarities and differences

(a) All three say being rich is not wrong in itself. All three say people should use money to help others.

(b) Christians and Sikhs believe money is linked to God, whereas humanists do not believe in God. Christians and Sikhs follow a holy book, whereas humanists decide using reason and evidence.

Similarities and differences are about beliefs, not just about actions. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 6: comparison

Christians and humanists both believe that being rich is not wrong in itself, and that people who have money should help others. However, the most important difference is why they help. Many Christians believe in stewardship: their money belongs to God, so they must use it well, and they follow Jesus’ warnings about the love of money in the Bible. In contrast, humanists do not believe in God or an afterlife, so they use reason, evidence and empathy to decide how to reduce suffering in this life, which is the only one they believe we have. This means a Christian gives because God asks them to, while a humanist gives because people need help now.

117 words. The paragraph opens with a similarity, states the most important difference clearly, explains where each view comes from, uses the specialist term “stewardship” correctly and links ideas with comparison words (underlined). It ends with a sharp one-sentence summary of the difference. Evidences criterion 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure