Worked example · Science · Year 7
LNF: Numeracy → Learning that statistics represent data and that probability models chance helps us make informed inferences and decisions → Collecting data
A secure Year 7 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. The counts are 9, 12, 7, 10 and 12 on the mown grass (total 50, mean 10) and 3, 5, 2, 4 and 1 in the long grass (total 15, mean 3). Three daisies sit on a right or bottom side and are not counted: one in Q2, one in Q4 and one in Q9. The key idea: a fair plan uses the same quadrat, the same rule and random places, with several samples in each area.
(a) I predict that there will be more daisies in each quadrat on the mown grass than in the long grass by the hedge, because daisies need light and long grass shades them.
| Quantitative | Qualitative |
|---|---|
| A, B, E, G | C, D, F, H |
The prediction names both areas and says which will have more, so a count can show if it is right. A reason is a bonus. E is quantitative because a percentage is a number. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.
| The problem | How to fix it |
|---|---|
| Only 2 quadrats on the short grass. That is too few samples to be sure. | Use at least 5 quadrats in each area. |
| Owain chooses places where he can see lots of daisies, so the results are biased. | Place the quadrats at random, using tape measures and random numbers. |
| Cerys uses a bigger quadrat, so the long grass counts cannot be compared with the short grass counts. | Use the same size of quadrat (50 cm by 50 cm) in both areas. |
| “Write down what we see” does not say what to count or how. | Count only daisies, use the counting rule and record each count in a results table. |
Also acceptable: doing the two areas on different days is not fair, because the weather or mowing might change. Do both areas on the same day.
Each fix answers its problem and is specific: how many, how to choose places, what size, what to record. Evidences criterion 3.
| Quadrat number | Area | Tally | Number of daisies |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Mown grass | ||||/ |||| | 9 |
| Q2 | Mown grass | ||||/ ||||/ || | 12 |
| Q3 | Mown grass | ||||/ || | 7 |
| Q4 | Mown grass | ||||/ ||||/ | 10 |
| Q5 | Mown grass | ||||/ ||||/ || | 12 |
| Q6 | Long grass | ||| | 3 |
| Q7 | Long grass | ||||/ | 5 |
| Q8 | Long grass | || | 2 |
| Q9 | Long grass | |||| | 4 |
| Q10 | Long grass | | | 1 |
Here ||||/ stands for a group of 5. In a handwritten tally, the 5th mark crosses the 4 before it, so each group of 5 is easy to count.
Counting rule decisions: Q2 has one daisy on the top side (counted) and one on the right side (not counted). Q4 has one on the left side (counted) and one on the bottom side (not counted). Q7 has one on the top side (counted). Q9 has one on the right side (not counted).
Clear headings, one row per quadrat, and every count matches the counting rule. A pupil who counted 13 in Q2, 11 in Q4 or 5 in Q9 has counted a daisy on the right or bottom side. Evidences criteria 4 and 5.
| Area | Total | Mean per quadrat | Fewest and most |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mown grass (Q1 to Q5) | 9 + 12 + 7 + 10 + 12 = 50 | 50 ÷ 5 = 10 | 7 and 12 |
| Long grass (Q6 to Q10) | 3 + 5 + 2 + 4 + 1 = 15 | 15 ÷ 5 = 3 | 1 and 5 |
(b) Yes, my prediction was correct. The mown grass had a mean of 10 daisies per quadrat, but the long grass had a mean of only 3. Even the quadrat with the fewest daisies on the mown grass (7) had more than the quadrat with the most in the long grass (5).
(c) Not completely. 5 quadrats is a small sample of a big field, and we only looked on one day. Using 10 or more quadrats in each area would make the result more reliable.
(d) The height of the grass in centimetres, or how much light reaches the ground.
The answer uses the data collected, quotes figures, and says honestly how sure we can be. Evidences criterion 6.