Worked example · PSE / Well-being · Year 8
LNF: Numeracy → Learning that statistics represent data and that probability models chance helps us make informed inferences and decisions → Collecting data
A secure Year 8 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key for Steps 2 to 5. The key ideas: answer boxes must cover everyone and not overlap, questions must be neutral and precise, and the sample must represent the whole school. The Step 6 results below are one invented example; every class will get different data.
| Q | Problem |
|---|---|
| Q1 | Asks for personal information that is not needed to test the hypothesis. It also makes people less likely to answer honestly. |
| Q2 | Missing options: cycle, scoot, bus, train, other. Someone who cycles has no box to tick. |
| Q3 | The boxes overlap: a 10-minute journey fits two boxes. There is no box for more than 30 minutes. The boxes also do not match the 15-minute hypothesis. |
| Q4 | Leading and loaded: “Don’t you agree” and “lazily” push people to say yes. |
| Q5 | Vague: “a lot” means different things to different people. |
Q6 collects qualitative data: reasons and ideas in words. It is useful, because it tells the council what might change people’s behaviour, not just what they do now.
Each problem is named precisely (overlapping, leading, vague, missing options). Evidences criterion 1.
Q2. How do you usually travel to school? Tick one. ☐ Walk ☐ Cycle or scoot ☐ Car ☐ Bus or train ☐ Other
Q3. How long does your journey to school usually take? ☐ Less than 5 minutes ☐ 5 minutes to less than 15 minutes ☐ 15 minutes to less than 30 minutes ☐ 30 minutes or more
Q5. On how many days last week were you active for at least 60 minutes? ☐ 0 ☐ 1 to 2 ☐ 3 to 4 ☐ 5 to 7
“Usually” and “tick one” deal with pupils who travel different ways on different days. The time boxes do not overlap, cover every possible journey, and split at 15 minutes to match the hypothesis. Q5 replaces “a lot” with a number of days. Evidences criteria 1 and 3.
(a) 10 people is too few to be reliable. They are all in Year 11 and all friends, so they may travel in similar ways (older pupils may drive or live near each other), and they do not represent the whole school.
(b) Ask, for example, 2 randomly chosen pupils from every form in every year group, which gives a sample of about 100 pupils from across the school.
The pupil explains both the size and the bias of the sample and plans a representative one. Evidences criterion 2.
| How they travel | Less than 15 minutes | 15 minutes or more |
|---|---|---|
| Walk | ||| | | |
| Cycle or scoot | | | |
| Car | | | || |
| Bus or train | || | |
| Other | ||
| Total | 5 | 5 |
A two-way table records both answers from each person together, so you can see whether journey time and way of travelling are linked. Two separate tally charts would lose that link.
Q6 answers: “A safe place to lock my bike.” “If my friends walked with me.”
The sheet is designed to test the hypothesis directly, and both quantitative (tallies) and qualitative (Q6) data are collected. Evidences criteria 2, 3 and 4.
Yes: 4 of the 5 pupils with journeys under 15 minutes walked, cycled or scooted, but only 1 of the 5 with longer journeys did. This supports the hypothesis. However, we only asked 10 pupils sitting near each other, so the results may not be true for the whole school.
The conclusion uses the data and is cautious about the small, unrepresentative sample.