Worked example · Geography · Year 10
LNF: Numeracy → Learning that statistics represent data and that probability models chance helps us make informed inferences and decisions → Collecting data
A secure Year 10 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. Stratified sample of 60: 6, 14, 24 and 16. Of 50: 5, 12, 20 and 13. Systematic intervals: every 10th person at site 1 and every 5th at site 2. Random shops: 07, 19, 04, 11 and 02. Practice only, not NEA work.
(a) Question 3, how far people travelled.
(b) Quantitative: question 3 (distance) or question 6 (how often, once improved). Qualitative: question 8 (reasons) or question 2 (a place name).
(c) The enquiry question also asks why people shop there. Question 8 collects reasons, which help to explain the distances.
The pupil links each question to the hypothesis or the enquiry question, and knows numbers from words. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.
| Q | What is wrong | Better version |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Asking an exact age is personal, and the group only needs age groups for the stratified sample. | Which age group are you in? ☐ 11 to 17 ☐ 18 to 34 ☐ 35 to 64 ☐ 65 and over |
| 3 | The categories overlap (5 km is in two boxes) and there is no box for more than 20 km. | How far did you travel to get here? ☐ less than 1 km ☐ 1 km to less than 5 km ☐ 5 km to less than 10 km ☐ 10 km or more |
| 4 | It is a leading question: it pushes people to say yes. It also does not help test the hypothesis. | Do you also shop at the retail park? ☐ Often ☐ Sometimes ☐ Never |
| 5 | It asks two things at once, so the answer is hard to record. | 5a How did you travel here? ☐ Walked ☐ Cycled ☐ Bus or train ☐ Car ☐ Other. 5b How much have you spent today? ☐ Nothing ☐ Less than £10 ☐ £10 to less than £30 ☐ £30 or more |
| 6 | “Often” and “sometimes” mean different things to different people. | How often do you shop here? ☐ Most days ☐ Once a week ☐ Once a month ☐ Less than once a month |
| 7 | Income is private and not needed for this enquiry. People may refuse to go on. | Remove it. Ask something useful instead, such as “What did you mainly come to the High Street for today?” |
Each problem is named with the right idea (leading, overlapping, double question, vague, private), and each fix is a usable question. The distance bands in question 3 split exactly at 5 km, so they test the hypothesis. Evidences criterion 3.
(a) Opportunistic · Systematic · Stratified · Random
(b) 07, 19, (23 is above 20, ignore), 04, 11, (19 repeats, ignore), 02. The shops are 07, 19, 04, 11 and 02.
Random numbers are used in order, and the pupil applies the rules for numbers that are out of range or repeated. Evidences criterion 4.
| Age group | 60 people | 50 people |
|---|---|---|
| 11 to 17 | 900 ÷ 9,000 × 60 = 6 | 900 ÷ 9,000 × 50 = 5 |
| 18 to 34 | 2,100 ÷ 9,000 × 60 = 14 | 2,100 ÷ 9,000 × 50 = 11.67, so 12 |
| 35 to 64 | 3,600 ÷ 9,000 × 60 = 24 | 3,600 ÷ 9,000 × 50 = 20 |
| 65 and over | 2,400 ÷ 9,000 × 60 = 16 | 2,400 ÷ 9,000 × 50 = 13.33, so 13 |
| Total | 6 + 14 + 24 + 16 = 60 | 5 + 12 + 20 + 13 = 50 |
You cannot ask 11.67 people, so each value is rounded to the nearest whole number, and the total is checked. Evidences criterion 5.
(a) Site 1: 400 ÷ 40 = 10, so ask every 10th person. Site 2: 150 ÷ 30 = 5, so ask every 5th person.
| How far did you travel? | Tally | Total |
|---|---|---|
| Less than 1 km | ||
| 1 km to less than 5 km | ||
| 5 km to less than 10 km | ||
| 10 km or more |
The interval is total passing ÷ number wanted. The tally chart uses the same non-overlapping categories as the improved question. Evidences criteria 3 and 5.
The group adds the totals for “less than 1 km” and “1 km to less than 5 km”. If this is more than half of the people asked, for example more than 30 out of 60, the hypothesis is supported. If it is 30 or fewer, the hypothesis is not supported, because most people travelled 5 km or more. Because the sample is stratified by age, the result is more likely to represent the whole town.
The pupil sets a clear numerical test for the hypothesis before collecting data. Evidences criterion 1.