Worked example · Design Technology · Year 8

Drawing a phone stand to scale with angles

LNF: Numeracy → Learning about geometry helps us understand shape, space and position, and learning about measurement helps us quantify in the real world → Angle

What this is

A secure Year 8 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Accept measurements within 1 mm and 2°. Real lengths: lip 14 mm, ledge 24 mm, back rest 120 mm, rear leg about 109 mm. Angles: a = 65°, b = 115°, c = 25°, d = 90°, e = 90°. Turns: J 90°, K 65°, T 155°. Elin drew the back rest at its real length (120 mm, should be 60 mm) and read the wrong protractor scale (115°, should be 65°). Tablet stand: lean 60°, b = 120°, c = 30°, back rest 90 mm at 1:2 and 45 mm at 1:4.

Step 1: scale and lengths

(a) “Every 1 mm on the drawing is 2 mm on the real stand, so I multiply drawing lengths by 2.”

PartOn the drawing (mm)WorkingReal length (mm)
Lip, L to J77 × 214
Ledge, J to K1212 × 224
Back rest, K to T6060 × 2120
Rear leg, T to R54 (54.4)54.4 × 2about 109 (accept 108 to 110)

(c) Yes: 14 mm and 24 mm match the stimulus, so the ruler was used correctly.

Every drawing length is doubled, and the given lengths are used as a check on the measuring. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 2: measure the angles

AngleEstimateMeasured
aacute65°
bobtuse115°
cacute (very small)25°
dright90°
eright90°

(a) 65 + 115 = 180°. The ledge and the table beyond K form one straight line, and angles on a straight line add up to 180°.

(b) 65 + 25 + 90 = 180°, which is right, because the angles in a triangle add up to 180°.

Each estimate agrees with the measurement, so a misread scale would be caught. Two angle facts confirm the measurements. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.

Step 3: angles as turns

BendAngle inside the bendTurn
Je = 90°180 − 90 = 90°
Kb = 115°180 − 115 = 65°
Tc = 25°180 − 25 = 155°

The biggest turn is at T (155°). The strip is folded nearly back on itself there, so the maker has to bend it furthest and most carefully.

The angle is treated as an amount of turn, linked to the angle inside the bend. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 4: check Elin’s drawing

(a) The back rest. It should be 120 ÷ 2 = 60 mm on the drawing. Elin drew the real length, 120 mm, so that part is at scale 1:1 while the rest is at 1:2.

(b) Angle a. It should be 65°. She counted from the 0 on the wrong scale, so she read 115°, which is 180 − 65. With a = 115°, the back rest leans forward over the ledge, so the phone has nothing to lean on.

(c) Estimate first. The lean is clearly less than a right angle, so it must be acute; 115° is obtuse, so it cannot be right.

Both mistakes are found with a reason: one scale error and one protractor error, each checked by a calculation. Evidences criteria 2, 4 and 6.

Step 5: draw the stand to scale

(a) A secure 1:2 drawing matches the stimulus: ledge 12 mm, lip 7 mm at 90°, back rest 60 mm at 65° to the table, and a vertical rear leg of 54 mm that meets the table 25 mm to the right of K. It is labelled “Side view, scale 1:2”.

(b) At 1:1 the lip is 14 mm, the ledge 24 mm and the back rest piece 50 mm, with the same angles: 90° at J and 65° to the table at K. The angles do not change when the scale changes; only the lengths do.

Lengths are halved for 1:2 and real for 1:1, while every angle stays the same. If the rear leg is badly out, the 65° angle is usually the cause. Evidences criteria 2 and 5.

Step 6: the tablet stand

(a) 60°: it tipped 0 times and 9 of 10 testers found it comfortable. 55° was comfortable for only 6 testers. 65°, 70° and 75° tipped over at least once.

(b) b = 180 − 60 = 120°. c = 180 − 60 − 90 = 30°. The turn at K is 180 − 120 = 60°.

(c) 1:2: 180 ÷ 2 = 90 mm. 1:4: 180 ÷ 4 = 45 mm.

(d) A table line, a 45 mm back rest at 60° to it, and a rear leg straight down, about 39 mm long.

The choice uses both rules of the specification, and the new angles come from angle facts, not guesses. Evidences criteria 3, 4 and 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure