Worked example · Humanities · Year 5
DCF: Interacting and collaborating → Collaboration
A secure Year 5 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key, and it uses the stimulus sheet “Owain Glyndŵr: a pretend shared document”. Headline answers: Cerys, Dylan, Amira and Jac can edit, Mr Rowlands can comment and Class 5H can view. Jac deleted Paragraph 3, written by Amira, at 10:31. The group should restore the 10:28 version; no other work is lost, because the delete is the only change after 10:28. The Year 3 class should be can view. The 10 corrections are: 1 was, 2 proclaimed, 3 a rebellion, 4 Owain Glyndŵr, 5 held, 6 a parliament, 7 captured, 8 took (or had taken), 9 were, 10 knows. By rule: P (past tense) 3 mistakes, V (standard verb form) 2, A (agreement) 1, W (precise word) 3, N (name) 1, which makes 10.
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| (a) Who made the document? (the owner) | Cerys |
| (b) Who can edit? | Cerys, Dylan, Amira and Jac |
| (c) Who can comment, but cannot change the words? | Mr Rowlands, the teaching assistant |
| (d) Who can only view? | Class 5H, everyone in the class |
| Who deleted it? | At what time? | Which paragraph? | Who wrote it? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jac | 10:31 | Paragraph 3 | Amira |
(f) The 10:28 version.
(g) No. The only change after 10:28 was Jac deleting the paragraph at 10:31, so everybody else’s writing is still there in the 10:28 version.
(h) Restoring is quicker than typing it all again. It brings back Amira’s exact words, so we will not forget a fact or add new mistakes. Also, it is Amira’s work, so it should go back the way she wrote it.
The pupil reads each role correctly from the Share panel and uses the version history to find who, when and what. They choose the last version before the delete and check that nothing else is lost. Accept any 2 sensible reasons in (h), such as speed, exact words, fewer mistakes or respect for Amira’s work. Evidences criterion 1.
| New person | Role | My reason |
|---|---|---|
| Mrs Jenkins, the class teacher | Can comment | She can give us advice, but the writing stays ours because she cannot change it. |
| Class 3P, the Year 3 class who will read the page | Can view | They only need to read it. They cannot delete or change anything by mistake. |
| Amira’s mum, a parent | Can view | She wants to read our page. She does not need to change it. |
Each role matches what the person needs to do, with a reason. The Year 3 class must not be “can edit”. Accept “can edit” for Mrs Jenkins if the pupil explains she needs to fix things, and “can comment” for the parent if the pupil wants kind feedback from home. This is a first step towards setting permissions for a group. Evidences criterion 3.
(a) Dylan wrote “this is rubbish” on Paragraph 4, which Jac wrote. It is unkind, and it does not tell Jac what is wrong or how to make it better.
(b) I like that you told the Year 3 readers about Owain Glyndŵr Day on 16 September, Jac. Could you change “We was” to “We were”? Then the sentence will be correct.
(c) Comment on Paragraph 3: Amira, your castle facts are really clear. Could you use “captured” instead of “got”? It is the exact history word, and it tells the reader what his forces did.
Both comments start with something real to praise, then name one exact change and how to make it. They use the writer’s name and stay polite. Any paragraph is fine for (c) if the advice is specific. Evidences criterion 4.
| No. | Paragraph | What the page says | Correct form | Rule |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 (Cerys) | Owain Glyndŵr is a Welsh nobleman. | was | P |
| 2 | 1 (Cerys) | his followers proclaim him Prince of Wales | proclaimed | P |
| 3 | 1 (Cerys) | This began fighting and stuff | a rebellion | W |
| 4 | 2 (Dylan) | In 1404 Owen Glindor | Owain Glyndŵr | N |
| 5 | 2 (Dylan) | Owen Glindor holds | held | P |
| 6 | 2 (Dylan) | a big meeting thing at Machynlleth | a parliament | W |
| 7 | 3 (Amira) | his forces also got Harlech Castle | captured | W |
| 8 | 3 (Amira) | English armies taked both castles back | took (or had taken) | V |
| 9 | 4 (Jac) | We was surprised | were | V |
| 10 | 4 (Jac) | nobody know for certain | knows | A |
(b) It is still true today that nobody knows for certain when or where he died, so the present tense is right. The verb has to match “nobody”, so it is “knows”.
All 10 corrections are right and each has a sensible rule. The pupil changes present tense verbs to the past for history (1, 2, 5), uses standard verb forms (8, 9), makes the verb agree with its subject (10), and swaps vague words for precise history words (3, 6, 7). Accept V or A for 9, since “we were” is also agreement. Accept “knew” for 10 if the pupil keeps the whole sentence in the past; the key point is that “nobody know” is wrong. Accept “began a rebellion” or “rebellion” for 3. This is the literacy evidence for standard forms of verbs and precise vocabulary. Evidences criteria 5 and 6.
Word bank used: ☑ parliament ☑ captured ☑ castle ☑ forces
Owain Glyndŵr in 1404
In 1404, Owain Glyndŵr held a parliament at Machynlleth. In the same year, his forces captured Harlech Castle and Aberystwyth Castle. However, by 1409 English armies had taken both castles back.
Check it: ☑ Yes, all the verbs are in the past tense.
Paragraphs 2 and 3 now read as one paragraph by one writer. Every verb is in the past tense, 4 word bank words are used correctly, the name is spelled as in the title, and no new facts are added. The chatty line “1404 was a busy year!” is left out or turned into a joining phrase like “In the same year”. “However” links the two ideas. This is the literacy evidence for consistent tense and precise subject vocabulary. Evidences criterion 6.
Our rules for editing a shared document
The rules come straight from the problems on the page: the deleted paragraph, the unkind comment and the mixed writing. Accept other sensible rules, such as “give readers the can view role” or “agree to write in the past tense before we start”. Evidences criteria 1 and 4.
A better title: Owain Glyndŵr, Prince of Wales. (Any short, clear title that is about him and would interest a Year 3 reader.)
Which role? Can comment. It lets someone suggest changes but stops them changing or deleting the words. It is a good idea for someone who is checking the page, not writing it, or when the page is nearly finished.
Comment for Paragraph 1: Cerys, I like that you gave the exact date, 16 September 1400. Could you change “is” to “was”, because he lived long ago?