Worked example · Design Technology · Year 10

Estimating and checking the cost of a batch: the Silff Nant shelf

LNF: Numeracy → Developing mathematical proficiency → Fluency

What this is

A secure Year 10 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. One shelf costs £6.86 (estimate £7). A batch of 20 costs £142.30 before discount; 10% off gives £128.07, or £6.40 per shelf. A batch of 50 costs £354.70; 20% off gives £283.76, or £5.68 per shelf. Elis’s 3 errors: plywood £9.20 should be £92.00 (decimal point slip), screws 1 bag should be 2 bags (wrong rounding), keyhole plates 20 should be 40 (forgot 2 per shelf). Waste: 20% of one sheet, 23.1% over the batch of 50.

Step 1: quick methods

CalculationQuick methodAnswerInverse check
(b) 20 × £0.78× 2 then × 10: 1.56 × 10£15.6015.60 ÷ 20 = 0.78 ✓
(c) 25 × £9.60× 100 then ÷ 4: 960 ÷ 4£240.00240 ÷ 25 = 9.60 ✓
(d) 50 × £3.90× 100 then ÷ 2: 390 ÷ 2£195.00195 ÷ 50 = 3.90 ✓
(e) 13 × £18.40× 10 plus × 3: 184 + 55.20£239.20239.20 ÷ 13 = 18.40 ✓

(f) 25 is a quarter of 100, so 25 lots of something is a quarter of 100 lots. Multiplying by 100 is easy (move the digits 2 places), and halving twice is easy.

Each method turns a hard multiplication into facts the pupil knows, and each answer is checked with the opposite operation. Evidences criteria 1 and 3.

Step 2: the cost of one shelf

ItemWorkingEstimateExact cost
Plywood18.40 ÷ 4£4.60£4.60
Screws3.00 ÷ 100 = 3p each, × 6£0.20£0.18
Keyhole plates3.90 ÷ 10 = 39p each, × 2£0.80£0.78
Varnish50 ml is 1/10 of 500 ml: 9.60 ÷ 10£1.00£0.96
Abrasive paper5.00 ÷ 20£0.30£0.25
Wood glue10 ml is 1/50 of 500 ml: 4.50 ÷ 50£0.10£0.09
Total for one shelf£7.00£6.86

£6.86 is close to the estimate of £7, so no line has a big slip.

Estimating every line before calculating means a slip shows up at once. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.

Step 3: a batch of 20

(a) About £7 × 20 = £140.

ItemAmount neededPacks to buyCost
Plywood20 ÷ 4 = 5 sheets5£92.00
Screws6 × 20 = 1201.2 bags, round up to 2£6.00
Keyhole plates2 × 20 = 404£15.60
Varnish50 × 20 = 1000 ml2£19.20
Abrasive paper20 sheets1£5.00
Wood glue10 × 20 = 200 ml0.4, round up to 1£4.50
Total before discount£142.30

(c) £142.30 is £100 or more but under £300, so 10% off. 10% = £14.23. Pay 142.30 − 14.23 = £128.07. Per shelf: 128.07 ÷ 20 = 6.4035, so £6.40.

(d) 20 × £6.86 = £137.20, which is £5.10 less. The group must buy whole packs: 80 screws are left over (£2.40) and 300 ml of glue is left over (£2.70). 2.40 + 2.70 = 5.10.

The answer of £142.30 is close to the £140 estimate. The pupil rounds up for whole packs and explains the extra cost exactly. Evidences criteria 2, 3 and 4.

Step 4: Elis’s 3 errors

Elis’s £48.70 is about a third of the £140 estimate, so something is badly wrong.

 The errorThe check that finds itCorrect cost
1Plywood: 5 × 18.40 is 92, not 9.20. A decimal point slip.Estimate: 5 × £20 = £100. Inverse: 9.20 ÷ 5 = 1.84, not 18.40.£92.00
2Screws: 1.2 bags was rounded down to 1 bag, which is only 100 screws.Does the rounding make sense? 100 screws is fewer than the 120 needed. Round up to 2 bags.£6.00
3Keyhole plates: he forgot that each shelf needs 2, so he costed 20 plates.Reread the quantities: 2 × 20 = 40 plates = 4 packs.£15.60

Check: he left out 92.00 − 9.20 = 82.80, 6.00 − 3.00 = 3.00 and 15.60 − 7.80 = 7.80. 48.70 + 82.80 + 3.00 + 7.80 = 142.30 ✓.

Reply to Elis: “The batch really costs £128.07 after the discount, which is £6.40 a shelf. Selling at £4 would lose £2.40 on every shelf.”

A different check is chosen for each kind of error, and the corrections are proved by adding back what was left out. Evidences criteria 2, 3 and 4.

Step 5: a batch of 50

(a) About £7 × 50 = £350.

(b) Plywood 50 ÷ 4 = 12.5, buy 13 sheets, £239.20. Screws 300, 3 bags, £9.00. Keyhole plates 100, 10 packs, £39.00. Varnish 2500 ml, 5 tins, £48.00. Abrasive paper 50 sheets = 2.5 packs, buy 3, £15.00. Glue 500 ml, 1 bottle, £4.50. Total before discount £354.70, close to the estimate.

(c) £354.70 is over £300, so 20% off. Key presses: 354.7 × 0.8 ÷ 50 =. Display: 5.6752. Amount to pay per shelf: £5.68. (Whole batch: 354.7 × 0.8 = £283.76.)

The multiplier 0.8 takes off 20% in one step, and the display is rounded to pounds and pence. Evidences criteria 2, 4 and 5.

Step 6: waste

(a) Sheet: 1200 × 600 = 720 000 mm². One shelf: 400 × 150 + 400 × 120 + 2 × 150 × 120 = 60 000 + 48 000 + 36 000 = 144 000 mm².

(b) 720 000 ÷ 144 000 = 5. But the parts are different shapes and cannot fit together with no gaps, and each saw cut removes a strip, so only 4 fit.

(c) One sheet: waste = 720 000 − 4 × 144 000 = 144 000 mm². 144 000 ÷ 720 000 × 100 = 20%. Batch of 50: 13 sheets = 9 360 000 mm², parts = 50 × 144 000 = 7 200 000 mm², waste 2 160 000 mm². 2 160 000 ÷ 9 360 000 × 100 = 23.07… = 23.1%. It is higher because the 13th sheet is only used for 2 shelves.

Area gives an upper limit, and the pupil explains why the real layout falls short. Evidences criteria 1 and 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure