Worked example · History · Year 9 · Advanced
LNF: Writing → Purpose · DCF: Producing → Sourcing, searching and planning digital content
A secure Year 9 response annotated against the lesson success criteria, doubling as the supply teacher’s complete answer key. Key numerical results: Lime tolls = 48d (40% of 120d income); Market tolls = 18d (15%); Coal tolls = 24d (20%); Total weekly tolls = 90d (75% of weekly income), leaving 30d (25%) for food and necessities.
| Feature | Source A: Colonel Henry Wyndham, J.P. (19 June 1843) | Source B: Dafydd Evans & 64 Tenant Farmers (24 Oct 1843) |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Who is the audience? | Sir James Graham, the Home Secretary in Whitehall, London (in charge of law, order and the army). | The Royal Commission of Inquiry sent by Parliament to investigate the South Wales turnpike unrest. |
| 2. What is the writer’s main purpose? | To alarm the government into sending a squadron of Dragoon Guards immediately to protect trust gates and estates. | To persuade the Commissioners to remove illegal side-bars and lower toll charges through lawful reform. |
| 3. What is the overall tone? | Alarmist, outraged, urgent and condemnatory. | Respectful, earnest, reasoned and pleading. |
| 4. How does the writer describe the farmers / protesters? | “a lawless midnight rabble of disguised conspirators” and “fanatics”. | “humble, industrious tenant farmers ground down by intolerable exactions” and “honest families”. |
| 5. How does the writer describe the toll charges? | Dismisses them as a “mere grumble over sixpenny road charges” against “lawful property”. | Calls them “intolerable exactions” and “unjust gates that starve our fields of lime and drive honest families to ruin”. |
Identifies audience, purpose and tone accurately for both sources and pairs direct quotations to show how word choice serves each writer’s aim. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.
| Type of journey | Toll per gate | Total gates per week | Weekly cost in pence (d) | Percentage of 120d weekly income |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Two-horse cart of agricultural lime | 6d | 8 gates | 8 × 6d = 48d | (48 ÷ 120) × 100 = 40% |
| 2. Two-horse cart of butter & cheese | 9d | 2 gates | 2 × 9d = 18d | (18 ÷ 120) × 100 = 15% |
| 3. Two-horse cart of household coal | 8d | 3 gates | 3 × 8d = 24d | (24 ÷ 120) × 100 = 20% |
| Combined weekly totals | 13 gates | 48 + 18 + 24 = 90d | 40% + 15% + 20% = 75% |
Remaining weekly income: 120d − 90d = 30d (2 shillings and 6 pence, or just 25% of weekly income). This strongly supports Dafydd Evans’s petition and refutes Colonel Wyndham’s dismissal of the tolls as a “mere grumble”: paying 40% of household income on lime tolls alone (and 75% across all road journeys) was financially ruinous.
(b) Digital sourcing evaluation: Search 2 is much stronger because quotation marks around "Rebecca Riots" lock the exact historical phrase, the Boolean operator OR captures documents mentioning either turnpikes or lime, the date 1843 narrows results to the key year, and site:library.wales restricts results to verified digitised collections at the National Library of Wales rather than unverified blogs.
Calculates every weekly cost and percentage accurately, uses the 40% and 75% figures to test the primary sources, and explains each digital search operator clearly. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.
Source A and Source B give sharply contrasting accounts of the 1843 Carmarthenshire protests because their writers had opposite purposes, audiences and vested interests. In Source A, Colonel Henry Wyndham is writing to the Home Secretary, Sir James Graham, with the urgent purpose of securing a squadron of Dragoon Guards from Bristol. Because Wyndham is himself a magistrate and Turnpike Trustee whose property and toll income are under threat, he adopts an alarmist, outraged tone. He labels the farmers a “lawless midnight rabble of disguised conspirators” guilty of “seditious terror”, while belittling their financial grievance as a “mere grumble over sixpenny road charges” so Whitehall will see the unrest as a violent rebellion rather than an economic protest.
In contrast, Source B is a formal petition from Dafydd Evans and 64 tenant farmers to the Royal Commission of Inquiry, written to persuade Parliament to abolish illegal side-bars and reduce tolls. Addressing the Commissioners respectfully, the farmers present themselves as “humble, industrious tenant farmers ground down by intolerable exactions” who want lawful relief rather than rebellion. The 1843 Llanfihangel toll table proves that the farmers’ complaints were well founded: hauling two carts of lime through a main gate and three side-bars cost 48d per week, swallowing 40% of a farmer’s 120d net weekly income, while total road tolls for lime, coal and market produce reached 90d (75%), leaving only 30d to feed a family.
Analyses both sources in depth, links vocabulary and tone directly to audience, purpose and vested interest, and integrates the calculated toll percentages (48d / 40% and 90d / 75%) as historical evidence. Evidences criteria 1, 2, 3 and 5.
In June 1843, around two hundred disguised local protesters known as Merched Beca dismantled Llanfihangel tollgate and three newly erected side-bars in Carmarthenshire. While local magistrates described the nocturnal attacks as lawless disorder and requested military support, tenant farmers argued before the Royal Commission that repeated sixpenny gate charges were driving families into poverty, with lime tolls alone taking 40% (48d) of a typical farmer’s 120d weekly income.
Replaces emotive invective with neutral, balanced museum prose that represents both perspectives and embeds the verified numeracy statistic. Evidences criterion 5.