Worked example · Science · Year 11
LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Clarity and vocabulary
Model plans and explanations at a secure Year 11 standard, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. Use them to check pupils’ notes. There is no single right wording. What matters is that the science stays accurate while the words change for each listener. The key facts: technetium-99m emits gamma rays (penetrating, weakly ionising) and has a half-life of about 6 hours, so after 24 hours only 1/16 is left.
| Term | To Tomos | To Mrs Price | To the panel |
|---|---|---|---|
| radioactive tracer | a tiny bit of special medicine that a camera can see | a very small amount of a radioactive substance, called a tracer, that shows up on the scan | a gamma-emitting radioisotope, technetium-99m, injected so its distribution can be imaged |
| gamma rays | invisible rays, a bit like light, that shine out through the body | a type of radiation that passes out of your body so the camera can pick it up | high-frequency electromagnetic radiation, highly penetrating |
| half-life of about 6 hours | it gets weaker very fast and has mostly gone by the next day | every 6 hours, half of it has decayed, so after a day only about a sixteenth is left | a half-life of about 6 hours: after 4 half-lives, 24 hours, activity falls to 1/16 |
| weakly ionising | it does not hurt the body much as it goes through | it does very little damage to your cells as it passes through | low ionising power compared with alpha, so a lower dose to tissue for a detectable signal |
Every version is true. The words get more technical from left to right, but no version says anything false to make it simpler. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.
“Hi Tomos. I know you’re worried about your taid, so I’ll explain what the scan does. The doctors want to look at his bones, but they can’t see through his skin. So a nurse gives him a tiny bit of special medicine through a small needle. It travels round his body and goes to the parts of his bones the doctors want to check. The medicine gives out invisible rays, a bit like a torch shining from inside the bone. A special camera catches those rays and makes a picture. The medicine is chosen because it gets weaker really fast. By the next day, almost all of it has gone. Drinking lots of water helps it leave his body. There’s always a tiny risk with anything like this, but the doctors only do it because the picture will help them look after your taid.”
Answer to “Will Taid glow? Can I hug him?”: “No, he won’t glow at all. The rays are invisible. The nurses will tell your taid if there’s anything to do after the scan, and the medicine is almost all gone by the next day.”
Starts with Tomos’s worry, uses no technical words, uses one comparison, is honest about risk and does not make up rules about hugs. Evidences criteria 2, 3 and 4.
“Mrs Price, it’s completely understandable to feel nervous when you hear the word radioactive. The substance in a bone scan is very different from what happens in a power station accident. You’ll have a small injection of what’s called a tracer. It collects in the parts of your bones that are repairing or growing, and it gives out gamma rays. These are a type of radiation that pass straight out of your body, so a camera next to you can pick them up and make a picture. They do very little damage to your cells on the way. The tracer also decays quickly: every 6 hours, half of it has gone, so after a day only about a sixteenth is left. Drinking plenty of water helps it leave faster. There is a small risk, as there is with any X-ray, but your doctor has asked for this scan because the information is worth more to you than that small risk.”
Answer to “Why put something radioactive inside me on purpose?”: “Because it’s one of the best ways to see which parts of your bones are repairing or growing, and the tracer is chosen so it gives a clear picture and then fades away quickly.”
Calm and respectful. Each science word (tracer, gamma rays, decays) is explained the first time it is used. The difference between perceived and actual risk is handled honestly. Evidences criteria 2, 3 and 4.
“Bone scans commonly use technetium-99m, and the choice comes down to two properties: the type of radiation and the half-life. It is a gamma emitter. Gamma radiation is highly penetrating, so it leaves the body and can be detected by a gamma camera, and it is weakly ionising, so the dose to tissue is low for the signal produced. An alpha emitter would be useless: the particles would be absorbed within a fraction of a millimetre of tissue, never reach the detector, and deposit all their energy in nearby cells. The half-life of about 6 hours is a compromise. It is long enough to prepare the injection, allow uptake by the bone and complete the scan, but short enough that after 24 hours, which is 4 half-lives, the activity has fallen to one sixteenth. The perceived risk is high because of the word radioactive, but the actual dose is small and justified by the clinical benefit.”
Answer to “Why not a half-life of several years?”: “Because the isotope would stay active inside the patient for years, irradiating their tissues long after the scan was finished. A long half-life also means a low activity for a given number of atoms, so you would need more of it to get a clear image.”
Precise terms used correctly: gamma emitter, penetrating, ionising, half-life, activity, dose. The argument is structured around the two properties and answers the challenge with physics. Evidences criteria 1 and 4.
Feedback received: “You said ‘half-life’ to Mrs Price but did not explain it, and you said it was totally safe.”
Improved: “The tracer fades away quickly. Every 6 hours, half of it has gone, so by this time tomorrow only about a sixteenth is left. Like any scan that uses radiation, there is a small risk, but your doctor has decided that what the scan shows is worth much more to you than that small risk.” (55 words)
The pupil acts on specific feedback: an unexplained term is replaced by a clear explanation, and an inaccurate claim of no risk is corrected. Evidences criterion 5.