Worked example · Mathematics and Numeracy · Year 5

Explaining a word problem method with connectives

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Connectives and syntax

What this is

A secure Year 5 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Key figures: Problem A 28 + 35 = 63, 63 ÷ 7 = 9 bags in each bin; Problem B 157 + 18 = 175 people, 3 coaches hold only 150, so 4 coaches (200 seats) and 200 − 175 = 25 empty seats; Problem C 8 × 24 = 192, 192 ÷ 6 = 32 boxes; Problem D 3 × £4 = £12, £20 − £12 = £8 change. Pupils’ sentences will differ: look for correct maths joined by connectives that fit their meaning.

Step 1: sort the connectives

Time and orderCause and effectAddingContrast
first
next
then
after that
finally
because
so
therefore
as a result
and
also
as well as
in addition
but
however
although

All 16 connectives are in the right group: 5, 4, 4 and 3. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: join up a choppy explanation

First, I added 28 and 35 because I needed the total number of bags, so there were 63 bags altogether. Next, I divided 63 by 7 because the bags were shared equally between 7 bins. As a result, each bin had 9 bags.

Seven short sentences become 3 longer ones, and all of Cerys’s maths is kept. Connectives used: first, because, so, next, because, as a result. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: solve and explain

157 + 18 = 175 people 3 coaches: 3 × 50 = 150 seats (not enough) 4 coaches: 4 × 50 = 200 seats 200 − 175 = 25 empty seats
(a) Number of coaches(b) Number of empty seats
425

First, I added 157 and 18 because the adults need seats as well as the pupils, so there are 175 people. Next, I worked out that 3 coaches have 150 seats. However, 150 is less than 175, so 3 coaches are not enough. As a result, the school needs 4 coaches, which have 200 seats. Finally, I took 175 away from 200, so 25 seats will be empty.

The pupil spots both steps (add the adults, then share into coaches) and explains why the answer rounds up to 4, not down to 3. The explanation uses 10 connectives from all 4 groups: first, next, finally (time and order); because, so (3 times), as a result (cause and effect); as well as (adding); however (contrast). Evidences criteria 3 and 6.

Step 4: find the mistake

1 tray: 24 ÷ 6 = 4 boxes 8 trays: 4 × 8 = 32 boxes Check: 8 × 24 = 192 Welsh cakes, 192 ÷ 6 = 32 boxes

Gethin, you divided correctly, because 24 ÷ 6 is 4. However, 4 boxes is only enough for 1 tray, but the café bakes 8 trays. You needed to multiply 4 by 8, so the correct answer is 32 boxes.

The pupil finds the missing second step, uses because, however and but, and is kind to Gethin by saying what he did well. The answer is checked a second way. Evidences criteria 4 and 6.

Step 5: start sentences in different ways

Iolo’s sentenceNew sentence
I needed to find the cost of the books, so I multiplied 3 by 4.To find the cost of the books, I multiplied 3 by 4.
I got £12 for the 3 books.After multiplying, I knew the 3 books cost £12.
I took £12 away from £20.Next, I took £12 away from £20.
I found that Nia gets £8 change.As a result, Nia gets £8 change.
I checked by adding £12 and £8, which makes £20.To check, I added £12 and £8, which makes £20.

Every sentence now starts in a different way, and the meaning and the maths stay the same: 3 × £4 = £12 and £20 − £12 = £8. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 6: check a partner’s work

This is how a partner would check the Step 3 explanation above.

GroupConnectives foundHow many?
Time and orderfirst, next, finally3
Cause and effectbecause, so, so, as a result, so5
Addingas well as1
Contrasthowever1

At least 3 connectives? Yes. From at least 2 groups? Yes. 4 coaches and 25 empty seats? Yes.

Star: You explained why 3 coaches are not enough, so I could follow your thinking.

Wish: You used so 3 times. Try therefore for one of them.

The star and wish are specific and kind, and the wish suggests a wider range of connectives. Evidences criteria 1 and 3.

If you finish early: answers

32 × £3 = £96. Caffi Mali sells 32 boxes and each box costs £3. Therefore, I multiplied 32 by 3, so the café gets £96.

Own problem (example): Elin walks 3 km on Monday and 4 km on Tuesday along the Ceredigion Coast Path. She does the same walk for 2 weeks. How far does she walk? First, I added 3 and 4 because Elin walks on 2 days each week, so she walks 7 km a week. Next, I multiplied 7 by 2 because there are 2 weeks. Although the question looks long, it only has 2 steps. Therefore, Elin walks 14 km, and I also checked that 7 + 7 = 14.

The own problem is correct: 3 + 4 = 7 km a week, 7 × 2 = 14 km. It uses connectives from every group: first, next (time and order); because, so, therefore (cause and effect); and, also (adding); although (contrast).

Why this response is secure