Worked example · Maths · Year 8

Explaining which phone contract is cheaper

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context

What this is

A complete, secure Year 8 answer, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. The numbers: Deal A £720, Deal B £723, Deal C £699. Deal C is the cheapest overall, but it has only 20 GB of data and needs £459 at the start, so it does not suit Elin. The best answer is Deal A. For Osian, Deal D costs £450 and Deal E £456, so Deal D is cheaper by £6. The most common mistake is choosing the cheapest deal without checking what the person needs.

Step 1: read the problem closely

(a) The deal is for 24 months. Elin uses about 25 GB of data a month. She can pay no more than £150 at the start.

(b) Her favourite colour is green, and she wants a good camera. We can ignore these because all three deals include the same phone. Where she lives and the 5G and calls also do not change the choice, because they are the same for every deal.

Separating what matters from what does not is the first step in organising an answer. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: the calculations

DealWorkingTotal over 24 months
A3 × £16 = £48; 21 × £32 = £672; £48 + £672£720
B24 × £26 = £624; £99 + £624£723
C24 × £10 = £240; £459 + £240£699

(b) Enough data: Deal A (30 GB) and Deal B (100 GB). Deal C has only 20 GB, which is less than 25 GB. Can afford at the start: Deal A (£0) and Deal B (£99). Deal C needs £459, which is more than £150.

Half of £32 is £16, and 24 − 3 = 21 months are left at full price. Check: 21 × 32 = 20 × 32 + 32 = 640 + 32 = 672.

Step 3: mark two answers

A well-organised answer…Answer X (Dylan)Answer Y (Nia)
1. says what is being worked outNo. There are no words at all.Partly. Yes for Deal A, but not for B or C.
2. shows every calculation with unitsPartly. The sums are right but there are no £ signs.Partly. Units for A and the total of B, none for C.
3. puts steps in order and links themNo. The reader has to guess which line is which deal.Yes. First, so, then.
4. ends with a conclusion and a reasonNo. Just the letter C.Partly. It names a deal, but the only reason is price.
5. checks everything the question saysNo.No. It never checks data or the £150.

(b) Deal C only has 20 GB a month but Elin uses about 25 GB. It also needs £459 at the start and she only has £150. So she could not afford to start it, and it would not do what she needs.

(c) Dylan: write a sentence before each calculation saying which deal it is, and put £ on every amount. Nia: explain Deals B and C in the same way as Deal A, and check the data and the money at the start before choosing.

The marking gives a reason for each judgement, not just a tick. Evidences criteria 2 to 5.

Step 4: Elin’s answer (model)

To choose the best deal, I will find the total cost of each deal over 24 months and then check that it suits you.

First I found the cost of Deal A. The first 3 months are half price, so 3 × £16 = £48. There are 21 months left at £32, so 21 × £32 = £672. Deal A costs £48 + £672 = £720.

Next I worked out Deal B. You pay £99 at the start, then 24 × £26 = £624, so Deal B costs £99 + £624 = £723.

Then I worked out Deal C. The phone costs £459 and the SIM costs 24 × £10 = £240, so Deal C costs £459 + £240 = £699.

Deal C is the cheapest. However, it only gives 20 GB of data and you use 25 GB, and it needs £459 at the start when you have £150. Deals A and B both give enough data and you can afford to start them.

Therefore I recommend Deal A, because it is £3 cheaper than Deal B over 24 months, it has enough data, and you pay nothing at the start.

One opening sentence says what the answer will do. Each step starts by naming the deal. Every amount has a £ sign. However turns the answer from cost to suitability, and the conclusion names the deal and gives three reasons using the numbers. Evidences criteria 2 to 5.

Step 5: Osian’s answer (model)

I will find the total cost of each deal over 24 months, then check that each one suits Osian.

First I worked out Deal D. For the first 12 months, 12 × £18 = £216. After the price rise, 12 × £19.50 = £234. So Deal D costs £216 + £234 = £450.

Next I worked out Deal E. The price is fixed, so 24 × £19 = £456.

Both deals give more than the 5 GB Osian needs, and neither costs anything at the start.

Therefore Osian should choose Deal D, because it is £456 − £450 = £6 cheaper over 24 months. He should remember that it costs 50p a month more than Deal E in the second year.

The pupil used the same structure without help, which shows the skill has transferred to a new problem. Evidences all five criteria.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure