Worked example · Languages, Literacy and Communication · Year 4
LNF: Literacy → Reading → Reading strategies
Model answers for a secure Year 4 reader, annotated. Inference questions have more than one good answer: accept any answer that is sensible and backed by a clue from the story or the pictures. An answer with no clue is not secure, even if it is right.
| First… | so… | so… | so… |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cadi left her gloves at home. | Her fingers got very cold in the strong wind (they turned pink, then white). | She put one hand up her sleeve and held the handle with only 2 fingers. | The handle jumped out of her fingers. |
The pupil links the gloves (paragraph 2) to the cold fingers and weak grip (paragraph 4) and the gust (paragraph 5). This is deducing cause and effect from statements that are far apart. Evidences success criterion 1.
1. Taid passes Cadi the handle. 2. Cadi’s fingers turn white. 3. Mot pounces on the handle. 4. Taid tells Cadi the kite has been torn before. 5. Cadi says she is going to remember something.
a) “I think Cadi feels upset and guilty because in paragraph 7 her eyes fill with tears and she says ‘I’m sorry, Taid’ and ‘I’ve ruined it’.”
b) “I think Taid smiles because he knows he can mend it. In paragraph 8 he says it has been torn before and ‘Nothing that can’t be mended’. He might also be remembering Cadi’s mam crashing it into a hedge.”
c) “Leapt tells me the kite went up very quickly and suddenly, like an animal jumping, because the wind was so strong.”
d) “Because Mot pounced on the handle and stopped it bouncing away. Without Mot, the kite would have flown off towards the Worm’s Head and been lost (paragraphs 5 and 6).”
Each answer explains a feeling or a reason that the story never states directly, and quotes a clue with its paragraph number. Evidences success criteria 3 and 5.
“I think there is a sewing tin in Taid’s pocket and he will sew up the kite. In Picture 2 there is a round tin poking out of his pocket with a needle and red thread. In paragraph 8 it rattles ‘like a tin full of buttons’ and he says it can be mended.”
The words alone say only “a tin full of buttons”. The needle and thread in the picture complete the clue. A pupil who uses both is using images to infer meaning. Evidences success criterion 4.
a) “She is going to remember her gloves. In paragraph 2 she left them on the kitchen table, and her cold fingers are why she let go.”
b) “I think she wants to feel safe and close to Taid after being upset, and to show she loves him because he was kind about the kite.” (Also fine: “because she is cold and tired”, if the pupil links it to the wind or the steep path.)
Part a needs a link right back to the beginning of the story; the author never says the word “gloves” at the end. Evidences success criteria 1 and 5.