Worked example · PE · Year 9

Giving a spoken analysis of a netball match

LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Purpose

What this is

A secure Year 9 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. The talk is written out so you can hear what a well-organised 1-minute analysis sounds like; pupils speak from notes, so their words will differ. Key figures: Manon 52.6%; team 65.1% (28 from 43); 42.9% of turnovers in Q4.

Step 2: the evidence

 WorkingAnswer
Manon’s shooting percentage10 ÷ 19 × 10052.6%
Team shooting percentage28 ÷ (24 + 19) × 100 = 28 ÷ 43 × 10065.1%
Turnovers in Q49 ÷ 21 × 10042.9%
 PointEvidence
Strength 1Ceri’s shooting18 from 24, 75%
Strength 2Defending in Q3Ffion’s 5 interceptions; we went ahead 23 to 22
The main thing to fixLong passes into the wind9 of our 21 turnovers were in Q4, and we lost Q2 and Q4

Every point has a number behind it, and the calculations are correct. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 4: a model 1-minute talk

Right, heads up, everyone. We lost by 2, but for three quarters we were the better team. First, the positives. Ceri, 18 from 24, that’s 75%. That’s brilliant shooting. And Q3 was our best quarter: Ffion made 5 interceptions and we went a goal ahead. However, the numbers show what cost us. Almost half our turnovers, 9 out of 21, came in the last quarter, when we were shooting into the wind. The same thing happened in Q2. We threw long, high passes and the wind took them. So, for next week at Aberwyddel, and it’s going to be windy again, one focus: short, flat passes, and everyone calls for the ball. We’ll practise it on Tuesday.

Player’s question: “How do we stop the long passes when we’re tired?”
Answer: “By moving to make it easy. If two people are always free close to the ball, nobody needs to throw it long.”

About 120 words. The opening sums up the match, signposts (“First”, “However”, “So”) show the order, there are 4 pieces of evidence, praise comes before one clear fix, and it ends with a single focus. It is honest but encouraging, and it names players only to praise them. Evidences criteria 1, 2 and 3.

Step 5: the assembly version

Good morning. This week, the Year 9 netball team played Ysgol Pentre Sidan in a close league match and lost by 30 goals to 28. Llanfrychan led after three quarters. Ceri scored 18 goals, and Ffion made 5 interceptions in the third quarter. The team will play Aberwyddel away next week. Please come along and support them. Well done, team, and thank you.

Changes: 1. I used formal language (“Good morning”, full sentences, “Ysgol Pentre Sidan”) because it is the whole school, not my teammates. 2. I left out the turnovers and did not criticise anyone, because the purpose is to report and celebrate, not to coach.

63 words. The same facts are selected and ordered differently for a new audience and purpose. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 6: reflection

My player remembered “short, flat passes” but not Ceri’s figure. Next time I will say fewer numbers and pause after each one, so the important ones stick.

The pupil uses what the listener remembered to improve how the talk is organised. Evidences criterion 5.

If you finish early: answers

Drill: any clear, ordered set of instructions, for example: “Groups of 4 in a third of the court. 1: pass only to someone within 3 metres. 2: every pass must be flat, below head height. 3: the receiver must call a name before catching. 4: swap the defender every 30 seconds.”

Goals into the wind: Pentre Sidan scored 9 + 8 = 17 goals in Q2 and Q4.

Why this response is secure