Worked example · Music · Year 8
LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Clarity and vocabulary
A secure Year 8 response for Card A, Dawns y Dyfrgi, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It includes the answers to Step 1, a model cue card and model scripts for both rounds. Each script is about 130 words, which takes about 1 minute to say at a clear pace. Pupils’ own introductions will differ: judge them against the success criteria, not against these words.
(a) 1 P · 2 F · 3 P · 4 F · 5 P · 6 F · 7 F (it could suit children if “ostinato” is explained) · 8 P.
(b) “The air is played lento and pianissimo, over a drone held by a second fiddle.”
(c) “It starts very, very quietly, like a whisper. Then it slowly gets louder and louder, which musicians call a crescendo, until the river crashes through the village. Then it fades away again.”
Chooses register by audience: technical words for experts, one explained word and an image for children. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.
Explains clarity in terms of structure, fillers and vocabulary choices, not just “Y is better”. Evidences criteria 2 and 5.
| Part | Key words |
|---|---|
| Greeting and hook | Hello! Otter? Hands up |
| Title and meaning | Dawns y Dyfrgi = The Otter’s Dance |
| Story | shepherd boy, otter leaping on rocks, hummed tune |
| 3 things to listen for | jig = dance; allegro = fast and lively; melody leaps like otter |
| Audience task | listen for last time: louder (crescendo) |
| Last line | Here is … |
“Hello, everyone! Hands up if you have ever seen an otter. Otters are brilliant jumpers, and our next tune is all about one. It’s called Dawns y Dyfrgi, which means The Otter’s Dance. Long ago, a shepherd boy in Cwm Tawelan watched an otter leaping from rock to rock in the river. He hummed a tune to match its jumps, and that tune became this dance. It’s a jig, a happy dance tune, and it’s played allegro: that means fast and lively. Listen to the fiddle. Its notes jump up and down, just like the otter. Here’s a challenge. The tune is played lots of times, and the very last time it gets louder and louder. See if you can spot when that happens. Here is Dawns y Dyfrgi!”
A question hooks the audience, each music word is explained in child-friendly language and linked to the story, and the challenge keeps them listening. Short sentences make it easy to say clearly. Evidences criteria 1, 3 and 4.
“Good evening. Our next piece is a jig from Cwm Tawelan, Dawns y Dyfrgi, The Otter’s Dance. The story goes that a shepherd boy watched an otter leaping on the rocks of the river Tawelan and shaped a melody around its jumps, and you can still hear those wide leaps in the fiddle line. It is in 6/8, with the lilting two-in-a-bar feel you would expect of a jig, and we take it allegro. The structure is a simple AABB. The triple harp supplies the chords and a hand drum keeps the pulse. We play it mezzo forte, but listen for the crescendo to forte on the final time through, when the otter, we like to think, makes its last and biggest leap. Dawns y Dyfrgi.”
The register is now formal: no questions to the audience, a calm and confident tone, longer sentences and technical terms (6/8, AABB, mezzo forte) used accurately without explanation, because this audience knows them. Evidences criteria 2, 3 and 4.
Feedback grid, Round 1 (for a speaker on Card D): clarity 3, pace 2, volume 3, music words 2, eye contact 1. Comment: “Great story about the flood, but you said ‘rubato’ without explaining it and read from your card most of the time.”
Step 7 reflection: “Pausing helped me most. In Round 1 I rushed and my listeners said my pace was 1, so in Round 2 I paused after the title and after the story, and I scored 3. For the folk club I cut the questions and used 6/8 and AABB without explaining them, which sounded more professional. My target is to look up at the end of every sentence instead of reading my cue card.”
Feedback is specific and linked to the criteria. The reflection names a strategy, uses evidence from the grids and sets a clear target. Evidences criterion 5.