Worked example · Music · Year 10

Graphing sound levels in a band rehearsal

LNF: Numeracy → Learning that statistics represent data and that probability models chance helps us make informed inferences and decisions → Representing data

What this is

A secure Year 10 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Scales: 1 square = 5 minutes across; vertical axis from 60 dB(A) with a break, 1 square = 2 dB(A). Drummer frequencies 1, 4, 4, 10. Drummer median 90, mean 87 (1653 ÷ 19), range 31 dB(A). Rhys’s bars show 87 and 80; 87 ÷ 80 = 1.0875, so his claim is false. Highest reading at both places: 20:05. At or above 85 dB(A): 12 drummer readings and 9 mixing desk readings out of 19.

Step 1: choose the graph and the scales

(a) The readings are taken over time, and a line graph shows how the level rises and falls through the rehearsal. Two lines on one graph make the 2 places easy to compare. A pie chart shows parts of a whole, and these readings are not parts of a total.

(b) 90 ÷ 5 = 18 intervals, so 1 square = 5 minutes. The graph uses 18 of the 20 squares.

(c) Start at 60 and use 2 dB(A) per square: 60 to 100 is 40 ÷ 2 = 20 squares, which fits in 22. Starting at 0 would squash every line into the top of the grid. Because the axis does not start at 0, I draw a zig-zag break at the bottom of the vertical axis.

The choice of graph is justified, and each scale is worked out from the size of the grid and the spread of the data. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.

Step 2: the line graph

100908070600 0153045607590 85 dB(A) Minutes after 19:00 Sound level, dB(A) Drummer Mixing desk

Title: Sound levels during the Glasfryn Youth Band rehearsal, 19:00 to 20:30. The dashed line marks 85 dB(A), the upper exposure action value. The two lines have the same shape, and the drummer line is always above the mixing desk line.

Even scales, an axis break, units on both axes, a key and a title. The points are joined with straight lines because the level between readings is not known. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.

Step 3: frequency table and bar chart

Reading, dB(A)Drummer readingsFrequency
60 to 69681
70 to 7970, 72, 75, 784
80 to 8982, 84, 86, 884
90 to 9990, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 96, 97, 98, 9910
Total19

Bar chart: frequency axis from 0 to 10, 1 square = 1 reading. Pairs of bars: 60 to 69 (drummer 1, desk 4), 70 to 79 (4, 3), 80 to 89 (4, 10), 90 to 99 (10, 2). The tallest drummer bar is in 90 to 99; the tallest desk bar is in 80 to 89.

The total of 19 checks that no reading was missed. The equal groups of 10 make the bars fair to compare. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 4: averages and range

(a) 68, 70, 72, 75, 78, 82, 84, 86, 88, 90, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 96, 97, 98, 99

Median: 19 readings, so the middle is the 10th: 90 dB(A).
Mean: total 1653 ÷ 19 = 87 dB(A).
Range: 99 − 68 = 31 dB(A).

(b) The break readings (70 and 68) and the warm-up readings pull the mean down. The median, 90 dB(A), is a better description of a typical reading while the band was playing. Both averages are higher than at the mixing desk (median 84, mean 80), and the drummer’s readings are a little more spread out (range 31 against 29).

Correct method for each measure, with a check that 19 values were used. The comparison uses an average and the range together. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 5: Rhys’s graph

(a) Drummer 87, mixing desk 80 dB(A).

(b) 1. The axis starts at 79, not 0, and there is no break to warn the reader, so the desk bar is tiny. 2. The scale is uneven: the labels go up by 1 (79, 80, 81, 82), then by 3 (to 85), then by 5 (to 90), but the gaps are the same size. This stretches the bottom of the axis.

(c) No. 4 × 80 = 320, and 87 is nowhere near that. 87 ÷ 80 = 1.0875, so the drummer’s mean is only about 1.09 times the desk’s mean. The drummer bar is 4.4 times as tall only because of the axis.

(d) Start the axis at 0 with equal steps (for example every 10), or start at a higher value but show a clear break, use equal steps, and write the values on the bars.

Both faults are named and explained, and the claim is tested with a calculation. Evidences criterion 6.

Step 6: conclusions

The loudest part of the rehearsal was the rock songs from 19:55 to 20:15. The highest reading at both places was at 20:05: 99 dB(A) at the drummer and 91 dB(A) at the desk. The quietest was the break at 19:50 (68 and 62 dB(A)). The drummer was louder at every reading, by 5 to 9 dB(A), and 7 dB(A) higher on average. 12 of the 19 drummer readings and 9 of the 19 desk readings were at or above 85 dB(A). These are single readings from one evening, and the 80 and 85 dB(A) values are for a person’s daily or weekly personal noise exposure, so the readings alone cannot show whether the law was broken. The drummer should wear hearing protection, especially for the rock songs, and the band could take a short break in the middle of the loudest section.

Every claim has a number from the data, the real noise values are used accurately, and the limit of the data is stated. Evidences criterion 6.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure