Worked example · Geography · Year 9
LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Collaborative talk
A model of secure Year 9 work by a pupil playing the Wildlife officer, with a short extract of good group talk, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. There is no right decision: groups may choose A, B or C. What matters is that the decision comes from listening, facts and compromise. Most groups that work well end with Option B and specific conditions.
(a) 1. The extension would destroy 5 hectares of old woodland, which cannot be replaced by planting young trees. 2. The 2024 survey found signs of hazel dormice, a protected species. 3. Replanting 8 hectares only happens after 15 years of digging, so wildlife loses its home for a long time.
(b) To the Quarry manager: “Could the extension avoid the 5 hectares of woodland and still be worth digging?”
(c) A smaller extension that leaves the old woodland alone, with a wider dormouse corridor.
Every point uses a fact from the fact file. The pupil plans a question that opens up an option, and a compromise before the meeting starts. Evidences criteria 2 and 4.
Chair: Thank you, everyone. So far, the main points are jobs, lorries past the school and the woodland. Can we look for a compromise?
Resident: I understand the jobs matter. However, 110 lorries a day past the school is too many.
Quarry manager: What would you accept if the lorries did not run at school start and finish times?
Resident: No lorries from 08:15 to 09:15 and from 14:45 to 15:45 would help a lot.
Wildlife officer: Building on that, could the quarry leave the 5 hectares of woodland out of the plan?
Quarry manager: That would take about 3 years off the 15, but we could live with it if the rest is agreed.
Chair: Can we agree on Option B with those two conditions? Let’s check with everyone.
Speakers stay in role, use the useful phrases, ask questions that lead to options, build on each other and reach a compromise. The Chair sums up and checks for agreement. Evidences criteria 1, 3 and 4.
| Role | Their main point |
|---|---|
| Quarry manager | 42 jobs depend on it; the quarry closes in 3 years without it. |
| Resident | 110 lorries a day past the school; dust and blasting. |
| Apprentice | Few jobs for young people in the valley; wants to stay. |
| Chair | Summed up three issues: jobs, lorries, woodland. |
Short, accurate notes of each person’s main point show active listening. Evidences criterion 3.
Our group recommends Option B, by a vote of 4 to 1 (the Resident voted C).
Conditions: 1. No lorries from 08:15 to 09:15 and from 14:45 to 15:45 on school days. 2. The 5 hectares of old woodland are left out of the extension. 3. The dust is checked every month, and the results are published.
Main reason: it keeps most of the jobs for about 12 years while protecting the school run and the dormice habitat.
The decision is clear, the conditions are specific and measurable, and the reason links jobs, people and the environment. Evidences criterion 4.
(b) The turning point was when the Quarry manager asked the Resident, “What would you accept?” It moved us from arguing to finding a solution. I built on it by asking about the woodland.
(c) Out of role, I think Option B is right, because closing the quarry would hurt families, but the old woodland cannot be replaced. I would also want the community fund spent on a safer crossing by the school.
The pupil identifies what moved the group forward, names their own contribution, and gives a personal view with a reason. Evidences criterion 5.