Worked example · History · Year 7

Hot-seating the builders of Castell Aberwern

LNF: Literacy → Speaking → Questioning

What this is

A secure Year 7 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key for Step 2. The key idea: open questions and follow-up questions get people talking, and a good listener builds each new question on the last answer. For the hot seat there is no single right answer; look for open starters, at least 2 follow-ups per round and notes that record what was actually said.

Step 2: open or closed?

QuestionAnswer
1. How old are you?C (a number)
2. What is a normal working day like for you?O
3. Do you like the castle?C (yes or no)
4. Why do you think the king built the castle here?O
5. Is the work dangerous?C (yes or no)
6. How has your life changed since 1283?O
7. Were you born in Wales?C (yes or no)
8. What worries you most about the future?O

Question 3 as an open question: “What do you think about the castle, and why?”

Question 5 as an open question: “Describe the most dangerous part of your work.”

“How old are you?” starts with “how” but is still closed, because the answer is one number. The pupil judges by the answer a question needs, not by its first word. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: question plan

CharacterOpen questions
Gwenllian1. How did you feel when the officials took your land?
2. Why do you sell bread to the English workers?
3. What would you like your children’s lives to be like?
Walter1. Describe the job you do on the castle.
2. Why did you come to Wales?
3. What is the hardest thing about living on the site?
Hywel1. Explain why your parents disagree about your job.
2. What have you learned from working with the English workers?
3. What would happen if you asked to train as a mason?

Follow-up for anyone: “You said you need the money. Why is that more important to you than how you feel about the king?”

Every question is open and the starters vary. The follow-up picks up a phrase from an answer. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.

Step 4: note-taker’s notes (Round 1, Gwenllian)

Key pointsFollow-ups heard
Land by the river taken in 1283 for the castle and town. Given a worse field up the valley. Husband died fighting for Llywelyn. Sells bread every morning, makes a bit of money. Pays a toll at the town market and cannot live inside the walls. Angry but needs the money.✓ ✓ ✓
“You said you have to pay a toll. How does that feel when the workers are English and do not pay?”

Interviewer’s note: the most interesting thing was that Gwenllian gains money from the castle and loses land because of it, both at the same time.

The notes are short phrases, not full sentences, and they record the answers rather than the questions. The follow-up quoted builds directly on an answer. Evidences criteria 2 and 4.

Step 5: summary and reflection

(a) The castle changed life in different ways for different people. Gwenllian lost her best land and cannot live in the new town, but she earns money selling bread to the workers. Walter was sent from Chester and misses his family, but he is paid and proud of the work. Hywel earns a wage but his family disagree about working for the English king. (63 words)

(b) “Explain why your parents disagree about your job” got the longest answer, because it asked for reasons and about two people, so Hywel had to give both sides.

(c) “How did Welsh people feel about the new castle towns 50 years later, once they were used to them?”

The summary pulls together what was heard from three characters and explains how the castle affected each. The reflection explains why a question worked. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.

If you finish early: ideas

Why this response is secure