Worked example · History · Year 8
LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis
A secure Year 8 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. The key idea: Source C is the most reliable for how the town treated the marchers. It was written by an eyewitness on the morning after, in a private letter, and its facts match Source A. Source A has useful facts but a hostile opinion. Source B was written 50 years later by someone who was not there, and it exaggerates (“every town”). Pupils may argue for a different source if they use who, when and why and quote the sources.
| Facts | Opinions |
|---|---|
| About 300 men from the South Wales valleys marched into Kingsford. | “It is a great pity that these men have been led astray by troublemakers.” |
| They were given soup and bread in the Temperance Hall by local volunteers. | “Honest working men would be better employed looking for work.” |
| The Mayor refused to meet the leaders of the march. | The Mayor “quite rightly” refused. |
Words showing the writer’s view: “led astray by troublemakers” and “tramping the roads”. Both make the marchers sound foolish and a nuisance.
The pupil sees that one sentence can hold both: “The Mayor refused” is a fact, but “quite rightly” is the writer’s opinion. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.
| Who? Were they there? | When? | Why? | |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | A reporter for a local paper that supported the government. Yes, an eyewitness. | At the time: the day after the marchers arrived. | To inform readers, but also to persuade them that the march was wrong. |
| B | Gwyneth Morgan, a marcher’s daughter. No, she was 11 and at home. | 50 years later, in 1986. | To remember and honour her father for a local history book. |
| C | Emlyn Morgan, a marcher. Yes, an eyewitness. | At the time: the morning after. | A private letter to reassure his wife and send news. |
Each judgement covers who, when and why, and notes whether the writer was an eyewitness. Evidences criterion 3.
(a) Gwyneth probably heard the story from her father, many times, over many years. Stories told again and again can grow. He was proud of the march, so he may have remembered the cheering and forgotten the shouting. She also writes as a proud daughter, so she is unlikely to say anything bad about the march.
(b) Emlyn does not want Annie to worry, and she has the children to look after with very little money. He might play down how tired, hungry or cold he is, or how unfriendly some people were. He even calls sleeping on the workhouse floor “dry” rather than cold or hard.
The pupil works out ideas the writers never state, using clues in the provenance and the wording. Evidences criterion 4.
| How the town treated the marchers | |
|---|---|
| A | Volunteers gave soup and bread; shopkeepers closed early; the Mayor refused to meet them. |
| B | In every town crowds cheered and women gave them food. People were “wonderful”. |
| C | Mixed: some kept doors shut and a few shouted “go home”, but the ladies in the hall gave soup and bread. |
A and C agree most: both say they got soup and bread in a hall, slept in the old workhouse, and that not everyone was welcoming. B disagrees, because it says everyone was friendly.
Details are cross-checked across the sources. Evidences criterion 5.
Source C is the most reliable for finding out how people in the towns treated the marchers, because Emlyn Morgan was there and wrote it the morning after, in a private letter. For example, he says “some of the town kept their doors shut” but “the ladies in the hall gave us hot soup”. This is backed up by Source A, which also mentions soup from volunteers and shops closing early. However, Source B is less reliable because Gwyneth was not there and wrote it 50 years later, and “in every town crowds came out to cheer” is an exaggeration. Even Source C has a weakness: Emlyn wanted to stop Annie worrying, so he may have made things sound better than they were.
123 words. The paragraph gives a clear judgement, supports it with who, when and why, uses short quotations from two sources, explains why another source is weaker, and admits a weakness in the chosen source. Evidences criteria 3 and 5.