Worked example · PE · Year 7
DCF: Producing → Evaluating and improving digital content
A secure Year 7 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key: all 10 language errors and all 3 factual errors are listed in Step 3. Pupils may list the language errors in a different order.
(a) The big cartoon dumbbell, then the mix of fonts.
(b) No. When and where are in tiny pale grey writing at the bottom, so I could not read them in 5 seconds. “Sports hall” is hidden in the middle of a paragraph.
Tests the poster against its purpose before anything else. Evidences criterion 1.
| Criterion | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | 1 | You cannot find when, where or how to sign up quickly. |
| Hierarchy | 1 | The cartoon takes half the space; the most important details are the smallest text. |
| Contrast | 1 | Pale yellow title and light grey details on white are almost invisible from a distance. |
| Consistency | 1 | Six different fonts, each line in a new one. |
| Colour not the only clue | 1 | Red and green show harder and easier stations, but there is no key and no symbol, so a red-green colour-blind pupil sees no difference. |
Every score is backed by something specific on the poster. Evidences criterion 1.
| No. | Error | Correction | Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CIRCIUT!!! | CIRCUIT | Spelling (and one exclamation mark at most) |
| 2 | are new | our new | Grammar (wrong word) |
| 3 | circuit’s club | circuit club | Punctuation (no apostrophe: nothing belongs to it) |
| 4 | Its free | It’s free | Punctuation (it is) |
| 5 | welcome, you | welcome. You | Punctuation (comma splice) |
| 6 | dont | don’t | Punctuation |
| 7 | excercise | exercise | Spelling |
| 8 | sqauts | squats | Spelling |
| 9 | trainers PE kit water bottle | trainers, PE kit and a water bottle | Punctuation (list) |
| 10 | friday | Friday | Punctuation (capital letter) |
(b) 1. It says 8 stations but lists only 7: lunges are missing. 2. It says work for 30 minutes at each station; it should be 30 seconds. 3. It ends “See you every wednesday!” but the club runs on Tuesdays and Thursdays.
All 10 language errors found and correctly classified, and every wrong fact checked against the PE department’s facts rather than guessed. The minutes error matters most: 8 stations of 30 minutes would take 4 hours. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.
(a) Join our new circuit club in the sports hall. It’s free, and you don’t need to be sporty. Circuits are great exercise for your heart and lungs. (27 words)
(b) Every session starts with a 5-minute warm-up and ends with a cool-down and stretches, so wear trainers with the laces tied.
Shorter than the original, every error fixed, and the safety sentence uses the facts from the source. Evidences criteria 2 and 4.
Lunchtime Fitness Circuit
Tuesdays and Thursdays · 12:40 to 13:15 · Sports hall
Years 7 and 8 · Free
Join our new circuit club. It’s free, and you don’t need to be sporty.
8 stations, 30 seconds each, 30 seconds rest: star jumps ▲, squats ●, press-ups ▲, plank ●, step-ups ●, skipping ▲, shuttle runs ▲, lunges ●
▲ harder ● easier: you choose
Warm-up first, stretches at the end. Bring trainers, PE kit and a water bottle.
Sign up with Mrs Jenkins in the PE office by Friday
Labels the pupil drew: (1) title, then when and where, in the biggest text at the top, so the 5-second test works; (2) one font (Arial) in two sizes, bold for the important parts; (3) dark blue and black on white for strong contrast; (4) triangles and circles as well as words, so colour-blind pupils can tell harder from easier; (5) cartoon removed, small photo of step-ups instead; (6) how to sign up at the bottom, big enough to read.
Each change fixes a problem scored 1 in Step 2, and the labels explain the reason, not just the change. Evidences criterion 5.
(a) Alt text: “Three Year 7 pupils doing step-ups on benches in the school sports hall.” (13 words)
(b) I moved the time, day and place to the top in large writing, because nobody could find them before. I used one clear font in dark colours on white, so the poster can be read from across the corridor. I fixed the 10 language mistakes and the 3 wrong facts, including 30 minutes, which should have been 30 seconds.
Alt text describes what is seen, briefly, without “image of”. The explanation links each change to the problem it solves. Evidences criteria 4 and 5.
Any clear shape pair works, for example a triangle for harder and a circle for easier, explained in a key.
“Lunchtime fitness circuit, Tuesdays and Thursdays, 12:40, sports hall. Free for Years 7 and 8. Bring trainers and water, and sign up with Mrs Jenkins by Friday.” (about 10 seconds)