Worked example · Mathematics and Numeracy · Year 6

Improving a maths help page on long multiplication

DCF: Producing → Evaluating and improving digital content

Also assessed, LNF: Literacy → Writing → Proofreading, editing and improving

What this is

A secure Year 6 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Key figures: estimate 50 × 40 = 2000; 47 × 36 = 1692 (282 + 1410); the group’s wrong line is 141, which should be 1410; the 8 errors are 3 spelling (befor, freind, easyer), 3 punctuation (here, dont, missing question mark) and 2 grammar (We was, it help). Early finishers: 64 × 27 = 1728; the group’s way gives 576, which is 1152 too small.

Step 1: purpose and audience

QuestionAnswer
(a) What is the page for?To explain how to multiply a 2-digit number by a 2-digit number. It is a set of instructions.
(b) Who is it for?Year 5 pupils who are learning long multiplication.
(c) Who made it?Cerys, Osian and Tomos, Year 6 at Ysgol Bryn Celyn.
(d) What should a reader be able to do?Work out a sum like 47 × 36 on their own and get it right.
(e) Where will people read it?On a screen, on the school website. Readers scroll, so the method should be near the top, and anything flashing will pull their eyes away.

Purpose and audience are both named, and (e) links where the page is read to its layout. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: check the maths

(a) 47 is about 50 and 36 is about 40, so the answer is about 50 × 40 = 2000.

(b) Column method

4 7 × 3 6 ------- 2 8 2 (47 × 6) 1 4 1 0 (47 × 30) ------- 1 6 9 2

(c) Grid method

×407
301200210
624042

Total: 1200 + 210 + 240 + 42 = 1692. Both methods agree.

(d) The second line, 141, is wrong. It should be 1410. The 3 in 36 is in the tens column, so it means 30. 47 × 30 = 1410, so you need a placeholder zero in the ones column before you multiply by 3. Then 282 + 1410 = 1692, not 423.

(e) The estimate says the answer is about 2000. 423 is nowhere near 2000, so the group would have known something was wrong. 1692 is close to 2000, so it makes sense.

The pupil works out the answer 2 ways, names the wrong line and explains the mistake using place value. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: score the page

CriterionScoreReason
Content2It has a method (part 4), an example (part 5), tips (part 6) and a way to check (part 7). But the method misses the placeholder zero, and part 7 is so small and pale that readers will miss it.
Accuracy1The example in part 5 gives 423, but 47 × 36 = 1692. Part 6 has 8 spelling, punctuation and grammar errors.
Layout1The big rocket (part 2) and the flashing box (part 3) push the method down the page. Part 4 is a wall of text with no numbered steps. The most useful tip (part 7) is the hardest to read.
Suitable for Year 52The friendly start (part 1) is good for Year 5. But part 4 is one long sentence, which is hard to follow, and the “Click here to win” box looks like a trick that a younger pupil might click.
Total6 out of 12 

I think the group put the rocket near the top to make the page look fun and to catch Year 5’s eye. That is a good reason, but the rocket has nothing to do with multiplying, so it wastes space. A picture showing 36 = 30 + 6 would be fun and helpful.

Every score has a reason that points to a part number, and the pupil explains the group’s reason for the layout before judging it. Any score of 1 or 2 is fine if the reason supports it; a score of 3 for accuracy is not secure. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: proofread the top tips

SentenceErrorCorrectionKind of error
1hereHerePunctuation (capital letter at the start of a sentence)
3beforbeforeSpelling
4dontdon’tPunctuation (apostrophe for a missing letter)
5freindfriendSpelling
636 × 47.36 × 47?Punctuation (it is a question, so it needs a question mark)
7We wasWe wereGrammar (the verb must agree with “we”)
7it help youit helps youGrammar (the verb must agree with “it”)
8easyereasierSpelling (change y to i, then add er)

Corrected paragraph: Here are some top tips from our group. Always line up your digits carefully so you do not get muddled. Check your times tables before you start. If you are stuck, don’t give up. Ask a friend for help. Did you know that 47 × 36 gives the same answer as 36 × 47? We were really pleased with our page and we hope it helps you. Some people find the grid method easier, so you could try that too.

Strategy: I read it one sentence at a time in a whisper. Hearing “we was” and “it help” told me they sounded wrong.

All 8 errors are found, corrected and sorted by kind, and the pupil names the strategy they used. Evidences criterion 4 (literacy).

Step 5: redraft the method

How to multiply a 2-digit number by a 2-digit number

1. Estimate first. Round both numbers to the nearest 10 and multiply them. ★

2. Write the numbers in columns: tens under tens, ones under ones.

3. Multiply the top number by the ones digit. Write the answer on line 1.

4. Write a 0 in the ones column of line 2. This is the placeholder zero, because the next digit is tens. ★

5. Multiply the top number by the tens digit. Write the answer next to the 0.

6. Add line 1 and line 2. Check your answer is close to your estimate.

Example: 47 × 36. Estimate: 50 × 40 = 2000. Line 1: 47 × 6 = 282. Line 2: 0, then 47 × 3 = 141, so line 2 is 1410. 282 + 1410 = 1692. That is close to 2000.

Another correct example a pupil might choose: 23 × 14. Line 1: 23 × 4 = 92. Line 2: 23 × 10 = 230. 92 + 230 = 322 (estimate 20 × 10 = 200).

StarWhat I changed, and whereWhy it makes the page better
1I moved the estimating tip from part 7 into step 1, and made it normal-sized text.It was too small and pale to read. Now readers estimate first, so they can tell if their answer is sensible.
2I added step 4, the placeholder zero.The old method left it out, so it taught the same mistake as the example. Now the example gives the right answer, 1692.

One long sentence becomes 6 short numbered steps, one action each. Both changes are marked, with where and why. Evidences criterion 5 (literacy) and criterion 2.

Step 6: leave a comment

Diolch, Cerys, Osian and Tomos! Your page has a really friendly start (part 1), so Year 5 will not feel scared. Your top tips (part 6) are useful too, especially lining up the digits.

One thing to improve: in your example (part 5) the second line should be 1410, not 141, because the 3 means 30. Please add a placeholder zero, so the answer becomes 1692.

My question: could you make your estimating tip (part 7) bigger and put it next to your example, so readers can check their answers?

2 strengths, 1 improvement with how to fix it, and 1 question, all linked to part numbers and written kindly, as a comment on an online platform should be. Evidences criterion 6.

If you finish early: answers

A helpful picture: the number 36 split into 30 and 6, with an arrow from 30 to “47 × 30 = 1410” and an arrow from 6 to “47 × 6 = 282”.

64 × 27: 64 × 7 = 448, 64 × 20 = 1280, 448 + 1280 = 1728. The group’s way: 64 × 2 = 128, 448 + 128 = 576. 1728 − 576 = 1152, so their answer is 1152 too small.

A “Try it yourself” box, for example: 32 × 21 = 672 (32 + 640) and 25 × 13 = 325 (75 + 250).

Why this response is secure