Worked example · Geography · Year 7
LNF: Literacy → Writing → Proofreading, editing and improving
A secure Year 7 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key: all 27 planted mistakes are listed below, followed by a model improved report. The key idea: proofreading fixes the mistakes, but editing and improving make the writing clear, organised and formal. Elin’s biggest problems are not only spelling: 3 facts are wrong, there are no paragraphs and the report has no conclusion.
| Sentence | Symbol | Mistake | Correction |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | C | amazon | Amazon |
| 1 | C | south america | South America |
| 1 | C | brazil | Brazil |
| 2 | F | River Nile | River Amazon (the Nile is in Africa) |
| 3 | sp | equater | Equator (also needs a capital letter) |
| 3 | P | all year, the temprature | all year. The temperature (comma splice) |
| 3 | sp | temprature | temperature |
| 4 | F | hardly ever rains … dry as a desert | it rains heavily all year, about 2,000 mm or more a year |
| 5 | P | 4 layers, from the top | 4 layers. From the top, (comma splice) |
| 5 | sp | emergant | emergent |
| 5 | F | canopy, emergant layer, … | emergent layer, canopy, understorey, forest floor |
| 6 | ww | really really tall | often 40 m tall or more |
| 6 | ww | loads of animals | many of the animals |
| 8 | ww | cool | special (or leave it out) |
| 8 | sp | addaptations | adaptations |
| 9 | P | dont | do not (or don’t) |
| 10 | sp | butress | buttress |
| 11, 13, 14 | R | Also … Also … Also | In addition, Furthermore, As a result |
| 12 | ww | loads of the rainforest | large areas of the rainforest |
| 12 | sp | deforrestation | deforestation |
| 13 | R | and … and … and … and | cattle ranching, soya farming, logging, mining and roads |
| 14 | ww | loads of stuff | carbon dioxide |
| 15 | ww | there homes | their homes (or habitats) |
| 16 | C | brazil | Brazil |
| 17 | P | Thats | That’s (but the sentence should be replaced, see ^) |
| 3, 5, 8, 12, 15 | // | no paragraphs | new paragraphs start at sentences 3, 5, 8, 12 and 15 |
| 17 | ^ | no conclusion | a conclusion that sums up and gives a view |
Also accept: a comma before which in sentences 11 and 14; biggest changed to largest tropical in sentence 2; they in sentence 13 marked ww because it does not say who.
A secure Year 7 pupil finds at least 15 of the 27 and records 10 correctly, including at least one capital letter, one spelling and one punctuation mistake. Evidences criterion 1.
| Symbol | Type | How many | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| C | Capital letter | 4 | south america → South America |
| sp | Spelling | 6 | deforrestation → deforestation |
| P | Punctuation | 4 | dont → do not |
| ww | Wrong, vague or informal word | 6 | loads of stuff → carbon dioxide |
| F | Wrong fact | 3 | River Nile → River Amazon |
| R | Repetition | 2 | Also at the start of 3 sentences |
| // and ^ | Paragraphs and missing parts | 2 | no paragraphs; no conclusion |
(b) Wrong facts matter most, because a reader would learn something untrue, such as that the Amazon is as dry as a desert. Spelling and capital letters matter too, but the reader can usually still understand what Elin means.
The counts total 27. Accept any type in (b) if the reason explains the effect on the reader. Evidences criterion 2.
(a) It is the largest tropical rainforest in the world, and the River Amazon flows across it into the Atlantic Ocean.
(b) It rains heavily all year, and many places get about 2,000 mm of rain a year or more.
(c) The rainforest has 4 layers. From the top, they are the emergent layer, the canopy, the understorey and the forest floor.
Every correction comes from the fact file, and the comma splice and spelling in sentence 5 are fixed at the same time. Evidences criteria 1 and 3.
| Paragraph | Sentences | Heading |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 to 2 | Introduction: where it is |
| 2 | 3 to 4 | Climate |
| 3 | 5 to 7 | The 4 layers |
| 4 | 8 to 11 | Adaptations of plants |
| 5 | 12 to 14 | Causes of deforestation |
| 6 | 15 to 16 | Effects of deforestation |
(b) Deforestation is the cutting down or burning of large areas of forest. The biggest cause in the Amazon is cattle ranching, because farmers clear the forest to make pasture for their cattle. In addition, land is cleared for soya farming, and much of the soya is used to feed animals. Furthermore, loggers cut down valuable hardwood trees such as mahogany, and mining companies dig for gold and iron ore. Roads such as the Trans-Amazonian Highway make this worse, because they let people reach new areas of forest. As a result, large areas are burned, which releases carbon dioxide into the air.
About 100 words. Each paragraph has one topic. The rewrite uses precise terms (pasture, hardwood, carbon dioxide), 4 linking words instead of “Also”, a list with commas and 2 extra details from the fact file (mahogany, the Trans-Amazonian Highway). Evidences criteria 4 and 5.
In conclusion, the Amazon is the largest tropical rainforest in the world, and its hot, wet climate and 4 layers make it home to a huge variety of plants and animals. However, deforestation for cattle ranching, soya farming, logging, mining and roads is destroying large areas of it. Although deforestation brings jobs and money to Brazil, it destroys habitats, washes away the soil and adds to climate change. Therefore, I think the Amazon should be protected, for example by replanting trees and stopping illegal logging.
The conclusion sums up both halves of the report, weighs the jobs and money against the damage and ends with a clear view. Evidences criterion 6.
My partner did not tick “At least 3 linking words”.
Before: “Loggers cut down mahogany. Miners dig for gold.”
After: “Furthermore, loggers cut down hardwood trees such as mahogany, and miners dig for gold.”
The pupil acts on the feedback: the improved sentence links the ideas and adds a precise term. Evidences criterion 7.
The Amazon rainforest
Introduction. The Amazon rainforest is in South America, and about 60 percent of it is in Brazil. It is the largest tropical rainforest in the world, and the River Amazon flows across it into the Atlantic Ocean.
Climate. The Amazon is close to the Equator, so the climate is hot and wet all year. The average temperature is about 27 °C in every month. It rains heavily on most days, and many places get about 2,000 mm of rain a year or more.
The 4 layers. The rainforest has 4 layers. From the top, they are the emergent layer, the canopy, the understorey and the forest floor. The emergent trees are often 40 m tall or more, and the canopy forms a thick roof where many of the animals live. As a result, the forest floor is very dark, because only about 2 percent of the sunlight reaches it.
Adaptations of plants. Plants have special adaptations that help them to survive. For example, many leaves have drip tips, so heavy rain runs off quickly and the leaves do not rot. Tall trees have buttress roots to hold them up, because their roots are shallow. In addition, lianas climb up tree trunks to reach the sunlight in the canopy.
Causes of deforestation. The model paragraph from Step 5(b).
Effects of deforestation. When the trees are gone, heavy rain washes the soil and its nutrients away, and animals lose their habitats. On the other hand, some people argue that deforestation is good, because it creates jobs and Brazil earns money by selling beef, soya and timber.
Conclusion. The model conclusion from Step 6.
Every mistake is corrected, each paragraph has a heading and one topic, linking words join the ideas and the tone is formal throughout. Evidences criteria 1, 3, 4 and 5.