Worked example · English · Year 9
LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis
A secure Year 9 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. Step 1: 1971; two hundred pounds and a borrowed van; Mr Lloyd from the bank; since Christmas; the end of September; on the hook, next to the keys. Step 3 (a): command, question, exclamation, minor sentences. Step 4: Gareth gives the orders at the start (“Shut that door”), Siân at the end (“Sit down, Dad”). Inferences in Steps 2 to 4 can differ from these: accept any idea that is backed up by a quotation and a line number. Show this after pupils have tried the steps themselves.
(a) 1971 (line 18). (b) Two hundred pounds and a borrowed van (line 18). (c) Mr Lloyd from the bank (line 7). (d) Since Christmas (line 33). (e) The end of September (line 35). (f) On the hook, next to the keys (line 32).
Every answer is exact and has a line number, so it can be checked quickly. Evidences criterion 1.
| What Gareth says or does | What it suggests about him | Key word or short quotation |
|---|---|---|
| Line 6 | He is hurt that Siân left home, and he hides the hurt behind a sarcastic dig. Not looking up means he avoids her eyes, so she cannot see how he feels. | “Thought you might have forgotten” |
| Line 11 | He knows the bank letters do matter, so this is a way of avoiding them. The order about hinges pulls the talk back to ordinary shop work, where he is still the boss. | “the letters that matter” |
| Line 18 | He is proud of his family’s history and uses it to defend himself. His father’s success makes his own failure more painful, and the exclamation shows how strongly he feels. | “He’d laugh at the lot of them” |
| Line 25 | He cannot face the letters. Picking up a tool and putting it down shows he is restless and lost: the tools of his trade cannot fix this problem. | “does not touch them” |
| Line 38 | The shop is part of who he is. As a boy the keys made him feel important in the town, so losing the shop feels like losing his place in Aberhedydd. | “the keys to the whole town” |
Subtext: Gareth is frightened and ashamed. He knows the shop is failing, and it embarrasses him that the bank rang his daughter instead of him. Talking about hinges lets him pretend that everything is normal.
Each inference goes beyond what Gareth says to what he feels, and each one is backed by a short, exact quotation. Evidences criterion 2.
(a)
| Sentence | Type | What it shows about the speaker |
|---|---|---|
| “Pass me those hinges.” (line 11) | Command (imperative) | Gareth tries to stay in control and change the subject by treating Siân like a shop assistant. |
| “Have you?” (line 16) | Question | Siân’s first real challenge. Two words question whether there is still a shop to run, and the silence after it shows the words hit hard. |
| “Two hundred pounds!” (line 18) | Exclamation | Gareth’s pride and emotion break through. He repeats the figure because his father’s achievement matters so much to him. |
| “January. March. June.” (line 22) | Minor sentences | Siân lays out the months like evidence, one at a time, just as she lays out the letters. She is calm and firm, and the pressure on Gareth builds. |
(b) The full stop makes “Did he.” flat, not curious. Gareth does not want an answer. He is pretending not to care and trying to close the conversation down.
(c) Line 6, “He does not look up”: he avoids eye contact so that Siân cannot read his face. Line 8, he folds the bag “very carefully, twice”: he keeps his hands busy with a tiny task he can control, to delay the conversation he cannot control.
Each sentence type is named correctly and linked to what it shows about the character. The pupil explains how punctuation and stage directions carry meaning that the dialogue hides. Evidences criterion 3.
(a) In lines 2 to 13 Gareth gives the orders: “Shut that door” (line 2) and “Pass me those hinges” (line 11). In lines 29 to 31 Siân gives them: “Sit down, Dad” (line 29).
(b) The turning point is line 16, “Have you?”. It is the first time Siân challenges him, and Gareth stops working and puts the bag down. After this she controls the scene with the letters. By line 32 the shift is complete: Gareth sits, she is “taller than him”, and she takes off her coat, which shows she is staying and taking charge. (Line 21 or line 29 are also good choices if the reason is explained.)
(c) In line 1 the “large, heavy” keys stand for the shop and the weight of running it. In line 38 they stand for Gareth’s childhood, his father and his pride in belonging to the town. In line 41 he gives them to Siân, so they stand for handing over responsibility: he finally accepts the truth, and closing her fingers over them shows love and trust.
The pupil tracks who gives orders across the whole scene, picks a turning point and justifies it, and follows the key image as its meaning changes. Evidences criterion 4.
The writer presents Gareth as a proud man who is hiding his fear that the shop is failing. At the start he is in control. His first words are the imperative “Shut that door” (line 2), and he treats Siân like an assistant when he orders her to “Pass me those hinges” (line 11). These commands suggest he wants to keep the talk on shop work so that he never has to mention the bank. The stage directions show the same avoidance: he “does not look up” (line 6) and folds a bag “very carefully, twice” (line 8), as if small tasks are the only things he can still control. His flat minor sentences, “On a Tuesday. Busy man.” (line 9), sound careless, but the subtext is embarrassment.
The structure then shifts the power. After Siân’s short question “Have you?” (line 16), she gives the orders, “Sit down, Dad” (line 29), and he obeys. Finally the keys, which he once thought were “the keys to the whole town” (line 38), become an image of his pride and his father’s legacy. When he closes her fingers over them, he gives up control, sadly but with love.
About 200 words written in 20 minutes. It opens with a clear overview, then uses eight short embedded quotations, each with a line number. It names more than three features (imperative, stage directions, minor sentences, subtext, question, structure, image) and explains what each one shows about Gareth, not just what it is. The second paragraph follows the power shift in order and ends on the key image. Evidences criteria 2, 3, 4 and 5.