Worked example · Business · Year 11

Judging a digital marketing campaign: Pobty’r Cwm

DCF: Data and computational thinking → Data and information literacy

What this is

A secure Year 11 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. The big idea: social media won on clicks and new customers, but search engine advertising won on cost per order, profit after promotion and customers who came back; email looks best of all until the new evidence shows that most of its orders would have happened anyway. This practises GCSE Business Unit 3, sections 3.4 Marketing strategies for success and 3.3.4 Financial performance.

Step 2: the performance table

ChannelClick-through rate (%)Conversion rate (%)Cost per order (£)Revenue per £1 spent (£)
Social media adverts800 ÷ 40,000 = 2.040 ÷ 800 = 5.0480 ÷ 40 = 12.00880 ÷ 480 = 1.83
Search engine advertising480 ÷ 12,000 = 4.036 ÷ 480 = 7.5360 ÷ 36 = 10.00900 ÷ 360 = 2.50
Email to loyalty members225 ÷ 1,500 = 15.045 ÷ 225 = 20.060 ÷ 45 = 1.33810 ÷ 60 = 13.50
Printed leafletsno clicks20 ÷ 5,000 = 0.4 (of leaflets)300 ÷ 20 = 15.00400 ÷ 300 = 1.33

Every figure is correct and the working is shown. The leaflet conversion rate is labelled as a different measure, so it is not compared unfairly with the online ones. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: did each channel pay for itself?

ChannelGross profit (£)Minus spend (£)Left after promotion (£)
Social media adverts880 × 0.6 = 52848048
Search engine advertising900 × 0.6 = 540360180
Email to loyalty members810 × 0.6 = 48660426
Printed leaflets400 × 0.6 = 240300−60 (a loss)
Whole promotion2,990 × 0.6 = 1,7941,200594

Uses gross profit, not revenue, so the result shows whether each channel actually made the bakery money. Check: 48 + 180 + 426 − 60 = 594. Evidences criteria 1 and 4.

Step 4: testing the claim

(a) Cost per new customer: social media 480 ÷ 34 = £14.12; search 360 ÷ 24 = £15.00; email none found (0 new customers, as it only reaches existing members); leaflets 300 ÷ 12 = £25.00.

(b) Both halves are true. Social media had the most clicks (800, against 480 for search) and the most new customers (34), and the cheapest cost per new customer, £14.12. But clicks are not sales. Its conversion rate was only 5.0%, it cost £12.00 per order against £10.00 for search, and it left only £48 of gross profit after paying for itself, against £180 for search. Email took the most orders of all (45). So the claim is not enough to justify spending the whole budget on social media.

(c) The chart measures clicks, not orders or profit, so it rewards the channel that got people to look, not the one that got them to buy. It also leaves out the leaflets completely and ignores spend: social media had the biggest budget, £480, so it should get the most clicks. The title “SOCIAL MEDIA WINS!” is an opinion, not a description.

Tests each part of the claim against the data and separates “most” from “best value”. The chart criticism names what is measured and what is missing. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 5: the new evidence

 Social mediaSearchLeaflets
% of new customers who bought again5 ÷ 34 = 14.7%9 ÷ 24 = 37.5%6 ÷ 12 = 50.0%
Spend per returning customer (£)480 ÷ 5 = 96.00360 ÷ 9 = 40.00300 ÷ 6 = 50.00

This strengthens the case against Carys’s plan. Social media found the most new customers, but fewer than 1 in 6 came back, so each loyal customer cost £96, more than twice as much as through search (£40). Search reaches people who are already looking for a Welsh gift, so they are more likely to become regular buyers. Leaflets have the best return rate, but the numbers are small (6 of 12) and they are local shoppers who can walk in, so I would not rely on that figure alone. Leaflets are also undercounted: about 15 shop customers used the leaflet without the code.

The email figures in Step 2 are too good. If 31 of the 45 orders would have happened with no email, only 14 orders were really extra. That is 14 ÷ 45 × £810 = £252 of revenue, £151.20 of gross profit and £91.20 after the £60 cost, so about £4.29 per extra order. Email is still worth keeping, but it is not the £426 winner it first looked.

The conclusion is changed, not just repeated, and the email figures are recalculated using the new evidence. Small numbers are treated with caution. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.

Step 6: the recommendation

Carys should not put the whole £1,200 into social media. I recommend £60 on email, £640 on search engine advertising, £300 on social media and £200 on leaflets. Search engine advertising gave the best value: it cost £10.00 per order compared with £12.00 for social media, it left £180 of gross profit after paying for itself against only £48, and 37.5% of its new customers bought again, so each returning customer cost £40 compared with £96. This is because search reaches people already looking for Welsh cakes, while social media interrupts people who are scrolling, which is why its conversion rate was only 5.0%. Email should stay because it costs only £60; even though 31 of its 45 orders would probably have happened anyway, each extra order still cost about £4.29. However, Carys is right that social media found the most new customers, 34, at the lowest cost per new customer, £14.12, so cutting it completely would slow the growth of her customer base. Leaflets look weakest, losing £60, but the data undercounts them. The main limitation is that spending more on search may not bring the same results, because only so many people search for those phrases each month. Carys should add a “saw a leaflet” button on the till, then compare next year’s results channel by channel.

219 words. A clear decision with an exact split that adds up to £1,200, more than ten figures from the analysis, reasons that explain the figures rather than repeat them, a genuine counter-argument, and two limitations of the data with a practical fix. This is the shape of a strong “recommend” answer in the Unit 3 examination. Evidences criteria 2, 4 and 5.

If you finish early: answers

Free postage. At the moment customers pay the £6.50 postage on top. If Carys pays it instead, it becomes a cost of every box, so £6.50 comes off the gross profit of every order. On a £25 order, gross profit falls from £15.00 to £8.50. She would need data on how many more people would buy with free postage, for example by testing it for one week.

Fairer chart. Put all four channels on the horizontal axis and gross profit left after promotion, or cost per order, on the vertical axis, starting at zero. Title: “Gross profit left after promotion costs, by channel, November 2025”.

Consent. In the UK, businesses usually need a person’s consent before sending them marketing emails, with a limited exception for existing customers. This protects people’s personal data and inboxes, and the Information Commissioner’s Office can fine businesses that break the rules.

Why this response is secure