Worked example · Geography · Year 11

Judging bias in sources about a honeypot village

LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis

What this is

A secure Year 11 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. Claims tested against Source C: visitors +72.2% (not “nearly doubled”), tourism jobs +47.4% (accurate), holiday homes 27% (about 1 in 4, not 1 in 3), house prices +72.7% (exaggerated), school −40.6% (not half). The key idea: both one-sided sources exaggerate, in opposite directions, and the data sit between them.

Step 1: purpose

SourceWhoPurposeView
AThe village business groupTo persuade people to visitPositive
BA long-term residentTo complain and persuade readers that tourism is harmfulNegative
CThe community councilTo inform with dataNeutral
DA visiting walkerTo entertain and share an experienceMixed, mostly positive
EThe national park authorityTo inform and consult on solutionsNeutral, balanced

Each source’s writer is linked to its purpose. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: fact, opinion and bias

(b) “stunning village” and “the warmest welcome in Wales” are opinions dressed up as facts; “no better place for a day out” is a superlative that cannot be checked; “thriving, welcoming, alive!” is emotive advertising language. Source A also leaves out every problem.

(c) “Tourism is killing our village” and “the people who actually live here pay the price”. They make the reader feel angry and sympathetic, so the problems seem worse and the benefits are forgotten.

(d) Tom admits he parked on the verge “like everyone else”, which supports Source B’s point about blocked lanes, even though Tom is positive about his visit. He also confirms the path erosion and litter.

The pupil separates checkable claims from opinion and explains how bias works: word choice, exaggeration and what is left out. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: reliability

SourceScoreReason
A1 or 2Vested interest: the business group gains from more visitors. One-sided.
B2 or 3Real local experience, but emotional, one-sided and some figures are exaggerated.
C4Data from records, no obvious interest. But see (b).
D2 or 3Honest eyewitness, but one person on one day.
E4 or 5Measured over 10 years, balanced, considers all groups.

(b) Visitor numbers are only estimates from tickets and one path counter, and the car count was made by volunteers on a single day, which may not be typical.

Scores are justified by vested interest, balance and evidence, and the pupil questions even the data source. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: checking claims

ClaimSource CVerdict
Visitors nearly doubled180,000 to 310,000: 130,000 ÷ 180,000 × 100 = +72.2%Exaggerated
Jobs up by almost half95 to 140: 45 ÷ 95 × 100 = +47.4%Accurate
One in three houses a holiday home27%, which is about 1 in 4 (1 in 3 would be 33%)Exaggerated
House prices nearly doubled£165,000 to £285,000: 120,000 ÷ 165,000 × 100 = +72.7%Exaggerated
School lost half its children64 to 38: 26 ÷ 64 × 100 = −40.6%Exaggerated

(b) 900 cars on the busiest day but only 220 car park spaces, and the number of spaces has not changed since 2015.

Every claim is tested with a calculation, and the verdict matches the numbers. Both biased sources exaggerate, in opposite directions. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 5: a model extended answer (255 words)

Tourism has brought clear economic benefits to Llanfeuno. Source C shows that jobs in tourism rose from 95 to 140 between 2015 and 2025, an increase of 47%, so Source A is accurate when it says they rose by almost half. Source E, from the park authority, which has no reason to favour businesses, agrees that visitor spending supports local jobs. Even Tom in Source D praises the café.

However, the problems are serious. The share of homes that are second homes or holiday lets rose from 8% to 27%, and average house prices rose by 73%. This supports Gwenllian Rees in Source B, although she exaggerates: 27% is closer to one in four than one in three, and the school lost 41% of its pupils, not half. Her emotive language, such as “killing our village”, shows she is angry, but the data show her main point is right. Tourism also damages the environment. Source E reports that the path has widened from 1.5 m to 4.2 m, and 900 cars competed for 220 spaces on the busiest day, which explains why Tom parked on the verge.

Overall, tourism has been good for Llanfeuno’s economy but harmful to its community and environment. Source A is the least reliable, because the business group gains from visitors and leaves out every problem. Source E is the most balanced. The evidence suggests that tourism has helped only to a limited extent, and the benefits go mainly to businesses rather than residents, unless schemes such as park-and-ride are introduced.

The answer uses all 5 sources, checks claims against data, comments on reliability as it goes, and reaches a clear judgement on “to what extent” that follows from the evidence. Evidences criteria 3, 4 and 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure