Worked example · IT · Year 11
LNF: Literacy → Reading → Understanding, response and analysis
A secure Year 11 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Step 3: lines 2, 12 and 13 are F; lines 7 and 21 are O; lines 18 and 19 are U. Line 7 could be argued as a claim; accept either with a reason. Line 12 is Dafydd’s own account, which could be checked by looking at the email.
| Source | Gist |
|---|---|
| A | The centre explains the breach, what was taken and what it has done. |
| B | Local news warns members about fake refund emails after the breach. |
| C | An angry post claims everyone’s bank details were stolen. |
| Source A | Source B | Source C | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How many people? | 2,400 (line 3) | 2,400, from the centre, not confirmed (lines 9, 16) | 10,000, from “my mate” (line 18) |
| What information? | Names, emails, booking history; no bank details (lines 3, 4) | Names and emails; no bank details (line 9) | “EVERYONE’s bank details” (line 18) |
| When was it found? | 12 March (line 1) | “This week” (line 8) | “They KNEW for weeks” (line 19) |
| What should members do? | Passwords already reset; ignore emails asking for bank details (lines 5, 6) | Do not click links; use two-step verification (line 15) | Cancel your cards (line 20) |
Precise detail with line numbers across all three texts, which makes the disagreements easy to see. Evidences criterion 1.
2 F · 7 O · 12 F · 13 F · 18 U · 19 U · 21 O
Line 19 is an unsupported claim: it sounds like a fact, but no evidence is given, and Source A dates the discovery to 12 March, only a day before the post.
The pupil explains the difference between something stated confidently and something supported. Evidences criterion 2.
(a) “HACKED!!!”, “before it’s too late” and “useless”. The capital letters and exclamation marks feel like shouting, which creates panic and urgency, so readers share the post before they stop to check it. It was shared 318 times.
(b) “We take the security of your information extremely seriously” (line 7). The centre wants to keep its members and its reputation, so it has a reason to sound calm and in control, even if mistakes were made.
(c) Mostly fair. “Hack” is a dramatic word, but Source A admits an “unauthorised person” got in, so it is accurate. The rest of the headline is a practical warning, not a scare.
Both the angry source and the official source are analysed: the pupil sees that careful, calm wording can also be persuasive. Evidences criterion 3.
| Source A | Source B | Source C | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who, and would they know? | Centre manager; knows the systems best | A journalist; spoke to the centre, a member and an expert | Anonymous user; second-hand from “my mate” |
| Why written? | To inform members and protect the centre’s reputation | To report news and warn readers | To vent anger and get shares |
| Evidence or corroboration? | Specific figures and dates; reported to a regulator | A member’s first-hand account; admits what it cannot confirm | None; replies contradict it |
| Possible bias | May play down the problem | Relies on the centre for the figure | Strongly against the centre |
Each judgement considers who wrote it, why, and what evidence supports it. Evidences criterion 4.
Source A is useful because it comes from the centre manager, who knows the system, and it gives precise details such as “2,400 members” (line 3). However, the centre has a reason to reassure people, and phrases like “extremely seriously” (line 7) are designed to protect its reputation, so it may play down the problem.
Source B is more balanced. It gives a first-hand account from a member who received a fake refund email, and it admits that it “has not been able to confirm independently” the number affected (line 16). This honesty makes it more trustworthy. It corroborates Source A that no bank details were held, but it relies on the centre for that information.
Source C is the least reliable. It claims “EVERYONE’s bank details” were stolen, but its only evidence is “my mate”, and a reply says payments go through a different company, which matches Source A. Its emotive language aims to spread panic, not to inform.
Overall, Source B is the most reliable, then Source A, which is detailed but not independent. Source C should not be trusted at all.
184 words. A judgement on each source, 5 short quotations, a corroboration (A and B on bank details), a disagreement resolved with a reason (10,000 against 2,400) and a ranked conclusion. Evidences criteria 2, 4 and 5.
Calm post: “Llynwen Leisure says names and emails of 2,400 members may have been seen. No card details were held. Watch out for fake refund emails: the centre has not sent any. Don’t click links. Turn on two-step verification.” (39 words)
Questions for the manager: How do you know the person could not reach the payment system? Why did members only hear on 14 March, two days after you found it? Has an independent expert checked your figure of 2,400?