Worked example · Computer Science · Year 9

Linking a balanced answer on AI homework helpers

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Connectives and syntax

What this is

The answers to Steps 1 to 3 and model answers for Steps 4 and 5, annotated against the success criteria. Pupils’ own sentences will differ: check that each connective does the right job and that the punctuation is correct. The most common mistakes are a comma splice (“Chatbots help, they can be wrong.”), starting sentences with And, and a conclusion that gives no reason.

Step 1: what job does it do?

JobConnectives
Adding a pointmoreover, in addition
Contrastingalthough, whereas, however
Cause and effecttherefore, as a result
Giving an examplefor instance, such as
Conditionunless, if
Concludingon balance

Step 2: which type of sentence?

SentenceType
Chatbots are available at any time of day.Simple
Cai finds chatbots helpful, but Ms Rees is worried about copying.Compound
If pupils check the answer in a textbook, they are less likely to learn something false.Complex
Some tools are free, so they could make extra help fairer.Compound
Pupils learn nothing when they copy an answer they do not understand.Complex

The test: can each half stand alone? In the compound sentences, yes. “If pupils check the answer in a textbook” cannot, so that sentence is complex. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: join them

(a) Although chatbots can explain topics clearly, they sometimes give wrong answers.

(b) If pupils copy the answer, they do not learn.

(c) A free chatbot could help some families because they cannot pay for a tutor.

(d) Some tools may store what you type. Therefore, pupils should not type personal details.

A comma follows a subordinate clause at the start of a sentence, as in (a) and (b). Therefore links two sentences, so it starts the second sentence rather than joining with a comma. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: Ffion’s draft, improved (model)

AI chatbots can be helpful because they explain things in a different way. However, many teachers are worried about them, since chatbots can give answers that are wrong. In addition, if pupils simply copy an answer, they do not learn anything. Some tools may also store what you type, which is a risk to privacy. On balance, I think chatbots should be allowed as long as pupils check what they are told.

Ffion’s ten choppy sentences become five linked ones. Six connectives do five different jobs (because, however, in addition, if, on balance, as long as), and there are complex sentences with because, since, if and which. Evidences criteria 1 and 4.

Step 5: a balanced answer (model, 230 words)

There are good reasons to allow pupils to use AI chatbots for homework. Firstly, a chatbot is available at any time, so a pupil who is stuck late in the evening can still get help. For example, Cai says that a chatbot explains topics in a different way, like a tutor, and that he can ask again without feeling silly. Moreover, because some of these tools are free, they could make extra help fairer for families who cannot pay for a tutor.

On the other hand, there are serious risks. Although a chatbot’s answer may sound confident, it can be wrong, as Ms Rees points out. If pupils copy that answer, they learn nothing, and their teacher cannot see what they really understand. In addition, some tools may store what users type, so pupils could give away personal details without realising. Many tools also have a minimum age, which means some younger pupils may not be allowed to use them at all.

On balance, I believe pupils should be allowed to use AI chatbots for homework, but only with clear rules. Pupils should use a chatbot to understand a topic, not to write their answers. Furthermore, they should check what it says against a reliable source, as Mrs Hughes suggests, and they should never type in personal information. As long as these rules are followed, the benefits outweigh the risks.

Connectives organise the whole text: Firstly, Moreover and In addition add points; On the other hand opens the second paragraph; On balance opens the judgement; As long as gives the condition. Sentences vary from short (“On the other hand, there are serious risks.”) to complex. Evidences criteria 1, 4 and 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure