Worked example · Integrated Science · Year 11

Linking a balanced evaluation of bus fuels

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Connectives and syntax

What this is

A complete, secure Year 11 answer, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key for Steps 1 to 4. The model evaluation in Step 5 chooses hydrogen made with renewable electricity; a pupil who chooses bioethanol can score just as well if the decision follows from the evidence. The most common weakness is a conclusion that says “I think hydrogen” with no reason, or that ignores one of the council’s two aims.

Step 1: sort the connectives

AddingContrastingCause and effectComparingConcluding
furthermore
in addition
moreover
whereas
although
however
on the other hand
as a result
therefore
consequently
this means that
similarly
both
on balance
overall

15 connectives, each placed by the job it does in a sentence. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: fill the gaps

(1) for example · (2) therefore · (3) However · (4) so · (5) In addition · (6) Overall

Gap 2 needs cause and effect; gap 3 turns the argument against bioethanol, so it needs a contrast; gap 6 sums up. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: join the sentences

(a) Hydrogen buses produce only water at the exhaust, whereas diesel buses produce carbon dioxide and nitrogen oxides. (complex)

(b) Hydrogen buses are not always low-carbon because most hydrogen is made from natural gas. (complex)

(c) Although hydrogen can be made using wind power, it currently costs more. (complex)

(d) The council would need to build a filling station; as a result, the switch would cost more at first. (compound: two main clauses joined by a semicolon and a connective)

(e) Converting a bus to bioethanol is cheap; furthermore, the fuel can be delivered to the existing depot. (compound)

In (b) the order changes so that the effect comes first and because introduces the cause. A comma before whereas and after Although… power keeps the sentences accurate. Accept (d) and (e) as two sentences with the connective starting the second, for example “Furthermore, the fuel…”. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 4: what is wrong with Tomos’s answer?

(a) Every sentence is a simple sentence.

(b) He never explains what a fact means, for example why making hydrogen from natural gas matters. He also gives no reason for his decision, and does not compare the two fuels or mention the council’s aims.

(c) Hydrogen buses only make water at the exhaust, so they would clean up the air in the town centre. However, most hydrogen is made from natural gas, which means that the carbon dioxide is released at the factory instead of from the bus.

The rewrite keeps Tomos’s facts but adds a consequence to each one with so and which means that, and However shows the turn in the argument. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.

Step 5: the extended answer (model)

Hydrogen fuel cell buses produce only water at the exhaust (H1), so they would greatly improve air quality in the town centre. However, most hydrogen today is made from natural gas (H2), which means that carbon dioxide would still be released where the hydrogen is made. Although it can be made with wind or solar power (H3), this currently costs more. Furthermore, the council would need a £2.5 million filling station (H5) and each bus costs about twice as much as a diesel one (H6).

Bioethanol, on the other hand, is much cheaper to start: each bus can be converted for about £15,000 (B6). The crops take in carbon dioxide as they grow (B2); therefore, the fuel adds less new carbon dioxide than diesel. However, farming and transporting the crops uses fossil fuels (B3), so it is not completely carbon neutral. In addition, the buses would still burn fuel, and consequently release nitrogen oxides in the town centre (B5).

Both fuels would cut carbon dioxide compared with diesel. On balance, the council should choose hydrogen, as long as it is made with renewable electricity, because it is the only option that meets both aims: it cuts carbon dioxide and it removes exhaust pollution from the town centre. Bioethanol is cheaper, but it only partly meets the first aim and does little for air quality.

Every card is linked to a consequence (so, which means that, therefore, consequently). Each paragraph has a benefit and a problem, so the evaluation is balanced. The conclusion makes a conditional decision and checks it against both aims in the question. It uses connectives from all five columns and a mix of simple, compound and complex sentences. It is 224 words. Evidences criteria 1 to 5.

Step 6: check and redraft (example)

(a) The model uses 16 connectives, with at least one from every column.

(b) Simple: Hydrogen is very flammable. Complex: Because hydrogen is very flammable, it must be stored in strong high-pressure tanks, which adds to the cost of the depot.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure