Worked example · History · Year 9

Linking the causes of the Merthyr Rising

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Connectives and syntax

What this is

A secure Year 9 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. The key idea: connectives turn a list of causes into an explanation. Long-term causes are A, B, C and D; short-term causes are E, F and G; the trigger is H. Some pupils may place D or E differently; accept it if they explain why.

Step 2: sorting the causes

Long-termShort-termTrigger
A, B, C, DE, F, GH

Link: Card E made card C worse, because when workers lost their jobs in the slump, more families fell into debt and had their goods seized by the Court of Requests.

The link sentence uses “because” and “when” to show one cause feeding another. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: connectives

  1. … the Court of Requests because its bailiffs could take their belongings.
  2. As a result, some workers lost their jobs. (Consequently or therefore also work.)
  3. Therefore, many of them supported reform. (Consequently or as a result also work.)
  4. Although the ironmasters were very rich, … (Whereas also works.)
  5. In addition, the Court of Requests was seizing goods … (Furthermore or moreover also work.)

Each connective matches the job the sentence needs: cause, effect, contrast or addition. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 4: sentences

(a) Workers depended on the ironmasters, but they had no union to speak for them.

(b) When the court seized Lewis Lewis’s trunk, a crowd forced the bailiffs to give it back.

(c) Although the rising was crushed, it showed that workers could act together.

A comma follows the opening clause in each complex sentence. Sentence (a) uses “but” to join two main clauses. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 5: model explanation

The Merthyr Rising had several long-term causes that were linked together. Because Merthyr grew so quickly, thousands of families lived in crowded, dirty houses. Furthermore, they depended completely on a few ironmasters such as William Crawshay, and there was no union to speak for them. Many families were in debt, so the Court of Requests, which could seize their belongings, was hated. In addition, most men could not vote; therefore, they had no peaceful way to change things.

However, these problems had existed for years, so short-term causes explain why the rising came in 1831. The slump in the iron trade meant that more workers lost jobs and fell into debt. As a result, Crawshay’s wage cuts made people even angrier. At the same time, the reform meetings gave workers confidence to act together. When the court seized Lewis Lewis’s trunk, this anger finally exploded into action.

About 150 words, with 9 connectives from all four columns. There are compound sentences (“Many families were in debt, so …”) and complex sentences (“Because Merthyr grew so quickly, …”, “When the court seized …”). “However” at the start of paragraph 2 links the two paragraphs. Evidences criteria 1, 2 and 3.

Step 6: improving a sentence

Before: Crawshay cut wages. People were angry.

After: When Crawshay cut wages in a year when many families were already in debt, people’s anger grew quickly.

Two flat simple sentences become one complex sentence that also explains the link. Evidences criterion 4.

If you finish early: ideas

Why this response is secure