Worked example · RE · Year 9

Listening and building: a wind farm on a holy hill?

LNF: Literacy → Listening → Listening as part of collaborative talk

What this is

A model of good listening in a group discussion, with a secure Year 9 observer log, group decision and reflection, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. There is no right answer to the question. The key idea: good listeners respond to the last speaker before adding a new point, give reasons when they agree or disagree, and ask questions that move the discussion on.

A strong exchange from Round 1 (transcript)

A: I think the climate matters most, because climate change affects everyone, not just this village.

B: I see your point, but Mair says some places should be left alone. Why should the climate beat a place that has been holy for centuries?

A: So what you are saying is that the holy place is part of people’s identity, not just a view? That is fair. But the turbines do not touch the spring.

B: Adding to what you said, Cerys asked if they could be moved further away. What would happen if they were? Then maybe both things could matter.

Every turn responds to the one before it. B disagrees with a reason and asks “why?”; A sums up B’s view before replying; B builds on A and asks “what would happen if?”, which moves the talk towards a compromise. Evidences criteria 1, 2 and 3.

Observer log (C watching A)

Listening behaviourTicks
Builds on what the other person said✓ ✓
Asks a question about reasons, results or next steps✓
Agrees or disagrees and gives a reason✓ ✓ ✓
Sums up what the other person said before replying✓
Interrupts or ignores what was just said✓

Best example: “So what you are saying is that the holy place is part of people’s identity, not just a view?”

Feedback to A: you summed up B’s point really clearly. You interrupted once. Next time, ask B a question before you make your own point.

The observer records actual words heard and gives specific, kind feedback. Evidences criterion 4.

Group decision (Round 3)

DecisionSupport the wind farm only if the turbines nearest the chapel ruins are moved or removed, and the company protects the path to the spring.
Main reasonClean energy is part of caring for the earth, which Christian stewardship, the Muslim idea of khalifah and humanist responsibility all support.
What we gave upD wanted all 8 turbines for the most electricity and money; C wanted none. We agreed on fewer turbines, further from the ruins.
A different viewC still thinks a holy place should never have turbines in sight of it.

The decision is a genuine compromise, it records what each side gave up, and it keeps a minority view rather than hiding it. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 6: reflection

(a) B said: “Why should the climate beat a place that has been holy for centuries?”

(b) It changed my view. I had thought only about electricity. But the belief card on sacred places shows that for some believers a place matters because of the prayer and pilgrimage that happened there. I still support the wind farm, because stewardship means caring for the whole planet. However, I now think the council should protect the spring and the view from it.

(c) “What would happen if ...?” helped most, because it stopped us arguing and made us look for a solution.

The pupil names what they heard, explains how it affected their thinking, and links to a belief card. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.

If you finish early: ideas

Why this response is secure