Worked example · English · Year 10
LNF: Literacy → Listening → Listening to understand
A secure Year 10 response from a pupil who was Pupil B (so they listened to Speech 1 and read Speech 2 aloud), annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. Visits: the councillor chooses 98,000 in 2015 to 61,000 last year (a fall of more than a third); the campaigner chooses 54,000 to 61,000 in the last 2 years (a rise of 13%). The councillor leaves out staffed hours falling from 38 to 20, books falling from 22,000 to 9,000 and the bus; the campaigner leaves out the £640,000 repair bill, the £90,000 yearly saving and the 105 opening hours. Ratings in Step 5 and the view in Step 6 can differ from these: accept any rating or conclusion that is backed by a reason and by figures from the speeches. Show this after pupils have tried the steps themselves.
| Listen for | My notes |
|---|---|
| Main points | 1. “Not closing, moving”. 2. Old building falling apart, repairs too expensive. 3. Fewer visitors, people use e-books. 4. Leisure centre: self-service, longer hours, cheaper to run. 5. Survey says people want evening opening. |
| Figures and what each one is about | 1910: building opened · £604,000 (?): repairs over 10 yrs · 98,000 visits in 2015, 61,000 last yr: “fall of more than a third” · 200: free parking · 07:00 to 22:00, 7 days = 105 hrs a week, now 38 · £120,000 a yr instead of £210,000: saves £90,000 · 7 out of 10 in online survey |
| Loaded or emotive words and phrases | crumbling, swallowed by a leaking roof, modern vibrant hub, fit for the 21st century, tough choices, vital services |
| What did the speaker not tell me? What would I ask? | How many staff? How do people without cars get there? How many people did the survey? What happens to the old building? |
Notes are short and organised, and every figure is paired with what it is about, so the notes still make sense later. The pupil flags one figure they were unsure of with a question mark instead of guessing silently. The last row already asks the questions that expose what the speech leaves out. Evidences criterion 1.
| Listen for | My notes |
|---|---|
| Main points | 1. Library is in the centre of town, next to bus stop and school; leisure centre is on the edge. 2. Hard to reach for old people and children. 3. Fewer books and fewer staff, machines instead. 4. Library is busy again and people rely on its computers. |
| Figures and what each one is about | 2 miles away · 1 bus an hour, none on Sundays · 1 in 4 users over 65 · petition 3,200 signatures · books 22,000 now, 9,000 in new space · staffed 20 hrs, not 38 · 12 computers used 9,000 times · visits up 13%, 54,000 to 61,000 in 2 yrs |
| Loaded or emotive words and phrases | (added after checking) “feel like a funeral”, “rips the heart out of our town”, “squeezed into a corner”, “simply disappear” |
| What did the speaker not tell me? What would I ask? | How would you pay for the repairs? Would you accept longer hours if there were more buses? |
I caught 14 figures correctly by ear. The figure I got wrong was the repair bill: I wrote £604,000, but it is £640,000.
The pupil summarises the partner’s speech accurately from listening alone, then checks against the text and is honest about the one error. Both viewpoints are now recorded in the same way, ready to compare. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.
| Technique | Speech 1: the councillor | Speech 2: the campaigner |
|---|---|---|
| Selection: visit figures | Starts in 2015: 98,000 down to 61,000, “a fall of more than a third”. Picks the start year that makes the fall look biggest. | Starts 2 years ago: 54,000 up to 61,000, “up by 13%”. Picks the lowest year so it looks like a comeback. |
| Loaded language | “crumbling” makes the building sound unsafe and hopeless; “modern, vibrant hub” makes a room in a leisure centre sound exciting. | “rips the heart out of our town” makes the move sound violent; “feel like a funeral” makes us grieve for something that has not closed. |
| Omission | Never says staffed hours fall from 38 to 20, or that books fall from 22,000 to 9,000, or that there is 1 bus an hour. | Never mentions the £640,000 repair bill, the £90,000 saving or the longer opening hours. |
| Weak or missing evidence | “Most people now borrow e-books”: no figure at all. The survey was online only and we are not told how many people answered. | “More than half our books will simply disappear”: they might go to storage or other libraries; she gives no evidence either way. |
| Who they speak for | “the whole community”, parents and workers: busy people with cars. | “Friends, neighbours”, pensioners, children, job seekers: people who rely on the library most. |
(b) Both are true because they start counting from different years. Visits fell a long way between 2015 and 2 years ago (98,000 to 54,000), then rose a little (54,000 to 61,000). Each speaker picks the part of the story that suits their side.
The pupil names each technique and explains its effect on the listener, not just what was said. They see that both speakers are biased, and that true figures can still be used selectively. Evidences criterion 3.
| Information | Relevant? | H, M or L | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Building opened in 1910. | Y | L | Background only. Its condition matters, not its age. |
| 2. £640,000 of repairs over 10 years. | Y | H | A huge cost that someone has to pay. The campaigner ignores it. |
| 3. Free parking for 200 cars. | Y | L | Helps drivers, but not the users who have no car. |
| 4. 1 bus an hour, none on Sundays. | Y | H | If people cannot get there, longer hours are no use to them, and 1 in 4 users is over 65. |
| 5. 7 out of 10 in an online survey. | Y | M | Relevant, but weak: only people online took part, we do not know how many, and “would use” is not the same as “will use”. |
| 6. Staffed hours fall from 38 to 20. | Y | H | People who need help with forms and computers can only get it for 20 hours. |
| 7. Bethan has used the library since she was 5. | N | L | It makes us trust her, but it is not evidence about the plan. |
Each rating has a reason, and the pupil separates information that is simply relevant from information that could decide the question. They also judge how reliable a piece of evidence is (the survey). Evidences criterion 4.
Both speakers present a one-sided view. Councillor Howells selects the fall in visits from 98,000 in 2015 to 61,000, but leaves out the recent rise and the fact that staffed hours would drop from 38 to 20. His loaded phrase “modern, vibrant hub” hides that the new space holds only 9,000 books instead of 22,000. Bethan Rowlands uses emotive language, such as “rips the heart out of our town”, and never mentions the £640,000 repair bill or how it would be paid.
The most significant point for me is access. Opening for 105 hours a week means little if there is 1 bus an hour and 1 in 4 users is over 65. However, the repair bill is real. On balance, I think the library should stay in the town centre for now, but the council should publish its full survey and look for a cheaper repair plan before anyone decides.
About 150 words written in 14 minutes. It uses 7 facts from the speeches, each with its figures, names a technique from each speaker (selection and omission for the councillor, emotive language and omission for the campaigner), picks out the most significant issue, admits the strongest point on the other side, and ends with a clear, conditional conclusion of the pupil’s own. Evidences criteria 3, 4 and 5.