Worked example · Drama · Year 11
LNF: Literacy → Listening → Listening for meaning
A secure Year 11 response from a pupil who listened in Round 3 (lines 21 to 30), annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets, followed by a subtext key for the whole extract. Inferences can differ from these: accept any idea that is backed up by something the pupil heard and, in Step 4, by a line number. The ending is left open on purpose, so either prediction is fine if it has clues. Show this after pupils have tried the steps themselves.
I am Pupil 3. I listen in Round 3, to lines 21 to 30. I read Rhys in Round 1, Dilys in Round 2 and Cerys with the sounds in Round 4.
The pupil reads the rotation grid correctly, so they hear Part 3 fresh, having only seen Parts 1 and 2.
| What I listened for | What I heard | What I think it means |
|---|---|---|
| Tone | Cerys: soft and careful, almost pleading. Rhys: short, bitter, then sharp at the end. Dilys: slow and gentle. | Cerys is trying not to scare Rhys off. Rhys is angry but also defending himself. Dilys is choosing her words carefully because she is about to say something that hurts. |
| Pauses and silences | A pause after “Your favourite”. Cerys stops in the middle of “He went out after”. A long silence (about 4 seconds) with only rain after “Every time”. | The broken sentence means something happened at home that Cerys cannot say. The long silence means everyone knows Rhys is right, and nobody can argue. |
| Sound effects | Rain all the way through. A can rolling along the ground. | The rain keeps it cold and miserable. The can is blown about by the wind, like Rhys, who is being pushed out of his home. |
| Dilys | “Your dad waited in this shelter too … with a bag not much smaller than that one.” | She is warning him that he is repeating what his dad did, and hinting that his dad’s leaving hurt people. |
| Rhys | “She can give mine to him, then.” | He is not really talking about food. He is angry with his mam for choosing “him” (her partner) over him. |
| Cerys | “There’s loads. She made loads.” | Mam made enough for Rhys because she wants him home. Cerys cannot say “please come back”, so she talks about lasagne. |
My prediction: I think Rhys will hesitate and maybe not get on the bus. When Dilys compared him to his dad he snapped “That was different” too quickly, as if he is scared it is not different. Also his sister came all the way out in the rain, which shows the family wants him.
Every row separates what was heard from what it means, and the meanings go beyond the words: food stands for love, “him” stands for the reason he is leaving. The prediction uses tone (“snapped”), not just the words. Evidences criteria 1, 2 and 3.
| Round | Who I read | Line, and what I wanted the listener to understand |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Rhys | Line 8, “Wrong number”: I said it flat and fast, so the listener would hear he is lying and wants the subject closed. |
| 2 | Dilys | Line 15: I left a real 2-second pause before “At least the shelter has company”, so it sounded lonely, not like a joke. |
| 4 | Cerys and sounds | Line 33: I started the engine hum very quietly so the listener would feel time running out before anyone mentions the bus. |
The reader thinks about the listener: each choice of tone, pause or sound has a reason linked to subtext. Evidences criterion 4.
(a) The sound effects set the scene: rain drumming on a tin roof tells you it is a shelter on a wet night, and the car passing tells you it is a road. The dialogue paints the rest: Dilys says “That’s a big bag” and tells Cerys “you’re soaked through”, which a stage play would not need, because the audience could see it.
(b) His mam is ringing because she is worried, and Rhys switches her off because he is afraid she will talk him out of leaving. The click is him cutting off his family, and he does it without a word.
(c) The long silence after “Every time”. Nobody can answer Rhys, so the silence agrees with him: the apologies have happened before. On radio, silence is stronger because there is nothing to look at, so the listener is left alone with the last words and the rain.
(d) The ending is left to the listener, just like Rhys’s decision: the doors staying open are a question. The engine getting louder slowly builds tension like a clock ticking. I think he does not get on, because he keeps telling himself “I’ve got my ticket”, as if he needs to convince himself, and Cerys’s “She’s still sitting up” is the last thing he hears about home.
Each answer explains what the sound or silence does to a listener, and why radio depends on it. The prediction is backed by 2 clues. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.
| Inference from listening | Line | Right, partly right or wrong? |
|---|---|---|
| Something happened at home that Cerys cannot say. | Line 23: “He went out after… (She stops.)” | Right. The stage direction confirms she stops herself on purpose. |
| Rhys snapped because he is scared he is like his dad. | Line 30: (sharp) “That was different.” | Right. The script asks for “sharp”, and Dilys’s reply “Was it?” in line 31 shows she does not believe him. |
| The rolling can was a bottle. | Line 25 | Partly right. It is a can, but the meaning (something pushed about by the wind) still works. |
From listening I understood how cold and bitter Rhys’s voice was, which I might not notice from the page. From the script I learned that Dilys is a widow: the character list says so, and I only half-noticed it from “drove” in the past tense.
The pupil tests each inference against a specific line and judges it honestly, including one that was only partly right. Evidences criterion 5.
The extract shows what Rhys and Dilys feel mostly through what the listener hears around their words. Rhys claims his bag holds “my kit. Football” (line 3), but the short, clipped minor sentences sound like a rehearsed lie. When his phone buzzes 3 times, the sound effect tells us his mam is desperate, and his flat “Wrong number” (line 8), followed by the click of the phone switching off, shows him cutting off his family without admitting it. Dilys’s subtext is carried by pauses. Her short beat before “I like the shelter. Nice roof” (line 13) shows she is dodging the real reason she comes every Friday, and the pause before “At least the shelter has company” (line 15) turns a joke into loneliness: the listener infers that since Emlyn died, she comes here so she is not alone. The long silence with only the rain underscore after “Every time” (line 28) lets Rhys’s anger hang in the air. Finally, the engine that grows louder builds tension, and when the doors open and “Nobody moves” (line 40), the sound itself asks the question Rhys cannot answer: whether he really wants to leave.
About 200 words written in 15 minutes. It opens with a clear overview, uses seven short embedded quotations with line numbers, and names more than three techniques (minor sentences, sound effect, tone, pause, silence, underscore, a sound that grows louder). Each technique is linked to an inference about feeling, not just described. Evidences criterion 6.
| Line | What is said or heard | What it implies |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | “It’s my kit. Football.” | A cover story: Rhys is leaving home. |
| 4 | “They play late in Cardiff, do they?” | Dilys has guessed where he is going, and lets him know it gently. |
| 9 | “Very keen, wrong numbers are, these days.” | Irony: she knows it is his mam, and that his mam is worried. |
| 13 to 15 | “Nice roof.” “At least the shelter has company.” | Dilys is lonely and grieving for Emlyn; she comes to relive his Friday night route. |
| 18 | “Go home, Cerys.” | He does not want to be talked out of it, perhaps because he knows he could be. |
| 21 | “There’s loads. She made loads.” | Mam wants him home: love said through food. |
| 22 to 27 | “him”, “He always says sorry” | Mam’s partner is the reason Rhys is leaving; there have been rows before, and apologies Rhys no longer believes. |
| 29 to 31 | Dad “never looked back” | A warning: leaving hurts the people left behind, and his dad may not welcome him as he hopes. |
| 32 | “I could come with you… Joke.” | Cerys wants to escape too, but stays for Mam; the laugh that is not a laugh gives her away. |
| 38 | “Right by the puddle. Every week.” | The splash brings back Emlyn; she is speaking to a memory. |
| 39 to 40 | “I’ve got my ticket”; nobody moves | Rhys is trying to convince himself; the open doors leave the decision to the listener. |
New lines: accept any 4 lines where the decision is shown only by sound, for example the doors hissing shut and the engine fading away, followed by footsteps walking up the street, or silence and one set of footsteps missing.
Emlyn: line 11 (“drove … for thirty-one years”, past tense, and “Every week I told him off”) and line 35 (“Emlyn was never early”). Line 15 (“At least the shelter has company”) supports it: she lives alone.
Sound design: accept 3 effects with a reason, for example a distant chapel clock striking the half hour to add time pressure, a quiet television from a nearby house to suggest home and warmth, or a gust of wind on “never looked back” to make the moment colder.