Worked example · Design Technology · Year 7
LNF: Literacy → Listening → Listening to understand
A secure Year 7 response, annotated against the success criteria. Topics not in the talk: opening hours and parking. Step 3: facts 1, 3, 4, 6, 7, 9, 10; opinions 2, 5, 8; not relevant 3, 6, 8. Key details: 8 holders; base no bigger than 20 cm by 12 cm; no taller than 15 cm; tables 60 cm across; about £6 of materials each, £48 for all 8; ready before Easter.
Accept notes in pupils’ own words if the numbers and units are right. The Step 2 grid is the listening evidence.
Predict: things blowing away in the wind; tables and menus getting wet in the rain. Circled: who will use it, size, cost, weather, cleaning, how many. Expected words: wind, rain, £.
Heard: ticked 10 topics: who will use it, size, cost, weather, colours, cleaning, materials, a deadline, how many she needs, a pet. Not heard: opening hours, parking.
(a) Mererid; she runs Caffi Glan Tywi, a café in Llandeilo. (b) Things on her outside tables sit loose, and the napkins blow into the river. (c) A holder for the napkins, sugar, salt and pepper and menu card; 8, one per table.
(d) Mererid, who runs a café in Llandeilo, wants 8 holders to stop napkins and other things blowing off her outside tables. (21 words)
Predictions use what the pupil knows about cafés and weather. The summary gives who, what and why, without detail. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.
| Heading | My notes |
|---|---|
| Who is the client? | Mererid, runs Caffi Glan Tywi, Llandeilo |
| Who will use it? | customers: families, walkers, older people (some arthritis); staff carry it in |
| What is the problem? | napkins, sugar etc. loose on tables; napkins blow into river when windy |
| What must it hold? | napkins, sugar sachets, salt and pepper, menu card |
| Where will it be used? | outside terrace by river; small round tables 60 cm across with teapot, cups, plates; rain and sun; brought in every evening |
| Size | base max 20 cm long × 12 cm wide; max 15 cm tall |
| Budget | about £6 materials each, £48 for 8 |
| How many, and by when? | 8 (1 per table); before Easter |
| Must have | holds all 4 items · napkin out with 1 hand · handle · size limits · copes with rain and sun · wipes clean with damp cloth · does not tip over · no sharp corners · about £6 each · 8 ready before Easter |
| Should have | staff can carry 2 at once · natural wood · Welsh slate panel to chalk table number · teal and cream · no shiny plastic |
| Could have | tiny vase for a flower |
Every number has its unit, and needs are sorted by signal words: “ideally” and “I’d love” became shoulds, “a nice extra” a could. Accept “no sharp corners” as a must (children’s safety) and “no shiny plastic” as a should or a must. Evidences criterion 3.
1 F R · 2 O R · 3 F N · 4 F R · 5 O R · 6 F N · 7 F R · 8 O N · 9 F R · 10 F R
(b) “Shiny plastic looks cheap” is only an opinion, but Mererid is the client and is paying. If the holder is shiny plastic she will not want it, so the specification should rule it out.
(c) Mot sleeping under table 3 changes nothing about the size, materials or use of the holder, so it would only fill up the brief.
The pupil sees that an opinion can still be relevant, and that a true fact can still be irrelevant. Accept R for 8 only if the pupil links it to the holder needing to cope with rain. Evidences criterion 4.
| My question | Why the answer matters for the design |
|---|---|
| 1. How many napkins and sugar sachets should each holder take? | It decides how big each space must be, and it all has to fit in 20 cm by 12 cm. |
| 2. Are the salt and pepper in pots or in sachets? | Pots need their own holes and could make it taller than 15 cm. |
| 3. When you said about £6, does that include paint and the slate? | Slate and paint could use up most of the money, so I need to know what to leave out. |
Also secure: How heavy can it be? When exactly do the tables go out? Can it be fixed to the table? Not secure: “How many tables are there?”, because she already said.
Each question targets a real gap or a vague word (“about” £6), and each reason links it to the design. Evidences criterion 5.
Mererid, the owner of Caffi Glan Tywi in Llandeilo, has a problem: everything on her 8 outside tables by the River Tywi sits loose, and on windy days the napkins blow into the river. I will design 8 table holders that keep napkins, sugar sachets, salt and pepper and a menu card together. They will be used outdoors by families, walkers and older customers, some with arthritis, and carried inside every evening by staff. Each must cost about £6 in materials, and all 8 must be ready before Easter. (89 words)
Covers who, where, the problem, what, how many, the users and the key limits in full sentences, and leaves out Mot, Gethin and August. Evidences criteria 4 and 6.
| Heading | Specification point | How it could be checked |
|---|---|---|
| Function | It must hold napkins, sugar sachets, salt and pepper and a menu card together, so nothing blows away. | Fill it with all 4 items; leave it outside on a windy day. |
| Customer | A customer must be able to pull out a napkin with 1 hand. It must have a handle, and staff should be able to carry 2 at once. | Ask 3 people, including an older adult, to take a napkin 1-handed; carry 2. |
| Size | The base must be no bigger than 20 cm long and 12 cm wide, and it must be no taller than 15 cm, so it fits on a 60 cm table. | Measure with a ruler. |
| Environment | It must cope with rain and sun outdoors and wipe clean with a damp cloth. | Wet it, leave it in the sun, wipe it; look for damage. |
| Safety | It must have no sharp corners and must not tip over when knocked. | Run a finger round every corner; push the full holder gently sideways. |
| Cost | The materials must cost about £6 or less per holder, £48 for all 8. | Add up the material prices; 8 × £6 = £48. |
6 different headings, Mererid’s exact numbers, must and should as she meant them, and a check for each point. An Aesthetics point (natural wood, slate panel, teal and cream, no shiny plastic) is equally good in place of Safety or Cost. Evidences criterion 6.
(a) 10 out of 10: every must in the grid is in the brief or the specification.
(b) The Function point. Once Mererid says how many napkins and sachets she wants, I can add numbers, such as “must hold at least 20 napkins”, so it can be checked properly.
The pupil tests the writing against the notes and sees how answers would make the specification more exact. Evidences criteria 5 and 6.