Worked example · Health and Well-being · Year 4

Making a group chat kinder

DCF: Citizenship → Online behaviour and online bullying

Also assessed, LNF: Literacy → Writing → Proofreading, editing and improving

What this is

A secure Year 4 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key. Key answers: kind and clear 8, 9 (message 2 accepted here or in unclear); unclear 3, 6; unkind or unsafe 4, 5, 7, 10. The two kinds of bullying are leaving someone out (message 5) and making fun of someone and sharing an embarrassing photo (messages 4 and 7). Edited messages will vary in wording; check the checklist points.

Step 1: sort the messages

Kind and clearUnclear (hard to understand or shouting)Unkind or unsafe
8 polite and says what she wants.
9 includes Erin.
2 kind, but no capitals or commas.
3 all capitals looks like shouting.
6 text speak, and “the thing” could mean anything.
4 makes fun of Erin.
5 tells everyone to leave Erin out.
7 shares a photo of Erin without asking.
10 says it is a joke, but it still hurts.

Bullying: leaving someone out on purpose (message 5) and making fun of someone and sharing an embarrassing photo (messages 4 and 7).

Every message is placed with a reason, and the pupil names two forms of online bullying with evidence. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.

Step 2: why online messages go wrong

(a) Erin cannot see Jac’s face or hear his voice, so she cannot tell he is joking. Everyone in the class can read it, so it is embarrassing, and it is about something she might already feel bad about.

(b) A message can be saved and shared with lots of people, and it stays there. You can send it very fast without stopping to think, and you do not see how upset the other person is.

Gives clear differences between online and face to face communication. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 3: edit the messages

Message 2: I want to be in a team with Jac, Leo and Cerys. Is that OK with everyone?

Message 3: Is anyone still choosing teams? I would like to join one, please.

Message 5: Erin can join a team too. Which team has space for her?

Message 6: See you at relay practice after school!

Message 10: Sorry, Erin. It wasn’t funny and I shouldn’t have said it.

Every message starts with a capital letter, names have capitals, each sentence ends with a full stop, question mark or exclamation mark, there are commas in the list in message 2 and apostrophes in “wasn’t” and “shouldn’t”. The shouting, text speak and unkind meaning have all gone. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 4: explain your changes

MessageWhat I changedWhy I changed it
3I changed the capital letters to lower case, added a question mark and added “please”.Capital letters look like shouting. A question mark shows she is asking, and “please” is polite.
6I wrote “See you” and “later” in full and said “relay practice after school”.Text speak can be hard to read, and “the thing” did not tell people where to go.

Says exactly where in each message the change is, and gives a reason linked to the reader. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 5: what should happen next?

(a) Erin should not reply with something unkind. She could keep the messages and tell Mr Price or another trusted adult, and use the report button.

(b) A classmate could send Erin a kind message, ask her to play at break, and tell Mr Price about the photo.

(c) Hi Erin, you’re welcome in our team. We can practise passing the baton at break, if you want. (Checked: capital letter for Erin, apostrophe in “you’re”, comma after “break”.)

Gives safe, realistic strategies: do not retaliate, keep evidence, tell an adult, report. The welcome message is checked against the list. Evidences criteria 4 and 6.

If you finish early: answers

Rules, for example: Use kind words, even when you are joking. Ask before you share a photo of someone. Tell Mr Price if a message upsets you.

Message 7 shares a photo of Erin without asking her, to make people laugh at her. That is unkind and unsafe, whatever the punctuation.

Why this response is secure