Worked example · Geography · Year 7

Measuring distances with map scale in Cwm Tawelan

LNF: Numeracy → Learning about geometry helps us understand shape, space and position, and learning about measurement helps us quantify in the real world → Measurement

What this is

A secure Year 7 response, annotated to show which success criterion each part meets. It is also your answer key. The true distances below were worked out from the map itself, so they are right whatever size the map printed. Pupils are measuring by hand, so accept answers within 0.2 km for straight lines and within 0.3 km for winding routes. Steps 2, 6 and 7 are calculations and have exact answers.

The 3 most common mistakes are: measuring with a ruler in cm and using “4 cm = 1 km” on the printed sheet (only the grid and the scale bar are reliable there); measuring a winding route as one straight line; and dividing by 1000 instead of 100 000 to change cm into km.

Step 2: warm up with units

(a) 3 km(b) 2.4 km(c) 850 m(d) 50 m
3000 m2400 m0.85 km0.05 km
(e) 250 cm(f) 25 000 cm(g) 100 000 cm(h) 1.5 km
2.5 m250 m1 km150 000 cm

Multiplies by 1000 to go from km to m and divides by 100 to go from cm to m. In (h), 1.5 km = 1500 m = 150 000 cm, done in 2 stages. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 3: count the grid squares

From and toDistance (km)Accept
School to waterfall2.01.8 to 2.2
Youth hostel to viewpoint2.52.3 to 2.7
Car park to viewpoint3.33.1 to 3.5
Campsite to Fferm Hafod2.32.1 to 2.5

For the car park to the viewpoint I counted 3 whole squares going north, then about 3 tenths of the next square, so 3.3 km.

Counts whole squares, then estimates the part square in tenths and gives km to 1 decimal place. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 4: the paper edge method

From and to (straight line)Distance (km)Accept
Church to youth hostel2.52.4 to 2.7
Bridge to mast1.51.3 to 1.7
Car park to youth hostel4.13.9 to 4.3
Campsite to waterfall1.91.7 to 2.1

The true distances are 2.55 km, 1.49 km, 4.12 km and 1.86 km. Each answer is read from the scale bar to the nearest small mark (100 m), not guessed from the squares. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 5: measure winding routes

RouteRoute distance (km)Straight-line distance (km)Extra distance (km)
Road: car park to youth hostel4.5 (accept 4.2 to 4.8)4.14.5 − 4.1 = 0.4
Footpath: car park to viewpoint3.8 (accept 3.5 to 4.1)3.33.8 − 3.3 = 0.5

(b) The road goes east through Llanhelyg first instead of heading straight for the youth hostel, because it has to reach the bridge to cross Afon Tawelan. After the bridge it bends several times as it climbs up the valley side.

(c) Gareth measured the straight-line distance, but nobody can walk in a straight line here: the road bends 6 times and goes round by the bridge. The real walk is about 4.5 km, so his answer is about 0.4 km too short.

The true route lengths are 4.53 km and 3.81 km. Measures each route section by section, subtracts to compare it with the straight line, and uses features on the map to explain the difference. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 6: ratio scales on full-size maps

Map lengthReal distance in mReal distance in km
1:25 000: 8 cm8 × 250 = 2000 m2 km
1:25 000: 10 cm10 × 250 = 2500 m2.5 km
1:25 000: 5 cm5 × 250 = 1250 m1.25 km
1:25 000: 13.2 cm13.2 × 250 = 3300 m3.3 km
1:50 000: 4 cm4 × 500 = 2000 m2 km
1:50 000: 4.6 cm4.6 × 500 = 2300 m2.3 km
1:50 000: 8.2 cm8.2 × 500 = 4100 m4.1 km

(b)

Real distance1:25 000 map (4 cm = 1 km)1:50 000 map (2 cm = 1 km)
1 km4 cm2 cm
750 m = 0.75 km0.75 × 4 = 3 cm0.75 × 2 = 1.5 cm
3.5 km3.5 × 4 = 14 cm3.5 × 2 = 7 cm

(c) Elin’s first step is right: 3 × 50 000 = 150 000 cm. But there are 100 000 cm in 1 km, not 1000. She should divide by 100 to get metres: 150 000 ÷ 100 = 1500 m, which is 1.5 km. This matches my Step 4 answer of 1.5 km for the bridge to the mast.

(d) On the 1:25 000 map, 1 km is drawn as 4 cm. On the 1:50 000 map, 1 km is drawn as only 2 cm, so everything is drawn half as big. 8 ÷ 4 = 2 km and 4 ÷ 2 = 2 km, so both give 2 km, the same as I counted in Step 3.

Every answer has working with units, goes both ways between map length and real distance, and is checked against the measurements from the printed map. Evidences criteria 1 and 4.

Step 7: how long will the walk take?

SectionDistance (km)Time (minutes)
1. Ridge path2.52.5 × 15 = 37.5
2. Footpath3.83.8 × 15 = 57
3. Road4.54.5 × 15 = 67.5
Total10.8162 (check: 10.8 × 15 = 162)

(b) 162 minutes = 120 + 42 minutes = 2 hours 42 minutes.

(c) 09:30 + 2 hours 42 minutes = 12:12. Add 45 minutes for lunch: 12:12 + 45 minutes = 12:57. The coach leaves at 13:30, so they make it with 33 minutes to spare.

(d) Yes. I measured 3.8 km for the footpath and 4.5 km for the road, the same as the warden. (A pupil whose answers differ by more than 0.2 km should say what they would do differently, for example turn the strip at every bend or measure from the centre of each symbol.)

Uses 15 minutes per km, checks the total a second way, changes minutes into hours and minutes, and adds times across the hour correctly. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 8: the shrinking map

Rhodri is wrong because “4 cm = 1 km” is only true on a full-size 1:25 000 map. His map printed smaller, so 1 km is no longer 4 cm. The school and the waterfall are still exactly 2 grid squares apart, so the real distance is 2 km; on his copy each square must be 3 cm wide. The grid and the scale bar still work because they were printed on the same sheet as the map, so they shrank by the same amount as everything else. A ratio scale written in words or numbers does not shrink, so it stops being true.

Spots the error, gives the correct distance with a reason, and explains clearly why the grid and the scale bar are print-proof. Evidences criterion 6.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure