Worked example · English · Year 11

Persuasive language in online adverts: fair or foul?

DCF: Producing → Evaluating and improving digital content

What this is

A secure Year 11 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. Step 2 is your answer key: Advert B breaks the most rules (3.1, 3.7, 3.17, 3.30, 3.47); Advert A’s buried “#ad” breaks 2.1 and its battery claim is likely to mislead; Advert C’s “most breathtaking” is puffery, which rule 3.2 allows, and its checkable claims are supported. The expected ranking, most to least honest, is C, A, B. Show this after pupils have written their own paragraph and rewrite.

Step 1 — the technique hunt

Advert Quotation Technique Effect on the target reader
A“Honestly the best earbuds I’ve EVER owned”Superlative, hyperbole, capitals“Honestly” makes a paid advert sound like a confession between friends, so his followers read it as advice, not selling.
A“every single day for a month”Personal testimonialSuggests the product has been tested hard by someone fit, which matters to gym-goers who admire him.
B“Are you REALLY ready for your GCSEs?”Rhetorical question, direct address, capitalsPlants a worry almost every Year 11 pupil already has, then offers the app as the cure.
B“Offer ends in 09:59 — only 3 places left”Urgency and scarcityA ticking clock pushes a stressed reader to tap before they read the pale small print.
C“Feel the rush”Imperative, sensory languagePuts the reader on the zip line in their imagination, which appeals to thrill-seekers.
C“Rated 4.8 out of 5 by our visitors”Statistic, social proofReassures the parents who pay the £96 that other families thought it was worth it.

Every row quotes exact words and explains the effect on a particular reader — followers, stressed Year 11s, parents — rather than “makes people want to buy it”. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2 — the claims checked

Claim Objective or puffery? What the checked facts show Verdict
A: the post, and where “#ad” appearsObjective: it either is an advert or it is notHe was sent the earbuds free and earns commission through his code, so it is an advert. “#ad” is the last of six hashtags, hidden behind “…more”. No partnership label.Breaks 2.1. The ASA guide says the label must be upfront, before people read the rest.
A: “30 HOURS of battery!!”Objective6 hours per charge; 30 hours only in total with the charging case.Likely to mislead by leaving out the key fact: 3.1. A runner would read it as 30 hours of listening.
B: “9 out of 10 students… improve their grades”Objective18 of 20 users who chose to answer said they felt their grades had improved. No actual grades.Breaks 3.1 and 3.7: no documentary evidence that grades improved.
B: “Offer ends in 09:59 — only 3 places left”ObjectiveThe timer restarts at 10:00 on every reload; “3 places” never changes, and an app has no places.Breaks 3.30 (a false time limit) and 3.1.
B: “Just £4.99 a month”ObjectiveBilled annually: £4.99 × 12 = £59.88 in one payment after the trial, shown only in pale small print.Breaks 3.17: undue emphasis on the monthly figure.
B: Ffion and “250,000 students”ObjectiveNo contact details for Ffion; no source for 250,000.Breaks 3.47 and 3.7.
C: “Wales’s most breathtaking adventure”PufferyNobody can measure “breathtaking”, and nobody takes it literally.Allowed under 3.2.
C: “1.2 km” and “selling out fast”ObjectiveMeasured at 1,212 m. 7 of the 12 summer weekend dates were already fully booked.Fair. The evidence exists, as 3.7 requires.

Separates puffery from checkable claims, judges each against the facts rather than against whether the product sounds good, and names a specific rule every time. Note that it also gives Advert C credit where it is due. Evidences criteria 2 and 3.

Step 3 — analysing Advert B

The writer of Advert B persuades a Year 11 reader mainly by making them anxious and then rushing them, so that they act before they think. The opening imperative, “STOP SCROLLING”, and the rhetorical question “Are you REALLY ready for your GCSEs?” use direct address and capital letters to plant doubt, since almost no Year 11 pupil feels completely ready. The advert then offers relief through social proof: “9 out of 10 students” and “Join 250,000 students” suggest that everyone else has already found the answer. The testimonial from “Ffion, Year 11, Bridgend” makes this personal and local, and the jump “from a 4 to an 8” is so specific that it sounds like evidence. Finally, the countdown and “only 3 places left” add urgency and scarcity. However, the persuasion is not fair. The “9 out of 10” is 18 of 20 users describing a feeling, not their grades; the timer restarts at 10:00 whenever the page is reloaded, so the deadline is false, which rule 3.30 forbids; and an app cannot run out of places. Most seriously, “Just £4.99 a month” hides the fact that the price is billed annually as £59.88, exactly the undue emphasis that rule 3.17 exists to stop. The advert works because every technique removes a reason to slow down and check.

217 words. The opening sentence is an argument, not a list; the quotations are short and embedded; the paragraph follows the advert’s own order (worry, relief, rush); and it turns at “However” to judge fairness with two named rules and the price worked out. The last sentence links all the techniques to one purpose. Evidences criteria 1, 3 and 4.

Step 4 — the honest rewrite

Revising for your GCSEs? GradeRocket gives you a ten-minute quiz every day and shows which topics you keep getting wrong. Try it free for 7 days. After that it costs £59.88 a year, paid in one go, which works out at £4.99 a month. Cancel before day 7 and you pay nothing. In our March survey, 18 of the 20 users who replied said they felt their grades had improved.

[ TRY IT FREE FOR 7 DAYS ]

What I cut or changed What I replaced it with Rule it fixes
The countdown and “only 3 places left”Nothing. A real free trial is reason enough to act; there is no deadline to invent.3.30, 3.1
“Just £4.99 a month” in bold, £59.88 in pale print“£59.88 a year, paid in one go” in bold, with the monthly figure after it.3.17
“9 out of 10”, “250,000” and FfionThe real survey result, described as what it is, and what the app actually does.3.7, 3.47

76 words including the button. It keeps the rhetorical question and direct address — persuasive but not dishonest — and swaps false urgency for a concrete benefit and a genuine free offer. Every claim can be traced to the checked facts. Evidences criteria 3 and 5.

Step 5 — the ranking

1. Advert C. Its big claim is obvious puffery, and its checkable claims — the length of the zip line, the bookings, the reviews — all have evidence behind them.

2. Advert A. The earbuds are real and so is the 30-hour figure, but hiding “#ad” behind “…more” means followers do not know they are reading an advert, which is the most basic rule of all.

3. Advert B. Five separate claims fail, and they are designed to work together to stop a stressed teenager from reading the price.

Each place is justified from Step 2 rather than from whether the product is appealing. Evidences criterion 2.

Why this response is secure