Worked example · MFL: German · Year 10

Planning a day out with German opening times

LNF: Numeracy → Learning about geometry helps us understand shape, space and position, and learning about measurement helps us quantify in the real world → Measurement

What this is

A secure Year 10 response and answer key, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. Key answers: halb drei is 14:30; the boat trip lasts 1 hour 25 minutes (85 minutes); the only plan that fits is the castle tour at 11:00 and the otter feeding at 16:15, with 55 minutes to spare before the 17:45 bus; Cai’s three mistakes are the boat time, the missing guided tour and the total time in town (8 hours 30 minutes). Show this after pupils have tried every step.

Step 1: Jonas’s spoken times

German24-hour12-hourWhat happens
um zwanzig vor neun08:408:40 amThe bus leaves Kleinhöfen.
um Viertel nach neun09:159:15 amThe bus arrives at the Marktplatz.
um Viertel nach elf11:1511:15 amFirst otter feeding.
um Viertel vor eins12:4512:45 pmMeet Oma at the harbour café for lunch.
um halb drei14:302:30 pmThe boat leaves.
um Viertel nach vier16:154:15 pmSecond otter feeding.
um Viertel vor sechs17:455:45 pmThe last bus leaves the Marktplatz.
heute Abend kurz nach siebenabout 19:05about 7:05 pmJonas phones again (Thursday evening). Accept any time from 19:01 to 19:10.

The trap is halb drei. In German, halb looks forward to the next hour: half way to three, so 2:30. English speakers often write 3:30 because “half three” means 3:30 in English. The timetable proves it: a boat leaves at 14:30 and none leaves at 15:30.

Every time is in both clocks, am and pm are correct across midday (12:45 is pm), and afternoon times are recognised from the context even though Jonas speaks in the 12-hour clock. The halb answer is checked against the timetable. Evidences criterion 1.

Step 2: dates and days

(a) Saturday 12 July.

(b) Thursday 10 July (Donnerstag, der zehnte Juli).

(c) The castle (Burg Ellern) and the open-air pool (Seebad). Both say Ruhetag: Montag. The zoo and the boat run täglich, every day.

(d) There are no boat trips on Sunday 13 July because of the lake festival (Seefest). Also, the bus timetable on the sheet is for Saturdays only.

The dates are read day first, then month, and the abbreviations are matched to the right weekday. Evidences criterion 2.

Step 3: durations and waiting times

(a) 14:30 to 15:30 is 1 hour. 15:30 to 15:55 is 25 minutes. Total 1 hour 25 minutes = 60 + 25 = 85 minutes. (Every boat trip in the table is 85 minutes long.)

(b) 10:00 to 17:00 is 7 hours.

(c) 08:40 to 09:00 is 20 minutes. 09:00 to 09:15 is 15 minutes. Total 35 minutes. (All three morning buses take 35 minutes.)

(d) 09:15 + 15 minutes walk = 09:30. The castle opens at 10:00, so you wait 30 minutes.

(e) In July the zoo closes at 18:30. Last entry is one hour before: 17:30.

(f) Boarding closes 5 minutes before departure: 14:30 − 5 minutes = 14:25.

Each answer counts on to the next whole hour, then adds the remaining minutes, and states the unit. Part (e) and part (f) use a rule from the page (last entry, boarding time) as well as the times. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 4: the plan

From ... to ...WhereWhat (and any walking time)
09:15MarktplatzGet off the bus.
09:15 to 09:30Marktplatz to BurgWalk, 15 minutes.
09:30 to 10:00BurgWait for opening, 30 minutes.
10:00 to 11:00BurgLook round the museum.
11:00 to 11:45BurgGuided tour, 45 minutes.
11:45 to 12:05Burg to HafenWalk, 20 minutes.
12:05 to 12:45HafenFree time, 40 minutes.
12:45 to 13:45Café am HafenLunch with Oma.
13:45 to 14:25HafenFree time; board by 14:25.
14:30 to 15:55BoatBoat trip round the lake, 85 minutes.
15:55 to 16:10Hafen to TierparkWalk, 15 minutes. Arrive before last entry (17:30).
16:15 to 16:30TierparkOtter feeding, about 15 minutes.
16:30 to 16:50Tierpark to MarktplatzWalk, 20 minutes.
17:45MarktplatzLast bus home.

Time to spare: 16:50 to 17:45 is 55 minutes (10 minutes to 17:00, then 45 minutes). Pupils may stay longer in the zoo, but they must leave by 17:25 at the latest. A margin is sensible because the otter feeding time is only “about” 15 minutes and a walk can take longer with a group.

Why this is the only plan that works: the 11:00 tour ends at 11:45, so it clashes with the 11:15 feeding; the 13:30 tour clashes with lunch (12:45 to 13:45); the 15:00 tour clashes with the boat (14:30 to 15:55). So the tour must be at 11:00 and the otters must be at 16:15.

Every row has a start and an end time, every walk is included, and every event is checked against the opening times, the boarding rule and the last bus. The pupil explains why the other tour times fail, so the plan is justified and not just guessed. Accept small differences in the free-time rows if the fixed times are right. Evidences criteria 3 and 4.

Step 5: Cai’s mistakes

  1. The boat time. Halb drei is 14:30, not 15:30. No boat leaves at 15:30, so Cai misses the boat Jonas wanted. He is still at the castle at 14:30.
  2. No guided tour. Jonas wanted a tour. Cai reaches the castle at 14:05 (13:45 + 20 minutes): the 13:30 tour has started, and the 15:00 tour would clash with the 14:30 boat. The tour has to be at 11:00, so the otters must move to 16:15.
  3. The total time. 09:15 to 17:45 is 8 hours 30 minutes, not 7 hours 30 minutes (09:15 to 17:15 is 8 hours, plus 30 minutes).

His other sums are right for his own plan: 15:30 + 85 minutes = 16:55, and 16:55 + 10 minutes = 17:05.

Each mistake is named, explained with a calculation or a rule from the page, and corrected. Evidences criterion 5.

Step 6: the plan in German

  1. Am Samstag, dem 12. Juli, fahren wir um 8:40 Uhr mit dem Bus nach Ellernsee.
  2. Um Viertel nach neun kommen wir am Marktplatz an.
  3. Von 11:00 bis 11:45 Uhr machen wir eine Führung in der Burg.
  4. Um Viertel vor eins essen wir mit Oma im Café am Hafen.
  5. Um halb drei fahren wir mit dem Schiff um den See.
  6. Um Viertel nach vier sehen wir die Otter im Tierpark.
  7. Der letzte Bus fährt um Viertel vor sechs ab.

Seven sentences (five were asked for). When a sentence starts with the time, the verb comes second and the subject third: Um halb drei fahren wir. The separable verbs split correctly: kommen ... an, fährt ... ab. Sentence 1 follows time, manner, place (um 8:40 Uhr, mit dem Bus, nach Ellernsee). Von ... bis ... is used once and four times are written in words. Evidences criterion 6.

If you finish early: answers

Cost for one young person: castle 4,00 € + zoo 5,50 € + boat 7,00 € = 16,50 €. Change from 20 €: 3,50 €. (The guided tour is included in the castle ticket.)

A 15:00 tour ends at 15:45, and the 20-minute walk reaches the harbour at 16:05. Boarding closes 5 minutes before departure, at 16:00, so you miss the 16:05 boat.

Why this response is secure