Worked example · Music · Year 11

Planning a reflective log for a composing brief

LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context

What this is

A secure Year 11 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key for the sort. Intention: N1. Decisions: N2, N3, N5, N8, N13. Feedback and testing: N6, N7, N9, N11, N12, N14. Evaluation: N15, N16, N17, N18. Leave out: N4, N10, N19. Accept N14 under evaluation and N8 under feedback if the pupil gives a reason. Practice only, not NEA work.

Step 1: sort the notes

SectionNotesWhy
A. IntentionN1the feeling he wanted, taken from the brief
B. Decisions and reasonsN2, N3, N5, N8, N13metre, key, instruments and tune, each with a reason
C. Feedback and testingN6, N7, N9, N11, N12, N14each comment or test, then what he changed
D. EvaluationN15, N16, N17, N18checks against the brief, doubts and next steps
Leave outN4, N10, N19about headphones, a bus and a file name: nothing to do with the music

Organising by purpose puts related ideas together, so the reader sees each decision with its reason and its result. Session order would split the whistle story across 3 sessions and bury the evaluation at the end of a diary.

Selects and rejects notes for a reason, and explains why purpose beats time order for this reader. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.

Step 2: topic sentences

A. My aim was to write a calm but adventurous theme that makes listeners feel they are setting off along the Welsh coast.

B. I made my main musical choices to create that mood.

C. Feedback and testing then changed the piece a lot.

D. The final version meets the brief, although I am less sure about one point.

Each sentence states the point of its paragraph, and B, C and D refer back to earlier ideas (“that mood”, “then”, “the final version”), which starts to link the log. Evidences criterion 3.

Step 3: paragraph plan

 Evidence and reasonsLink
Abrief: 90 secs, calm but adventurous, Welsh hint, space for voice; aim: bright morning on the coast path“to create that mood”
B6/8 rocks like waves; D major bright; harp; pentatonic whistle = traditional; frame drum builds ending“then changed”
CMrs Pryce: whistle fights voice → out of middle; Carys: horror film → Bm to G; phone: drone vanished → up an octave + guitar; 108 secs → cut 8 bars“The final version”
D92 secs within 85 to 95; 16-sec intro, quiet middle, D chord ending, no fade; doubt about Welsh feel; real harp“Overall …”

Short notes, not sentences, with exact evidence in every row and a planned link between paragraphs. Evidences criterion 4.

Step 4: the reflective log

The brief asked for a 90-second theme for the podcast Ar y Llwybr that felt calm but adventurous, had a hint of Welsh traditional music and left space for the presenter. My aim was to make listeners feel as if they were setting off along the coast path on a bright morning.

I made my main choices to create that mood. I chose 6/8 because its two lilting beats in a bar rock like waves. D major, with harp arpeggios, sounds bright and open, and I wrote a tin whistle tune on a 5-note pentatonic scale so that it would sound traditional. A soft frame drum builds the ending to its last chord.

Feedback and testing then changed the piece a lot. Mrs Pryce warned that the whistle would fight the presenter’s voice, so I took it out of the middle and kept only harp and soft strings. Carys said the opening sounded like a horror film, so I changed the B minor chord in bar 2 to G major, which made it brighter. On my phone, the low cello drone vanished, so I moved it up an octave and added guitar. My first version lasted 108 seconds, so I cut 8 repeated bars.

The final version meets the brief. It lasts 92 seconds, within the 85 to 95 allowed. The 16-second introduction, the quiet middle and the ending on a big D major chord, with no fade, match the structure. However, I am less sure about the Welsh feel, although Mrs Pryce thinks the pentatonic tune and harp achieve it. Overall, the theme does its job; with more time, I would record a real harp.

About 275 words in 4 linked paragraphs. Each decision has a reason tied to the brief; each piece of feedback is followed by the change it caused; the evaluation checks length, structure, mood, Welsh feel and phone listening, admits a doubt and ends with a precise conclusion. Evidences criteria 3, 5 and 6.

Step 5: check

All 5 boxes ticked. Improved sentence: “I changed a chord” became “I changed the B minor chord in bar 2 to G major, which made the opening brighter.”

The improvement adds exact detail and a result, which is what the reader needs. Evidences criterion 5.

If you finish early: answers

Why this response is secure