Worked example · Music · Year 11
LNF: Literacy → Writing → Planning and organising for different purposes, audiences and context
A secure Year 11 response, annotated so you can see which success criterion each part meets. It is also the answer key for the sort. Intention: N1. Decisions: N2, N3, N5, N8, N13. Feedback and testing: N6, N7, N9, N11, N12, N14. Evaluation: N15, N16, N17, N18. Leave out: N4, N10, N19. Accept N14 under evaluation and N8 under feedback if the pupil gives a reason. Practice only, not NEA work.
| Section | Notes | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A. Intention | N1 | the feeling he wanted, taken from the brief |
| B. Decisions and reasons | N2, N3, N5, N8, N13 | metre, key, instruments and tune, each with a reason |
| C. Feedback and testing | N6, N7, N9, N11, N12, N14 | each comment or test, then what he changed |
| D. Evaluation | N15, N16, N17, N18 | checks against the brief, doubts and next steps |
| Leave out | N4, N10, N19 | about headphones, a bus and a file name: nothing to do with the music |
Organising by purpose puts related ideas together, so the reader sees each decision with its reason and its result. Session order would split the whistle story across 3 sessions and bury the evaluation at the end of a diary.
Selects and rejects notes for a reason, and explains why purpose beats time order for this reader. Evidences criteria 1 and 2.
A. My aim was to write a calm but adventurous theme that makes listeners feel they are setting off along the Welsh coast.
B. I made my main musical choices to create that mood.
C. Feedback and testing then changed the piece a lot.
D. The final version meets the brief, although I am less sure about one point.
Each sentence states the point of its paragraph, and B, C and D refer back to earlier ideas (“that mood”, “then”, “the final version”), which starts to link the log. Evidences criterion 3.
| Evidence and reasons | Link | |
|---|---|---|
| A | brief: 90 secs, calm but adventurous, Welsh hint, space for voice; aim: bright morning on the coast path | “to create that mood” |
| B | 6/8 rocks like waves; D major bright; harp; pentatonic whistle = traditional; frame drum builds ending | “then changed” |
| C | Mrs Pryce: whistle fights voice → out of middle; Carys: horror film → Bm to G; phone: drone vanished → up an octave + guitar; 108 secs → cut 8 bars | “The final version” |
| D | 92 secs within 85 to 95; 16-sec intro, quiet middle, D chord ending, no fade; doubt about Welsh feel; real harp | “Overall …” |
Short notes, not sentences, with exact evidence in every row and a planned link between paragraphs. Evidences criterion 4.
The brief asked for a 90-second theme for the podcast Ar y Llwybr that felt calm but adventurous, had a hint of Welsh traditional music and left space for the presenter. My aim was to make listeners feel as if they were setting off along the coast path on a bright morning.
I made my main choices to create that mood. I chose 6/8 because its two lilting beats in a bar rock like waves. D major, with harp arpeggios, sounds bright and open, and I wrote a tin whistle tune on a 5-note pentatonic scale so that it would sound traditional. A soft frame drum builds the ending to its last chord.
Feedback and testing then changed the piece a lot. Mrs Pryce warned that the whistle would fight the presenter’s voice, so I took it out of the middle and kept only harp and soft strings. Carys said the opening sounded like a horror film, so I changed the B minor chord in bar 2 to G major, which made it brighter. On my phone, the low cello drone vanished, so I moved it up an octave and added guitar. My first version lasted 108 seconds, so I cut 8 repeated bars.
The final version meets the brief. It lasts 92 seconds, within the 85 to 95 allowed. The 16-second introduction, the quiet middle and the ending on a big D major chord, with no fade, match the structure. However, I am less sure about the Welsh feel, although Mrs Pryce thinks the pentatonic tune and harp achieve it. Overall, the theme does its job; with more time, I would record a real harp.
About 275 words in 4 linked paragraphs. Each decision has a reason tied to the brief; each piece of feedback is followed by the change it caused; the evaluation checks length, structure, mood, Welsh feel and phone listening, admits a doubt and ends with a precise conclusion. Evidences criteria 3, 5 and 6.
All 5 boxes ticked. Improved sentence: “I changed a chord” became “I changed the B minor chord in bar 2 to G major, which made the opening brighter.”
The improvement adds exact detail and a result, which is what the reader needs. Evidences criterion 5.